親子拼音班

Umi

NING'S MUM,

我問過佢地要190/半個鍾, 單對單, 都唔平喎...
不過, 我都想問下你個小朋友學左幾耐, 同埋半個鍾係咪真係足夠呢??  佢地話學晒80張PAPER,  都叫學完,差不多年半多左右!  你認為係咪OK呢??

係咪好多QUESTION 呢!! =)

Umi

thxs for your feedback!

東山語言中心

其實親子班, 最理想的不是單對單. 單對單一來貴, 二來沒有一個學習的氣氛.

單對單反而對小孩來講造做成一種壓力.  

KittyCandy

Dear Ning's mum,

Please pm the details for me.  Thanks!

zewellgar

各位Mama,
我相信Ning's mum 兒子上 phonic class 和我的兒子四年前就讀同一中心(it was located at Mongkok Road, right?).以下是個人經驗:
-一對一,$190/30mins是目標爲本的付出,若年紀太少,性格活潑的小孩會難warm-up,因進度是根據每堂提問,家課成績而推行(不背誦音標+練習只徒添壓力及浪費金錢)
-負責人Windy 亦對我表明這(phonic class)不是playgroup, they have conversation class as well but it's a diff. criteria.It's a result-oriented design.
-my son joint them at primary five(quite a late start)& finished the course within 10 months.
-he's lucky that the tutor showed her tenderness,patience (although he's lazy);
-in my opinion,children at primary2-3 is a prerferable age cos some school may hv phonic lesson twice a week, they hv the fundamental
concept --to Recite symbols and not for FUN.
-his schoolmate also join English lesson and found it's useful for brushing-up those hardworkers(aim to success ones).

Above is only experience from four years ago and not sure for any changes currently.The key point is to understand yr child first.

zewellgar

Oops, my son finished the course in 14months but not 10 months (80 chapters).
He also teach me the correct pronounications cos I'm studying IPA now. It's tough for an adult! HAha..

zewellgar

因見到BK另一篇幼兒拼音topic,容許我講些题外話--Native Speaker:

"好多語言中心, 只係標榜有native speaker, 但好多時老師本身的發音又唔正確, 而且老師經常轉換. 最慘的就係上堂的時候, 老師馬馬虎虎, 同小朋友隨便傾一兩句計, 其餘的時間就讓小孩自己玩玩具, 就是一堂."

我的老師亦感嘆家長認為native speaker=西人 的觀是一相情願,佢發覺他們不注重纠正孩子的錯誤,不瞭解亞洲人語言结構,有TESOL,IPA Dip. 又如何呢?e.g. 他們如何用中文向4-7歲小朋友講舌尖,舌齒音....有疑問的幾歲
小人兒怎能問?(溝通不到只做成不明白).况且歐洲言中Sweden語無 "sh"音, English 個字他們更需留意怎發音.他們愛自由無壓力生活,一聲去旅行、回國就走,學生剛熟络便要轉新面孔。(試想教統局Net Teacher 情况便知年薪去到$40萬都留不住)

Maggielaw

Please PM me also.  Thank You!

Umi

zewellgar,

咁我想問下你個小朋友學完之後係咪真係識自行拼讀呢?? 同埋你覺得那裡的導師好唔好呢?? 因為我打算明天帶佢去試下!

Masaka

Dear ning's mum,

Pls kindly pm me, tks.

zewellgar

HI UMI,

如果是小兒曾就讀的同一中心(at Mongkok Road junction with Nathan Road)的話,[親子拼音]可算有改革。課程資料充實,當年的tutor雖是 年輕的女孩子但確有才能,小兒可自行拼讀及他們有教導查字典。原來現可以試讀!?看過以後可否分享意見？

Kevin&Mama,
Frankly, for 4 years-old kids phonic group would be a better approach. You may consider using ready made teaching materials from bookstores(or search around BK chatroom) to understand the feedback from your kid. Those one to one class a bit harsh for them as the course cover 80 chapters.

zewellgar

ning'mun,

親子課程都喺$190/30mins(一大一小) 嗎？可惜當年沒有提供,否則我唔需現在自己學(常常自言自語!)
上堂時家長可提問嗎?教導過程中有特別之處嗎?

祝你們早日踏上成功之路,愉快學習。

Umi

今天我帶個女上左次堂喇. 但我個女唔係好喜歡囉, 可能呢一類型比較適合大年紀或者比較定既小朋友掛.  我個女仲流左第一滴淚, 話唔鍾意返呢度. 搞到我都唔知點算.....
係咪個個開頭都係咁架??  不過的確係比起letterland / jolly phonic 的進度係快的,  我個女上一堂都已經教佢ba, ca, da, fa, ga, ha , ja & ka.  都算快.  但講真就真係冇咩趣味性囉.  純粹係傳統既上堂方式.  我見個度d小朋友都係比較沉靜d.  唉.....不過我都會比佢再試多一陣睇下會否適合佢囉. 因為我唸條條大路通羅馬.  但我驚佢會對英文冇興趣囉.

zewellgar

Umi,

妳的回應正是我想指出的觀點:小孩的反應可影響度,所
以30 分鍾不會有唱遊,flash card.....以傳统方法教導全套理論及實踐。(並非提出任何批評,只想大家知道他們與坊間phonic class 理念不同,好有心理準備)

Kevin&mama
pls check pm. thanks.