拉小提琴的家長分享 / 交流請進

PaPa

原帖由 PaPa 於 08-11-10 11:37 發表
有朋友介紹了兩位小提琴老師﹐一位在演藝讀﹐另一位在香港其中一間大學讀﹐我想找他們給小朋友試堂﹐然後才決定要邊位。

我應否開門見山問佢地已達到甚麼級別？
我應該試幾多堂？
點樣決定要邊位？
...

還是去鑽石山國際音樂學校搵老師單對單教好D呢？

bebebe12345

原帖由 bebebe12345 於 08-11-10 12:33 發表


囡囡除了鋼琴，是否還有學鋼琴？

candytl,
再睇先知寫錯,其實想問囡囡除了鋼琴，是否還有學小提琴.

candytl

原帖由 bebebe12345 於 08-11-16 21:21 發表


candytl,
再睇先知寫錯,其實想問囡囡除了鋼琴，是否還有學小提琴.

bebebe12345,

我囡囡學咗差不多3年小提琴, 不過都係"為學而學", 同你的小朋友們不在同一層次. 因平時實在練得太少, 現時每月只上兩堂課, 遲啲恐怕為應付呈分試都要暫停.

candytl

原帖由 PaPa 於 08-11-10 11:37 發表
有朋友介紹了兩位小提琴老師﹐一位在演藝讀﹐另一位在香港其中一間大學讀﹐我想找他們給小朋友試堂﹐然後才決定要邊位。

我應否開門見山問佢地已達到甚麼級別？
我應該試幾多堂？
點樣決定要邊位？
...

PaPa,

如果不知其他情况下, 我會揀主修小提琴的那位. 每個人的做法唔同, 我係會直接問老師的資歷的, 例如佢學音樂的背景, 教學經驗, 學生成績等等, 雖然這些未必係好老師的標准, 但算係一項揀老師的指標.

聽講國際音小的老師質素唔錯, 值得比較下.

beetle

小女只學了半年小提琴, 老師就話升GRADE 2 , 要俾GRADE 2學費. (她剛完成suzuki book 1, 冇拉其他書), 收費合理嗎? Pls give advice, thank you!

beetle

Anyone know about the standard of SAR Philharmonic? My friend introduce me a violin teacher who is from this Orchestra.

aria

hello
請問大家
小朋友九月份開始學習小提琴..老師採用鈴木教學法.
大家覺得這教學法如何...可否分享意見..

因為老師沒有教看譜只是跟著cd一起練習,老師在課堂內教指法和拍子..小朋友聽著cd學習,練..好似有點問題..

rookiemom

Your girl must be very smart if she can finish suzuki book 1 in 1/2 year. Do you think she can play all songs very well? If she can, consider her as grade 2 is reasonable.

原帖由 beetle 於 08-11-18 21:23 發表
小女只學了半年小提琴, 老師就話升GRADE 2 , 要俾GRADE 2學費. (她剛完成suzuki book 1, 冇拉其他書), 收費合理嗎? Pls give advice, thank you!

rookiemom

My son also uses 鈴木 books, but 老師有教看譜. I think my son's teacher is not adopting the 'authentic' 鈴木教學法, but a mixture of that. It works for my son very well.

原帖由 aria 於 08-11-19 21:28 發表
hello
請問大家
小朋友九月份開始學習小提琴..老師採用鈴木教學法.
大家覺得這教學法如何...可否分享意見..

因為老師沒有教看譜只是跟著cd一起練習,老師在課堂內教指法和拍子..小朋友聽著cd學習,練..好似有點問題.. ...

beetle

rookiemom,

thanks for your advice. My gal is not smart and not talented.  I can only say she has good memory  . The thing I worry now is that her teacher is very young and very little experience in teaching.  I afraid my gal learnt wrong method and wrong posture. How's your child's progress? Pls share!

原帖由 rookiemom 於 08-11-20 09:07 發表
Your girl must be very smart if she can finish suzuki book 1 in 1/2 year. Do you think she can play all songs very well? If she can, consider her as grade 2 is reasonable.

PaPa

我現時都正在找一位有經驗的小提琴老師比我小朋友﹐有無好介紹？

beetle

PaPa,

I remember you're EC parents.  My girl is going to EC next year.  Do u live at TKO?  I found one teacher at HangHau. I'm going to have trial lesson later.  See if he's good or not.

原帖由 PaPa 於 08-11-20 18:32 發表
我現時都正在找一位有經驗的小提琴老師比我小朋友﹐有無好介紹？

rookiemom

Hi Beetle,

My son has been learning violin for 1 year and 2 months. He has finished 1/2 of suzuki book 2. Other parents told me the norm is 1 year 1 book, so I think your girl's progress is pretty fast.

Does your gal practise everyday, and how long? My son normally would practise 1/2 hr each day.

rookiemom

原帖由 beetle 於 08-11-20 13:25 發表
rookiemom,

thanks for your advice. My gal is not smart and not talented.  I can only say she has good memory  . The thing I worry now is that her teacher is very young and very little experie ...

PaPa

原帖由 beetle 於 08-11-20 23:09 發表

I found one teacher at HangHau. I'm going to have trial lesson later.  See if he's good or not.

Trial Lesson係點樣安排？免費or收費？
可否PM一些details比我？
如︰收費﹑會否上門﹑男or女老師﹑老師的qualification﹑大約年紀﹑家長可否一同上堂﹑…

Thx!

beetle

rookiemom,

Your son's progress is good! Suzuki book 2 is far more difficult than book one.  Apart from Suzuki, does he use other books? My girl only practise 20 min everyday....

原帖由 rookiemom 於 08-11-21 09:13 發表
Hi Beetle,

My son has been learning violin for 1 year and 2 months. He has finished 1/2 of suzuki book 2. Other parents told me the norm is 1 year 1 book, so I think your girl's progress is pretty fa ...

beetle

PaPa, pls check pm!

原帖由 PaPa 於 08-11-21 09:46 發表


Trial Lesson係點樣安排？免費or收費？
可否PM一些details比我？
如︰收費﹑會否上門﹑男or女老師﹑老師的qualification﹑大約年紀﹑家長可否一同上堂﹑…

Thx! ...

rookiemom

My son also uses Wohlfahrt.

原帖由 beetle 於 08-11-21 13:51 發表
rookiemom,

Your son's progress is good! Suzuki book 2 is far more difficult than book one.  Apart from Suzuki, does he use other books? My girl only practise 20 min everyday....

gabriela0407

各位前輩好,

請問有冇1/2的小提琴 和 少年篠崎小提琴教本第1冊 可送贈或平讓(其中一樣都可以).
請留pm, thank you.

candsmama

beetle and rookiemom,

I would like to find a Violin teacher to my 4-years old daughter. I prefer the teacher by using Suzuki method (mixed with other methods are also good). Please kindly PM me.

Many thanks
candsmama

gabriela0407

急~~1/2的小提琴


各位前輩好,

請問有冇1/2的小提琴 和 少年篠崎小提琴教本第1冊 可送贈或平讓(其中一樣都可以).
請留pm, thank you.