有冇人知中學部近年會考成績

andrewpapa

I don't think is a good idea, also, one year bad result can overcome other years of good results?

Will it be too over-reacted?

[ 本帖最後由 andrewpapa 於 10-9-17 15:44 編輯 ]

hogwarts

It is no doubt that Yr 08-09 was not a fruitful year for SPC's academic results.  It could be partly blamed to the not well prepared changes from subsidized school to DSS dating back to 2003.  However, the Yr 09-10 results did improve a lot.  Also, it is an on-going challenge to the school in how to balance the parent's demand of  good academic results & development of the boys' mind and body.  

As a parent of student in the current F2 year, I am content with what the school is offering and I have no reservation to recommend the school.

I would suggest to parents taking sometime to read the Principal's messages, especially the one about marks in early Sept.

funnyguy

原帖由 hogwarts 於 10-9-18 08:28 發表
It is no doubt that Yr 08-09 was not a fruitful year for SPC's academic results.  It could be partly blamed to the not well prepared changes from subsidized school to DSS dating back to 2003.  However ...

better tommorrow

jeremyphlam

原帖由 KOKOMAN 於 08-6-19 13:25 發表
有冇人知中學部近年會考成績?
聽說跌了很多，連一般區內英中也好過它?

Extracted from
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2230797&extra=page%3D1&page=1


中西區分析

中西區有9間官津學校, 唔係band1英中就係band3中中. 男校英中以英皇同聖若瑟較top, 上年聖若瑟14分有75.92%而英皇就67%. 高主教比聖類斯較好, 前者屬band1中(上年14分有61.45%), 後者屬band2頭(最後一次公佈14分有42.9%). 女校英中以英華同聖士提反較top, 聖士提反上年14分有79.1%, 而英華就冇資料. 但係英華係中西區女生首選, 相信命運同英皇差不多, 會考14分估計都係6x%, 聖嘉勒屬band1尾.

第一階段中六收生, 聖嘉勒中五約157人, 中六有84個位, 結果有5個位剩, 即是有79人夠14分(如果全部原校升讀), 佔50.32%. 而英皇中五約192人, 中六有120個位, 結果有20個位剩, 如果全部人原校升讀, 就有100人夠14分, 佔52.08%. 但係我相信有唔少英皇仔走咗去第二間讀. 整體14分既比例應該同上年差唔多, 都係6x%咁上下. 不過我地唔可以只睇14分既比例, 優良數目都好重要.

Band3中中有2間, 聖士提反堂同梁銶琚. 如果以所剩學位推算. 聖士提反堂14分佔13.13%而梁銶琚佔15%. 兩者似乎唔係差好遠, 但梁銶琚比聖士提反堂早收夠人, 相比之下梁銶琚比聖士提反堂好少少. 如果以我標準去評估, 呢兩間屬band3中.

中西區仲有兩間抽獎直資, 即係聖保羅書院同香港聖瑪加利女書院. 如果根餘額推算, 前者有13個位剩, 14分就佔46.39%, 不過睇番上年佢既學校報告, 有94.4%既中六位係原校升讀, 即大約58%, 所以佢係差過高主教, 但係都好過聖類斯好多. 至於聖瑪加利, 就有20個位剩, 14分推算係25%, 屬band2尾. 當然選學校(尤其是band2尾至band3), 校風都好緊要, 要自己去實地理解, 呢o的工夫唔慳得.

歸納上面既分析, 下面就係中西區學校既排位.

band1頭
聖士提反女子中學 (上年6科14分佔79.1%)
聖若瑟英文書院 (上年6科14分佔75.92%)

band1中
英皇書院 (上年6科14分佔67%)
英華女學校
高主教書院 (上年6科14分佔61.45%)

band1尾
聖保羅書院  (推算上年6科14分約佔58%, 今年46.39%)
聖嘉勒女書院 (推算今年6科14分佔50.32%)

band2頭
聖類斯中學 (最後一次公佈6科14分佔42.9%)

band2尾
香港聖瑪加利女書院 (推算今年6科14分佔25%)

band3中
樂善堂梁銶琚書院 (推算今年6科14分佔15%)
聖士提反堂中學 (推算今年6科14分佔13.13%)

andrewpapa

Jeremyphlam,

thank you for posting the finding from other thread, but i need to point out to you that secondary school has no banding catergory under EDB.  The banding system is for the P6 student to join the central allocation.  Official document per attached.

http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManage ... ents_100420_eng.pdf

If you want to point out the disappointed result of the secondary school, please only use the school report P24 to 27.  thanks

[ 本帖最後由 andrewpapa 於 10-10-20 01:29 編輯 ]

hogwarts

09 考試成绩不理想是不争的事实，但做了聖保羅7年多的家長，那一年不理想的成绩，正好是被用来不断提醒孩子要不懈的努力外，还要注意竞争之激烈与社会上不同價值覌间的互动。

虽如 DrBabyAlex 所言，香港不少 doctors 都是 Paul 仔，但我都有遇过 Paul 仔的士大佬 (但言谈中，他可能是车主)，大嘆当年读书不夠努力，今日要开车搵食。說到底有好环境、好師资，还要加上自己的努力才成。

其实本打算不再为此题目多言的了，但今天在 MTR 睇見一个 Hong Kong Museum of Coastal Defence 有关 British Army Aid Group 的专题展出之 poster後, 禁不住要写上兩句。

一如其他有長遠历史的传统学校，SPC 出了不少名人，在 wikipedia 的 SPC entry 中不乏在近代历史留名的风流人物。但今天 MTR 的 poster，卻令我想起一个，在我第一次上 SPC website 时，就使我有无名感动的人物，他的名字叫黄樹培 Wong Shiu Pun，他没有被放上 wikipedia 的龙虎榜，但你可以在 Stanley Military Cemetery Roll of Honour 上找到他的名字，在二次大战时，他因为身为 British Army Aid Group 的一员，被日本侵略军處决。如果你的孩子在中五时，能在宗教科名列第一，孩子就会拿到以他命名的奖学金。若我是基督徒，這可以是一個很好的理由要選擇 SPC。

作为非基督徒我认为孩子虽要榜样，不一定 10A 才是好榜样，但 Wong Shiu Pun 就是一个不简单的好榜樣。

Roll of Honour 上的简单記錄：


WONG, Volunteer, SHIU PUN PRESTON, British Army Aid Group. 29th October 1943. (Served as WONG SHIU PUN). Husband of Phillis Grace Wong, of Hong Kong. Sp. Mem. 1. E. Coll. grave 1.

有点長氣与离题，大家見笑了。

[ 本帖最後由 hogwarts 於 10-10-29 00:22 編輯 ]

tiksilong

I am an old boy from St. Paul's College. I would say traditionally the academic results were good not because of the teachers, but the environment and the quality of the student. During my time with SPC, SPC attracted very high quality student admitted into its secondary school, and the standard of the SPC Primary School student were very high.

During my time, the entrance rate to universities from F7 was very high, however there were still some student who scored badly during HKCEE (I know a few classmates who got 8 U).

I also heard a lot of people saying the quality of SPC has dropped recently but I am surprising to see only around 50% of student can get 14 or higher in HKCEE.

But I still have faith into SPC as my son was failed to get into SPC Primary School last year even though I am an old boy, which could mean that they are still very careful in selecting student. My son finally ended-up in another primary school but I am still planning to give my son a try to get into P2.

[ 本帖最後由 tiksilong 於 11-1-21 22:50 編輯 ]

JNmimi

hogwarts & tiksilong:  

感謝你們的分享, 讓我對 SPC 增添了解, 加強了信心!