聖羅撒小學家長

心心媽

Daisy媽咪

我個女話同Daisy好朋友喎,因為Daisy時常請佢食糖!

Daisy媽咪

係 ??? 我好少比糖佢帶番學校既喎, 不過新校車姨姨就成日比糖佢地 ! 你個女係咪叫 x心怡 ?

AmyWonglo

clanna,

How many marks do your girl have? 20 or 15?  If 20, for sure from past experience.  If 15, the chance may be around 50%.  But every year willl be different, can't really base on this %, if you are lucky, you can get the seat even if the possibilities is very low.  Right?  So, if you have make up your mind for St. Rose primary, just go ahead for it and the chance will be VERY high for St. Rose's kinders.

clanna123

AmyWonglo:
我個女是大女,唔知有幾多分,因第一次,完全冇頭緒,暫時計劃聖羅撒第一,聖家第二.第時個妹跟埋家姐唔使煩.唔知我的計劃得唔得.你個女是否讀St.Rose,請指點下我.Thanks

AmyWonglo

Clana123,

Are your girls catholic?  If yes, the eldest one will have 20 marks.  If not, then only 15 marks.  You can visit the EMB website to see the details.  
Click---> 小一入學統籌辦法

Under the current system, if your eldest one get in St. Rose, for sure the younger one can follow.

In the 1st round, you can only select one school.  No second choice.
  
Is she studying in St. Rose KG?  If yes, then she will have the chance for 3rd round.  If no, you can only try in the 1st and 2nd round.

clanna123

AmyWonglo: 我地唔係catholic.讀保良局幼稚園,好擔心派位派得唔好,會害左個女.所以我想round 1聖羅撒,round 2: (1)聖羅撒 (2)聖家.之後未想到.不過好多謝你的意見.

AmyWonglo

Hi, Clanna123,

我想可能應揀第一為聖家，第二為聖羅撒較好。因為聖家有第三輪扣門機會，但不知會否睇"誠意分"。不過聖家第一輪就好似15分機會不大。妳再搜集一下資料及意見先再決定吧！六、七月派位後應該有很多人上BK傾派位結果、扣門情玩等等。

祝妳好運！

Daisy媽咪

clanna123 寫道:
AmyWonglo: 我地唔係catholic.讀保良局幼稚園,好擔心派位派得唔好,會害左個女.所以我想round 1聖羅撒,round 2: (1)聖羅撒 (2)聖家.之後未想到.不過好多謝你的意見.

不用擔心, 我女兒都係讀保良局幼稚園, 不過amywonglo 分析得岩, 如果 st.rose 搵唔到, 佢3rd 只會留比佢kinder 個d.  我識兩個朋友都係首輪15分派左聖嘉! good luck!

clanna123

是否round 1 揀聖家,之後round 2 的第一是聖家,第二是聖羅撒.不過都好多謝兩位媽咪的意見.

vickycheung36

hi,

聖家是否34校綱

clanna123

聖家好似唔係34校綱,但是我又聽到有家長話好似下年34,35,36校網會合併.

AmyWonglo

Clanna123,

If you don't have any preference between these 2 schools.  Then, that's what you should do as this will enable your chance for 3rd round in Holy Family.  This is to play it in a safe mode.

However, if St. Rose is your preference, then, you can still try St. Rose in the 1st Round.  If you are lucky, you can get the seat in 1st Round.    And that's why I said about check from other BK parents if Holy Family will give you a chance for 3rd round if you don't choose them in the 1st round.

clanna123 寫道:
是否round 1 揀聖家,之後round 2 的第一是聖家,第二是聖羅撒.不過都好多謝兩位媽咪的意見.

AmyWonglo

scotia.nova,

It does not matter which KG you choose if you target on these schools because the entry of P.1 is base on "Luck" in the first 2 rounds.

However, for Heep Yun and St. Rose, they will have a chance for 3rd round for their kinders.  But, the chance for 3rd round will be higher in St. Rose than Heep Yun.  Heard from the BK that the chance for HY is very, very low for their kinder in 3rd round.

Lastly, please note that in this game, you can't be greedy in your selection.  If you don't select St. Rose as your FIRST choice in the first 2 rounds, they may not give you the chance for the 3rd round.  That's what we were told by the school.

So, what you need to think right now should be : what TYPE of KG you want to send your girl.

clanna123

AmyWonglo: 我完全明白,但我同老公唔想因為學位而受洗,因我地拜神的.家族係水上人.

cameo

如果協恩同st.rose相比,咁協恩真係少好多學位o架,可以上佢地個校網睇睇...因我女選校都係協恩round 1第一志願,若唔放佢喺第一,就完全無機會,放佢第一都好難抽得中~

vickycheung36

hi clannal123

現在已合併了, 是34 + 36 , 聖家是41.

cameo

scotia.nova ,
我自己覺得,點去揀,點去排位,真係好"個人",因為有媽咪會好著重學校"名氣",有媽咪完全以子女為出發點(例如先考慮活動教學or傳統教學,地區等等~)
我自問都覺得個女係適合活動教學多d,而一位好了解囡囡的幼稚園老師就認為小女較適合讀女校,但34網無活動教學o既女校,所以我只可以以自己準則去考慮,所以心儀的係協恩同st.rose,我都知協恩同st.rose的叩門機會太太太低,所以round 1選舊油天,萬一round2衰晒兩間,而呢兩間又無得叩門,咁真係好似無晒"目標"咁,所以舊油天係為round 3的叩門以防萬一吧~
我個人覺得協恩同st.rose喺成績同校風都好好,不過協恩學位少,所以在round2必要將佢放在乙部第一志願,而第二志願就係st.rose~~~
我知今年開始34網同他網合併左,其實可能相對更多人以協恩或st.rose為目標~我女係出生人口好低o既一年,所以填表可以大膽d吧....hehehe~