明天IN埋學之園, 完成所有N班INTERVIEW了

sammilalang

絕對認同，我今日同囡囡去interview時，外藉老師講故事，佢又細聲，又冇乜表情，最慘就係，另一方有個小朋友喊得好大聲，老師又冇處理，令到小朋友分哂心，不但答吾到問題仲喊埋一份。唉！

super1984

腦的發展是要循序漸進的. 睇Discovery Channel, 講到那些早產嬰兒, 例如那些30週出世的BB, 有較大比例大過之後有學習障礙, 原因是BB本應在30週是活在媽媽肚裡面一個相對安靜的環境, 但早了出世, 醫院那些儀器對早產BB來說是嘈音, 或者BB的腦部都沒有發展到可以接受那些資訊, 你夾硬質俾佢, 咪變腦殘囉.

Hoho_baby

回復 porkma 的帖子

Wow porkma, we got the same situation as you. My son cried once enter the school and refused by teacher (ask him to calm down first) for twice. So we gave up la. No hope!

porkma

回復 Hoho_baby 的帖子

i was sad and i hit my son. I am a devil mum.......................................Very upset now.....................................

karenbabe

雖然我的小朋友沒有4圍走，但填問卷時我都不能專心地填，因為，除非在家，否則去別的地方時都會關顧著他，即使是如學校般安全地方，畢竟他只是個剛滿歲的小孩，這是做母親的責任。

我覚得討論區是用來發表意見既地方，發表負面回應不一定等於抱怨，正負面的回應亦有其參考價值。

karenbabe

不要怪責的你的兒子，小孩子喊有好多原，或者他不喜歡那環境。
記得我第一次跟兒子去interview時，他扭計不肯坐下來跟老師談話，最後失敗而回，一出校門我便責備他，他顯得很不開心，發呆不說話，後來幸好老公提醒我才想通，馬上tum返兒子，他即時笑返開心返。
小朋友很容易忘記的，你快點錫返佢

super1984

其實係唔係我地對小朋友要求過份左? 正常一個人, 面對一個陌生的環境都會不安, 這是人的本能, 幾千萬年的進化史, 一輪汰弱留強之後, 有警覺性的可以留低. 有咩可能小朋友面對一個新環境唔四圍望, 好奇心也是人的本性.

我個仔第一個星期返PN, 咪又係喊, 個個都喊, 第二個星期已經唔喊, 而家呢, 入到去, 自動自覺坐埋位, 同我講拜拜. 有咩問題? 如果一間學校, 收24個PN, 24個人第一日返學都唔喊, 我反而認為好有問題.

bumblebee_wong

LH 的要求實在太高, 我個仔琴日係HP果間足足成兩個鐘先放入出黎,! 好多BB喊既喊, 叫既叫, 周圍行來行去都有, 有O的仲訓左, 無論小朋友表現點, 有冇做曬指令, 成個INTERIEW 無喊我已經大讚佢! 因為連大人都忍唔到, 更何況小朋友?

不過大家又唔洗甘在意INTERVIEW 既, 我琴日見到有好多家長同老師SAY HELLO, 相信有不少位已經比左有BROTHERＯＲSISTER 既...

四隻貓

喊同唔喊都唔係問題，而係代表間學校想通過interview收邊類學生。
我覺得現在某些學校的要求是過份的，但我地可以點？考k1要求會更深，考小一既問題更深到高過小一程度。(有空可到小一選校看看），唉
當然大家都可以在這兒自由表達意見，這是BK/EK寶貴之處.

bobbili

校長有簡介嗎?  我昨日早上 interview 時校長只是走進課室就叫名交問卷 la, 也没有叫家長問問題.

bumblebee_wong

四隻貓, 好同意你既講法. 某些學校的要求是過份的
學之園收生要求好高, 不過亦有人覺得佢PN 係幫人教仔, 因為PN 入到既都係勁人, 佢TRAINＵＰ　左一年，　通常佢ＰＮ既小朋友就會走曬去名校或龍校。

豬嘜仔

原帖由 bumblebee_wong 於 12-03-10 發表
四隻貓, 好同意你既講法. 某些學校的要求是過份的
學之園收生要求好高, 不過亦有人覺得佢PN 係幫人教仔, 因 ...

Agree, k1 有好多學生過咗SC or KV

hoihoima

While we are claiming that the PN interview is very difficult and unreasonable, please take a look of 小一選校, som parents compared Primary 1 interview and PN/K1 interview and found that Primary 1 interview is MUCH MORE demanding and competitive.

k5itkyp

我個女in LV o個間，情況又冇其他家長講咁混亂 ...

1. 流程大致沒問題，但等候時間偏長，尤其是in校長o個part，大約等o左半個鐘，校長主要問o下家長對學校有咩期望，完全沒有向小朋友發問，只是用o左五分鐘左右，在場冇見老師比分，所以呢part都唔知有冇計分！

2. 有家長話interview內容比較深，我自己覺得好難講，她們做的都o係一o的好standard的問題，不過有o的問題對一o的PN小朋友的確係比較難應付，不過這都係一個過程，相信學校會因應小朋友的反應來評分，家長也不須要為子女不懂回答某些問題而不開心，只要小朋友表現應有的反應就OK la。

3. 講故事o個part如可安排獨立課室會好一點，因另一組的講故事聲真係會對小朋友有影響。

MattiesMom

I seriously think the interview arrangement is very poor and time wasting.  The school could of group the "Story time" & the "Individual interview" together rather than divided into two parts!?!?  Last part was even more ridiculous, the parent has to fill out a questionnaire with the child side by side in an exam setting.  My hubby said that totally shocked him!!  The exam setting gave others the impression that the school was totally strict - is the 2 yrs old going to write exams??  I have to look after my son which he was actually not feeling well and filled out the long questionnaire at the same time.  Where most other kinders will send out the form and ask the parent to fill at home and bring along to the interview.  At the very end, the principal asked all the interviewed kids to return and bring the form to her, she mus-pronounced my son's name,  The saddest part was she said to my son: "you can leave now!"  The whole interview process took 1 1/2 hr to 2 hrs and how can blames some of the parents lost patients at the teacher.  It was total disappointment despite all good comments on the blog.  Even though my son did quite well at the interview, we won't put him there.  

bblyly

interview既過程其實都係雙方互相了解。既然呢間比你既印象唔好，真係"佢揀著你都唔好去讀"，相信到時放返個位出黎，waiting list上面既媽媽會好感激你。

大約16揀1，講真唔容易

kitmantsoi

我仔仔讀K1上星期好八卦問过学校多唔多人考;佢地話今年比往年多好多人報·作為LH家長係開心既起碼多左人對學校認同·相信亦因為人數多左人流處理差左學校失預算· 我兩年前考流程一樣·所以好暢順相比起我考其他学校更順暢· 填問卷環節我都經歷过, 同大家一樣顧得仔黎填唔到·但相信學校可能借此環境觀察. 此校着重家校合作·培養的不只在學術更着重孩子心身成長;同時學校需要家長參與·要求家長同學校溝通·學校更会安全家長講座對家長係有要求.
其實大家想下安排三部分面試对學校容易D定求其五分鐘对話易D·一間有心既學校付出大量人力物力去做面試,老師們兩天內接待千位家長學生笑唔出可否值得體量? 他們是教育者並非酒店接待員! 我絕對認為LHLV老師們及校長好有愛心.

bubumum

Totally agree!!

ccwong101

Totally agree!  The school assesses students with various aspects in both Chinese, English as well as in individual and group setting.  Observing a student cannot be done by 5-10 minutes.  The last part of filling the questionnaire aims at observing the students to see if they can concentrate and/or love reading.  

To declare, as the parents of LHK, I totally trust and agree with the school.  The school really spends lots of efforts in developing their students.

In my opinion, having a right match between the school and the parents is very important.  Different parents have different preferences on the school.  

Good luck to all!