聖約瑟小學與香港華仁小學

麟媽媽

我朋友的兒子在St. Joseph讀緊小一，9月升小二了。佢唔覺得太多功課，佢個仔都可以在佢放工返屋企之前自己完成功課。我朋友反而覺得壓力不是來自學校，而是來自家長，因家長們都知升中時只收得少過一半學生，所以有D家長迫得小朋友好犀利，咁小朋友實覺辛苦的。

東京mewmew

麟媽媽 寫道:
因家長們都知升中時只收得少過一半學生，所以有D家長迫得小朋友好犀利，咁小朋友實覺辛苦的。

完全同意, 因為我老公個fd未移民之前, 佢個仔都係讀呢間學校, 佢個仔讀到無心機, 於是一家最後移民去左加拿大, 個仔係加拿大讀書讀得都幾開心

至於我就比較鍾意華仁, 因為校風好, 教出黎D小朋友好gentleman

kpw

但係有傳港華中學成績大不如前，朋友叫我個仔考DBS或Lasalla 好Ｄ。希望大家多俾意見。
謝

paeds

as you said "有傳", actually a lot of the postings in BK are only parents 'hearing from here and there' and some even by 'guessing'. It's true that some schools public result may not be as high as expected for a prestigious school (eg how many 10As, 9As etc) but the most important is the overall standard and the quality of vast majority of their students.
I personally don't know exactly about the teaching of the above 2 schools, but how can you judge the standard of these schools? by their career?i can tell you that all these top notch schools produced lots of professions eg lawyer, doctor, accountant, engineer, consultant, you name it.
Most important is your personal likings and the feeling towards the school. You must have one that you prefer towards the other!
Full support to the child towards the chosen school is very important!
God bless :(

paeds

kpw, Do you really want your child to travel all the way from HK island to Kowloon Tong everyday? I admit that some schools are more 'famous' than others, but i think travelling time is also a very important factor.

kpw 寫道:
但係有傳港華中學成績大不如前，朋友叫我個仔考DBS或Lasalla 好Ｄ。希望大家多俾意見。
謝

hi123

香港華仁書院，去年有13位尖子同學入大學，即唔駛考A-level，讀大學。(參考中學概覽http://www.hkedcity.net/school/ssp/detail/sch_remarks.phtml?sch_id=1585 )
如果成績不是太差的話，這校設有多項獎學金，供出國留學或留港讀大學都用得着。(參考這校網站的download column)

kpw

My son is studing in Nursery class and  we plan to move to HK island later. Actually, because of this plan, my daughter will move to new scholl in HK island. I just got confirmation from Marymont for my Daughter's P2 admission. so far so good.

kpw

Hi 123,

The info. make me frastruate a bit. Information come from our family's good friend and they are also Band 1 secondary  school's senior staff.

I will keep an eye on it.

麟媽媽

其實St. Joseph同華仁小學都是很好的小學，讀到邊一間都不錯喇，尤其華仁仲要分上、下午校，一晝得兩班咁少位，派到真係好好彩！
我都識幾多人讀呢兩間小學/中學的(而家讀緊同埋畢左業N咁多年的)，有個奇怪現象，St. Joseph出黎的外表比較醒目、談吐風趣又招招積積咁，但又不會令人生厭、黑人憎個種喇…而華仁出黎的比較”土”，但個個都好有修養、謙謙君子。前排我到過華仁小學，當時是小息，個個小朋友跑來跑去係度玩，但跑到我身邊，那男孩便停下來，跟我點一下頭打個招呼，之後跑開繼續玩，我看他至多三年班，我好impress呢…
呢兩間學校既學生有一個共通點，便是對學校有好大的sence of belonging，呢樣野一定係由小培養出來，如果學校生活唔開心，又點會咁呢？

麟媽媽

kpw,
如果姊姊讀女校，弟弟便沒有了首名子女的分，而亦沒有了兄姊就讀必收的資格，我個好朋友都有呢個煩惱，她兩個女兒讀聖保祿，而家煩緊細仔如何，你又有無咩打算可分享下呢？可知現行的收生制度便是如此，St. Joseph、華仁、喇唦 (全是津校) 都要計分的，如果首輪失敗便要看彩數大抽獎了，住同區都仲望抽中，如果跨區機會仲渺茫….

kpw

如果抽到就最好, 否則, 香港島是傅統名校區, 可選其它私校亦司。我們搬家己是為了細路, 姊姊亦要放棄原先之學校，細路應無話可說。

麟媽媽

chelseawan,
你講得無錯，St. Joseph一級8班300人，升中收唔到90人，好多學生會升唔到原校。我琴日先同我同學傾電話，佢兒子在St. Joseph讀，9月升P.2了。她說同學之間分數好接近的，家長們都好緊張分數，唔keep住考全級80名內便危危乎。她兒子平均分九十五分以上都只是考全班12名，佢話兒子還需要加把勁…..小朋友自動自覺讀書考到九十幾分都仲未夠好，小朋友好可憐~~ :cry:

龍嫂

真係估唔到St. Joseph收番咁少自己人，印象中仲以為直升添。咁升唔番St. Joseph中學的小朋友，多數派去咩學校呢？

麟媽媽 寫道:
chelseawan,
你講得無錯，St. Joseph一級8班300人，升中收唔到90人，好多學生會升唔到原校。我琴日先同我同學傾電話，佢兒子在St. Joseph讀，9月升P.2了。她說同學之間分數好接近的，家長們都好緊張分數，唔keep住考全級80名內便危危乎。她兒子平均分九十五分以上都只是考全班12名，佢話兒子還需要加把勁…..小朋友自動自覺讀書考到九十幾分都仲未夠好，小朋友好可憐~~ :cry:

Sindy

照政府派位制度,升中一應該中學會收最少小學119人(85%)(當只得第二輪計)應該唔會得咁少架,請問仲有咩其他因素呢??thanks

麟媽媽

Sindy,
其實我都唔清楚現時升中制度如何，原校直升與外來收生比例有沒有準則？我只知St. Joseph中學得5班，小學有成8班，而上年是收不足90人的。
究竟制度是要收85%小學總人數，還是中學學位的85%要預留給直屬小學？收得咁少都是St. Joseph家長講的，有無人知道多D升中制度呢？

Sindy

係預留中學學位既85%,我睇過中學有200個位,當第一階段係有30%60人(我都唔知而家應該幾多)

(200-60)x85%=第二輪既位

因為當佢地中學第一輪一個都唔收返小學既學生,收晒外生,咁都應該有119個人,除非佢地band1&2夾埋都係得90人,其他全部都係band 3,因為只係band3佢地學校可以選擇唔收,唔係的話,係要跟政府個制度的,所以我唔係好明白,點解得咁少人,thank you

Zen

sindy

1st round 30%是否可以只收外校生？1st round 是幾時入表申請的？

聽講去年好似話得７０個可以直升．但我估尼個數字係代表band 1 生，一定可以直升，其餘的便是band 2 & band 3，要抽籤決定，所以最後可以直升應該多過７０人．

m1m1sam

"唔keep住考全級80名內便危危乎....平均分九十五分以上都只是考全班12名" ---- 咁我不如讀官小，讀北角官小都升到皇仁同金文泰播!

如果以300人計，即使收119人都係少，一半都唔夠。
我都好想知餘下180人升邊間中學？
莫非會去同區的'華仁"？

龍嫂 寫道:
真係估唔到St. Joseph收番咁少自己人，印象中仲以為直升添。咁升唔番St. Joseph中學的小朋友，多數派去咩學校呢？


[quote]
麟媽媽 寫道:
chelseawan,
你講得無錯，St. Joseph一級8班300人，升中收唔到90人，好多學生會升唔到原校。我琴日先同我同學傾電話，佢兒子在St. Joseph讀，9月升P.2了。她說同學之間分數好接近的，家長們都好緊張分數，唔keep住考全級80名內便危危乎。她兒子平均分九十五分以上都只是考全班12名，佢話兒子還需要加把勁…..小朋友自動自覺讀書考到九十幾分都仲未夠好，小朋友好可憐~~ :cry:

[/quote]