用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 談幼稚園 培正 vs. 民生, any advice please?
查看: 2192|回覆: 39
go

培正 vs. 民生, any advice please?

Rank: 1


22
發表於 09-1-10 23:17 |顯示全部帖子
Both Pui Ching (am) and Munsang (am) accepted my daughter.  How to choose?  Please give some advice.


309
發表於 09-1-11 02:25 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1112
發表於 09-1-11 14:31 |顯示全部帖子
I will choose Pui Ching, it is because I think we need to think long-term prospect for choosing one-dragon school and Pui Ching Secondary School is more famous than MC

Rank: 1


22
發表於 09-1-11 16:25 |顯示全部帖子
傻BB & lcyaa

Thanks for the advice.  PC is in fact our 1st choice.  But Munsang seems to be a good one too.  So, still have a dilemma in making the final decision.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2516
發表於 09-1-11 19:30 |顯示全部帖子
或者你可以考慮吓英中同中中既問題
因為呢個係我無報到培正的原因
不過我而家都比政府個咩彈性班搞到一頭煙

其實你小朋友已經好叻呢
本人覺得二間都係好學校
努力呀 ^.^


原帖由 natbaba 於 09-1-11 16:25 發表
傻BB & lcyaa

Thanks for the advice.  PC is in fact our 1st choice.  But Munsang seems to be a good one too.  So, still have a dilemma in making the final decision.

Rank: 1


22
發表於 09-1-11 21:57 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 michellebaby 於 09-1-11 19:30 發表
或者你可以考慮吓英中同中中既問題
因為呢個係我無報到培正的原因
不過我而家都比政府個咩彈性班搞到一頭煙

其實你小朋友已經好叻呢
本人覺得二間都係好學校
努力呀 ^.^


...


Thank you!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


412
發表於 09-1-11 23:02 |顯示全部帖子
我也煩同一問題. 不過多數也會去培正交留位費, 用多3個月時間去考慮, 費時後悔.

原帖由 natbaba 於 09-1-11 21:57 發表


Thank you!

Rank: 1


22
發表於 09-1-11 23:07 |顯示全部帖子
Right, I will do the same.

原帖由 dora611 於 09-1-11 23:02 發表
我也煩同一問題. 不過多數也會去培正交留位費, 用多3個月時間去考慮, 費時後悔.

Rank: 2


57
發表於 09-1-12 00:40 |顯示全部帖子
近期睇了好多關於培正及民生, 邊間好?
因這兩間都係一條龍, 多數會一齊報.
而我都報了此兩間.    我都好煩惱.

培正係好學校, 品德好, 而成績亦不俗, 英文成績出來也不差, 全部都正面, 好好評價. 但...好多人都好擔心, 因為係中文中學
反而, 民生讚壞都有.

而我就考慮到:
1)環境...個人覺得民生環境無得彈, 培正就太舊
2)名聲...培正出名過民生
3)師資...吾知道.
4)教學...都係吾知道. 培正好多讚揚, 但就用自己一套
5)中/英中學...雖然培正英文成績出來不差, 但考慮到課本是中文, 就有問題. 數學, 會計 etc...點可能是中文. 對上大學及出來做事, 會好難理解. eg:"Acount Payable"即"應付未付賬" (好似係咁解). 上當年我老豆就係用這些中文名稱問我一D關於會計上的問題, 我即時O咀. 這不是關係到英文的寫講睇.

[ 本帖最後由 LoLoLoLo 於 09-1-12 00:42 編輯 ]

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46104
發表於 09-1-12 00:46 |顯示全部帖子
Just watched from a TVB news two nights ago, Pui Ching's classes are conducted in Cantonese but the text books are all in English.

I think I have changed my thought about Pui Ching, because my secondary school use the same teaching method during F.1-F.5 also, and I think it is a pretty effective way.

Frankly, if books are in Chinese, it's unacceptable in a global society like HK!

Rank: 4


842
發表於 09-1-12 10:06 |顯示全部帖子
I just called PC Middle School to ask:
All F1-3,  all books in Chinese, and teach in Chinese,

For higher form, for science stream, books in eng, for Art stream, all book in Chinese, 3 classes for science and 3 for Art, that why go into Science is rather competitive.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4555
發表於 09-1-12 10:10 |顯示全部帖子
若是培正跟民生. 唯有選培小. 到升中時再選英中. 民生除了是英中的名外. 好像由名氣, 校風, 成績也是培正較好.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


186
發表於 09-1-12 10:53 |顯示全部帖子
屬個人小小意見:
環境問題:
民生外觀確實不錯,但內裹都舊舊地(不境都歷史尤久)
培正由於校友多捐款足,内部設施不斷更新及加置
新建中的教育大樓有排舞室、體育館等.。。。。
英中與中中:
老實説,十年後的事,我們的政府可能已作多九次微調
及三次大調了。
由於當年從民/培揀了培幼,現是培正家長,有偏見架,
不喜勿罵!


原帖由 LoLoLoLo 於 09-1-12 00:40 發表
近期睇了好多關於培正及民生, 邊間好?
因這兩間都係一條龍, 多數會一齊報.
而我都報了此兩間.    我都好煩惱.

培正係好學校, 品德好, 而成績亦不俗, 英文成績出來也不差, 全部都正面, 好好評價. 但...好多 ...

Rank: 3Rank: 3


164
發表於 09-1-12 14:22 |顯示全部帖子
如果培正收我就會揀培正. (好可惜唔收.) 因為好似d comments postive 啲. 民生就聽聞德行麻麻. (但民生收咗我阿仔) 所以我都唔知好唔好俾小朋友讀.


314
發表於 09-1-12 14:33 |顯示全部帖子
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 3Rank: 3


161
發表於 09-1-12 16:27 |顯示全部帖子
have a question about the band 1 % of the primary school.  I just find Pui Ching has only about 50% band 1 students, while Munsang has less than 50%.

On the other hand, I find there are many of the local schools (not famous) do have 5x - 60% band 1 students, not mentioning their peer school at kowloon tong, 九龍禮賢學校 which is over 70%, and 九龍塘宣道小學 is over 80%.  

My question is :
1. If then, why do we have to go these 2 schools in any means (presume many of the families live quite far away from the school) ?  

2. On the other hand, it's very likely that their secondary school will become the DSS school, meaning that we have to pay school fees for 12 years.  Is that really worth ?

3. They do not allow students to join the lucky draw for P1. That means, we have limited our choices to their primary school.

Hope anyone can answer me.  Thanks !

Rank: 3Rank: 3


202
發表於 09-1-12 17:51 |顯示全部帖子
I am one of those who prefer MSC than PC.  In the old school days, the best primary school graduates (for Kln city net) would go to LS/MCS, the second best will go to MSC and Holy Family, PC is a rare choice.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2516
發表於 09-1-13 10:19 |顯示全部帖子
民生啲德行麻麻嗎 ?
有冇啲咩 link or sample? 我想了解多些啊
因為收了我的小朋友
而家亦打算就讀民生幼稚園
想了解多些呢 thanks.

原帖由 莊生bb 於 09-1-12 14:22 發表
如果培正收我就會揀培正. (好可惜唔收.) 因為好似d comments postive 啲. 民生就聽聞德行麻麻. (但民生收咗我阿仔) 所以我都唔知好唔好俾小朋友讀.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


164
發表於 09-1-13 11:38 |顯示全部帖子
我個朋友她在教會事俸, 所以有機會接觸到該校學生(相信是幾個吧!). 她就說她們很世界女. 跟住我就無多問了. 不過, 2月17日民生有活動, 我都會去再觀察吓, 再決定.

原帖由 michellebaby 於 09-1-13 10:19 發表
民生啲德行麻麻嗎 ?
有冇啲咩 link or sample? 我想了解多些啊
因為收了我的小朋友
而家亦打算就讀民生幼稚園
想了解多些呢 thanks.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2516
發表於 09-1-13 14:35 |顯示全部帖子
我到時都會帶埋小朋友去呀
你會上午去定下午去 ?

我交留位費o固日見啲小朋友好有禮貌咁同畫畫老師say bye 呢~ 等我 17 號去時再觀察多啲先 ^^

原帖由 莊生bb 於 09-1-13 11:38 發表
我個朋友她在教會事俸, 所以有機會接觸到該校學生(相信是幾個吧!). 她就說她們很世界女. 跟住我就無多問了. 不過, 2月17日民生有活動, 我都會去再觀察吓, 再決定.

...