Dps vs yw

Sheep06

Monchichi110 發表於 20-11-27 12:19
讀YW (如果唔係AIM HIGH上神校) 使唔使外補?

識好多人 aim high 上神校都冇外補

winglam327

pckpck 發表於 20-5-5 01:34
試唔試扣dps好呢？
因為有細妹跟尾，想為細妹而試吓扣dps
但Yw 男仔讀就開心好多，佢自己都鍾意

想問一下yw出左offer了？

janesong

回覆 Sheep06 的帖子

early bird interview是在哪里看/？是学校网站里看吗

黃大力

YW sure

Sheep06

janesong 發表於 20-11-29 15:14
回覆 Sheep06 的帖子

early bird interview是在哪里看/？是学校网站里看吗

你指 DB early bird interview? 只有被邀請interview 的人才會知，學校網站不會公佈

黃大力

Sheep06 發表於 20-5-6 12:12
每年YW 成績好的 around 1x 去DBS, around 10佪  去 SPCC, around 6 佪 去 LSC ，已經 廿幾三十人 ...

咁條數好易計
英華頭30人，即1/5去了神校，其餘上英華書院band 1B

DPS頭十個入了DBS, 剩下的去邊，係咪全部有英華書院級數收？
如果自信個仔好叻，就去英華，做頭30名去神校，好過得一間DBS選擇，如果冇信心好叻，都係英華，確保點都有英華書院揸手。

janesong

回覆 Sheep06 的帖子

好的 谢谢

KT001

英華係中小，上堂或教材係咪真係全中文？咁英文會唔會比英小差好多？

b3410

KT001 發表於 20-12-4 09:31
英華係中小，上堂或教材係咪真係全中文？咁英文會唔會比英小差好多？

第一，英文只是小學所學的課程中的一個科目，還有其他很多因素需要考慮，例如其他科目學習情況，師資，課程，peers，學習環境等等。
第二，兩文三語來講，中文比英文更加難掌握。通常英小的通病係中文比較弱，而且積重難返，好難到中學再追返。如果出國留學可能冇所謂，如果打算考DSE就比較麻煩。

第三，英小英文好，中小英文唔夠好，係一個迷思。舉個例子，SPCCPS，喇沙小學，都係中小，不過冇人夠膽話佢哋英文唔好。或者，我諗除了男拔小，女拔小，其他英小應該冇人話自己英文可能教的好過SPCCPS。

第四，如果打算將來出國留學，最好的應該讀國際學校。不過，有時家長又想小朋友有一定的中文基礎，或者經濟問題，選擇英小，我覺得呢個情況可以考慮英小。

小結，英小是選學校的一個考慮因素，不過不應該作為主要決定因素。

ppmmbb

黃大力 發表於 20-11-29 20:36
咁條數好易計
英華頭30人，即1/5去了神校，其餘上英華書院band 1B

非常同意你的睇法！

但發現好多家長揀小學時只望上(可能大家都覺得自己小朋友唔會係最差那批)，沒有望下，如果6年後，小朋友的成績不幸地是Band 3 / 級尾，會有什麼打算？龍中/直屬中是否都保證會收小學部的學生？

黃大力

ppmmbb 發表於 20-12-4 10:01
非常同意你的睇法！

但發現好多家長揀小學時只望上(可能大家都覺得自己小朋友唔會係最差那批)，沒有望下 ...

所以好多人唔識計數，不論推算小朋友是叻個批，還是中遊，甚至下遊，都無可能不選英華，叻的可上跳神校，中至下可保1B名校，Dps叻個批反而選擇不及英華多(獨沽一味DBS)，中至下遊的就跌出英華級數以外選擇。
道理一字咁淺。

黃大力

KT001 發表於 20-12-4 09:31
英華係中小，上堂或教材係咪真係全中文？咁英文會唔會比英小差好多？

其實呢，一個小朋友英文叻唔叻，係同平時在家閱讀習慣更有關系，如果在英小冇回家閱讀習慣，英文一樣唔得，同時，中文水平也是如此。

honeybunny8

回覆 b3410 的帖子

"其他英小應該冇人話自己英文可能教的好過SPCCPS。" <--- SPCCPS English is probably just above average, at least in early primary years. It's hard to believe it's better than all other top-tier English primary schools wor...  

b3410

honeybunny8 發表於 20-12-7 15:41
回覆 b3410 的帖子

"其他英小應該冇人話自己英文可能教的好過SPCCPS。"

例如邊間top -tier English primary school? DG/DB已經話除外了。

honeybunny8

回覆 b3410 的帖子

From my observations, in addition to DB/DG, St. Paul Convent and Good Hope students also have very strong English language skills. I would imagine other English primary schools including Maryknoll and Marymount would also be strong in English.
To gain proficiency in a language requires much practice/usage, so naturally students at English primary schools would have an advantage. As most of their subjects are taught in English, and assuming the schools have dedicated sufficient resources to create a holistic English language environment, the students would be stronger in English comprehension and writing and speaking.

This is not to say that SPCCPS' English teaching is sub-par. I just don't think it's definitely superior to all other HK local schools other than DB/DG, particularly in lower grades. But the ultra strong Chinese program more than makes up for it. So it's a trade-off.

hfnyd

師資好重要，dps 出名太多老辰子，英華老師有愛心

b3410

honeybunny8 發表於 20-12-7 21:20
回覆 b3410 的帖子

From my observations, in addition to DB/DG, St. Paul Convent and Good Hope studen ...

呢幾間都係傳統學校中，英文非常好的學校。不過SPCCPS，唔會差過佢哋喎。大家都係一樣好，點解一定要分邊個更加好呢？

honeybunny8

回覆 b3410 的帖子

As parents we all want to make informed/educated decisions, so it is helpful to know, for those who consider English proficiency as high priority for their kids for whatever reason, that students at English-medium schools have better command of and exposure to English than students at Chinese-medium schools. It is not a myth but a fair point when comparing schools of the same caliber.
Since you used SPCCPS as an example, I'd say the school's English teaching is rather easy at the early grades (comparing my kids' homework to those of English-medium schools), but it might get harder during upper grades. Once piece of practical advice I heard from alumni moms, whose children finished SPCCPS and moved on to top international schools for secondary, that as SPCCPS Math's taught in Chinese, students who target international schools or studying overseas should get additional English / English Math tutoring a couple years in advance to prepare for entrance exams.

So, depending on what level of English proficiency the parents want for their kids, there do exist differences between English-medium and Chinese-medium schools, and the differentiation should not be generalized as a myth.

73662710

b3410 發表於 20-12-4 09:57
第一，英文只是小學所學的課程中的一個科目，還有其他很多因素需要考慮，例如其他科目學習情況，師資，課程 ...

You use the top one school in hk as standard for comparison!!!!How many Spcc or Lasalle in HK?
Moreover, their students' good command of Eng is owing to their family education, not from their schools.

黃大力

kaboBB 發表於 20-5-5 21:03
一定YW,DPS除了果十個位，其實一D都唔吸引⋯⋯

Exactly