根德園`過來人'請指教！

bonnieandtung

非常同意ArgusMum的講法! 其實選幼稚園真的要睇家長對幼稚園的教學方式是否認同! 每間幼稚園都各有長/短處!真的最緊要小朋友開心地學習! 囡囡讀根德後真的做到開心地學習, 每晚都捉住我講今日學了些甚麼! 學了甚麼歌仔! 致於考小學, 相信每個家長都擔心, 其實只要小朋友本身有實力, 教甚麼小學都可啦!  

SauYee

My girl was in K1 in KV last year but now she's studying in a very common school.  The reason why I withdrew from KV was that she insisted not to study K2 in KV.  The teacher told me once that the whole class raised their hands when the teacher asked who wanted to study K2 but only my girl didn't.  When studying there, she's happy but I didn't know why she refused to go to K2.  When I asked her lately, she told me the teacher in K2 are so 惡 and she didn't like.  Don't know why she got this feeling.  One thing I don't like KV myself is I never met the headmistress for the whole year (I took my girl to school) and they didn't even have a graduation ceremony.

ArgusMum

Hi Sauyee
點解你囡囡會覺得k2既老師會好惡既??但你真係因為呢個原因唔比佢上k2?k1老師打比你同你傾呢個問題架?死啦,聽到你咁講,我都驚驚地我個仔第日會咁同我講tim..
不過話時話,我只係知道校長叫A.LEUNG,佢咩樣我真係唔知,我問過個仔,佢話校長好肥喎...
點解咁神秘既??
ARGUSMUM

SauYee 寫道:
My girl was in K1 in KV last year but now she's studying in a very common school.  The reason why I withdrew from KV was that she insisted not to study K2 in KV.  The teacher told me once that the whole class raised their hands when the teacher asked who wanted to study K2 but only my girl didn't.  When studying there, she's happy but I didn't know why she refused to go to K2.  When I asked her lately, she told me the teacher in K2 are so 惡 and she didn't like.  Don't know why she got this feeling.  One thing I don't like KV myself is I never met the headmistress for the whole year (I took my girl to school) and they didn't even have a graduation ceremony.

Clementmammy

Dear All,

My boy is studying in K3 this year. I face the same problem as you-My kid don't wanted to go to school in K1 but not K2, he told me that the teacher is so mad. Every morning is hard for me to make him get in the bus. When he came back from school, you can tell he was not happy at all.
I discussed with my husband and decide to change school for him around Dec. (At the end I found the reason why he don't like the school was because in K1 teacher won't give them candy same as playgroup. :

In K2, he is OK. He loved the teacher so much. May be the teacher look so kind (with smile on her face) and secondly he get use to the school.
In K3, he told me that he don't like to go to school again. May be I think K3 teacher is look serious.

Kids always change their mind. If they don't like to go to school was may be just the outlook of the teacher.

twokidsmum

我去面試和註冊嗰兩日, 佢哋都幾好笑答, 亦有主動同我打招呼, 所以我對佢哋印象OK架! 另外, 我見我兩個朋友嘅仔都鬼咁活潑, 佢哋話KV幾好喎!

乜真係咁差咩, 唔好嚇我啦!

PACMA

我仔仔而家在Kentville 讀緊K2. 我又從來未聽過佢話唔鍾意返學或者唔喜歡邊個老師喎! 有時佢病咗, 返唔到學, 佢都會唔高興, 話Miss xxx 會好掛著佢

Eva

我一心想俾個仔做大仔去插班REPEAT K3, 諗住佢地程度高D,唔駛浪費一年時間讀相同的課程.

現在看了大家的評論,有點驚訝又失望!

既然大家都說它的程度高,為什麼又會英文程度低呢? 難道程度高只是指中數? 現在我仔在很普通的救世軍讀K3,已經識自己用拼音讀D未見過的生字, 例如: FINISH, CHOPSTICKS ETC... 和一些句字,例如: MY FEET ARE WET. MY SHEEP IS WHITE ETC... 咁算唔算高,還是正常的程度?

其實是一位有個女在'女拔'讀五年班的朋友介紹我根德園REPEAT的. 她說'女拔'收很多學生都是讀根德的. 我不是想入'女拔',因為我個是仔來^_^,只是心想名校都收,應該程度同品行都唔錯.

她又說所接觸的同學仔中,大部份學習態度好(回家會自動自覺做功課的),成績好和自理能力高的都是根德園出品. 她還抱恕自己的女兒太依賴, 現在要放棄工作來訓練她.

她說,如果我想亞仔第日入名校如喇沙等,最好俾佢入根德園TRAIN下先,到時我自己會舒服D WOR.

依家都唔知試唔試好!?

pmamylee

其實只論學術程度,根德園不是傳說中的很深很深,比起現在一般採用活動教學的幼稚園,程度當然較深,但他們老師對小朋友的訓練確有自己的一套方法,如果想小朋友將來升讀傳統小學,根德是一個不錯的選擇,正如你說"成績好和自理能力高的都是根德園出品".

Bambi

以過來人講句:Your friend tell you the turth.
每間學校當然都係有好有唔好, 人地話好去到你身上都未必全部係o岩. 最後都係睇你aim在那方面, 唔係人地講2句就同你決定你仔囡條路喎. BK係一個好地方去discuss, 但'她'不是the whole world.

Eva 寫道:
我一心想俾個仔做大仔去插班REPEAT K3, 諗住佢地程度高D,唔駛浪費一年時間讀相同的課程.

現在看了大家的評論,有點驚訝又失望!

既然大家都說它的程度高,為什麼又會英文程度低呢? 難道程度高只是指中數? 現在我仔在很普通的救世軍讀K3,已經識自己用拼音讀D未見過的生字, 例如: FINISH, CHOPSTICKS ETC... 和一些句字,例如: MY FEET ARE WET. MY SHEEP IS WHITE ETC... 咁算唔算高,還是正常的程度?

其實是一位有個女在'女拔'讀五年班的朋友介紹我根德園REPEAT的. 她說'女拔'收很多學生都是讀根德的. 我不是想入'女拔',因為我個是仔來^_^,只是心想名校都收,應該程度同品行都唔錯.

她又說所接觸的同學仔中,大部份學習態度好(回家會自動自覺做功課的),成績好和自理能力高的都是根德園出品. 她還抱恕自己的女兒太依賴, 現在要放棄工作來訓練她.

她說,如果我想亞仔第日入名校如喇沙等,最好俾佢入根德園TRAIN下先,到時我自己會舒服D WOR.

依家都唔知試唔試好!?

moooon

我看了很多的 post，eg: SC vs KV, SC vs Heep Yunn, KV vs 培正, .....etc.

可能真如一句：樹大有枯枝（我是指學校的師資方面）。100% 保證？如果有的話，我都想知是那一間，即去---睇睇！

「她說'女拔'收很多學生都是讀根德的....」點解我反而聽說是收 SC 學生的可能性高些的講法？話因為 SC 出品，英文好些....等等因素，所以有成功率高些的講法。如果有人真的如此說，咁即是：唔知信那一邊講好啦。

honeybbb

我都從未見過校長, 真係好神秘, 我d朋友簡直唔相信我個仔讀左kv 3年都未見過校長, 因為而家好多學校校長都親民 [quote]
ArgusMum 寫道:
Hi Sauyee
不過話時話,我只係知道校長叫A.LEUNG,佢咩樣我真係唔知,我問過個仔,佢話校長好肥喎...
點解咁神秘既??

Eva

請問有無人答到我以下的問題呢(只有中數好??)?

其實我是因為聽聞它程度較深,接近小學,所以才打算去,否則去姐姐那間REPEAT,什麼校服書簿也不用買!

可是大家對它的評價很不一致. 可能真是講運氣,不同的班主任有不同的待遇,所以小孩子有不同的反應.

也有朋友說金巴倫的程度和英文也很好,但是沒有根德園收生那麼多,所以相對入名校的比率不及它.

反而SC就好小朋友提. 不過我個女有個同學是SC的,她成績只是一般但人有點驕傲和無禮,又不太自律,常常給老師口頭警告.  她的媽媽也是因為她太依賴,所以又不工作來看著她. 看來活動教學的孩子好像比較依賴一點啊!因為之前提過的拔率媽咪也因為女兒依賴而放棄工作在家TRAIN她的,是啟思出品的,也是辦活動教學出名的.

不過這只是我我身邊唯一SC的個別例子,不能一枝竹打一船人!

請問根德園有正規的普通話堂,電腦堂和外國人教英文嗎?

反正它也不一定收我個仔, 可能考左至算!

Eva 寫道:
我一心想俾個仔做大仔去插班REPEAT K3, 諗住佢地程度高D,唔駛浪費一年時間讀相同的課程.

現在看了大家的評論,有點驚訝又失望!

既然大家都說它的程度高,為什麼又會英文程度低呢? 難道程度高只是指中數?

maggie(r.a)

      

moooon

之前都有 post 過的事例分享一則：
我老公有個舊同事，他的女兒今年已是 KV 的 K3 學生，話說囡囡本來天真活潑，但自從讀了 KV 之後，因曾被老師當面罵過，之後變得「靜」了，父母當然心痛，還有點後悔選了 KV，所以前幾日，他也勸我老公說：KV 不太好...等等，仲有就是 apply 小學 all failed！我給這件真人真事，令到我憂心了好幾天。令我要諗是否要轉汰去 SC？

我自己看法！記得 N 年前，我讀幼稚園的時候，都有考試，老師都很「惡」！升讀小學之後，那小學的老師「更惡」，一個可能只是那日剛好她心情壞（我估），我曾被她失驚無神，問都無問地「一巴掌」摑我塊臉，原因只是我後面的同學聊我傾偈，我又應她....，小朋友而已，做老師的「唔駛咁呀」！咁，我會否因為發生了「惡」老師（或變態老師）而令我性格變成「沉鬱」？

或者都可能是年代唔同，現在的小孩子通常都很寶貝，生一兩個，點同以前兄弟姊妹八九個？老師惡？都唔惡得過屋企那兩件--亞爸亞媽。

其實父母都可以做個「中間人」的角色。例如我囡囡有次同我講，她很喜歡某姨姨，因為她從沒罵過她，但 Daddy 和媽媽有罵過她....！她有如此想法，當然要開導她，甚至要教育她正確的方向，要她明白「罵」不代表父母不愛惜她。

大頭玲

Hi Eva

Frankly, Chinese & Maths seem quite good in KV but English really not that good (compare with some famous Kindergarten nowadays).  They trained you very well in Chinese & Maths, like,  a lot of writings and a lot of maths exercises.  But English, the kids are trained to spell/remember many vocabs/sentences instead of knowing phonics to read themselves.  So, depends what English level you are expecting the kindergarten can offer to your kids.  For me, it seems not that adequate as I am afraid he might have difficulty to connect to English Primary School next year.  KV really trained the kids knowing discipline.  My boy is quite naughty, but still trained quite well now and is still a very happy boy as well.   
If you want to shift school for your kid, you ought to think it clearly.  Like he can adapt it or it's that really necessary??!!  Your kid might need to do a lot of writing in KV, how about his present Kindergarten?  Can he accept such changes?? etc....  So just think it thoroughly

alc

我認為活動教學真的會讓小朋友學得開心些,但因小女不是那些很有表現慾的小朋友,我怕她反而在活動學習中顯得被動,被忽略,反而傳統學習會讓大家公平學習.當然我會給她在外再學一些跳舞,畫畫等(她很喜歡!),讓她接觸多些不同的人和事物,培養興趣.學校是學習的地方,如果太過"活動",我怕她會不適應現實的小學.
我有朋友的女在SC K3,也是報考的一間也不成!我個人認為SC太商業啦,佢會標榜自己小一收生情況,都會幫家長寫推薦信,會教家長跟著她們所定的LIST去報小學(確保收生分佈),我朋友個女,讀咗三年,仍然一D小朋友MANNER都冇,去街食飯會捐落枱攪大家隻腳,在餐廳周圍跑,有客人到訪會躲著拉你的衣裙,直言說你到訪的朋友(大人)醜樣,我個人忍受不了這些活潑及自由創意.....我知SC是似國際學校式的活動教學,但又有幾多小學可以容許這樣呢?在推薦信中隻字不提她的行為,只會說是主動,活潑好動.....如果大家想學校會"幫"你的,可以考慮SC吧!但我又想,小朋友有樣學樣,大半班小朋友也這樣"活潑好動"又怎樣可以學習呢?

youma

請問根德園有正規的普通話堂,電腦堂和外國人教英文嗎?
Thanks.

JJ1122

有普通話堂, but what is 正規?  They sing songs only.
電腦堂, yes, just let them to know what it is.  but be honest  I hate 電腦堂 for kinder students.. what's for?  for short-sight?
外國人教英文-- NO

youma 寫道:
請問根德園有正規的普通話堂,電腦堂和外國人教英文嗎?
Thanks.

Bambi

睇黎妳幾唔鐘意妳個friend喎!

alc 寫道:
我有朋友的女在SC K3,也是報考的一間也不成!我個人認為SC太商業啦,佢會標榜自己小一收生情況,都會幫家長寫推薦信,會教家長跟著她們所定的LIST去報小學(確保收生分佈),我朋友個女,讀咗三年,仍然一D小朋友MANNER都冇,去街食飯會捐落枱攪大家隻腳,在餐廳周圍跑,有客人到訪會躲著拉你的衣裙,直言說你到訪的朋友(大人)醜樣,我個人忍受不了這些活潑及自由創意.....我知SC是似國際學校式的活動教學,但又有幾多小學可以容許這樣呢?在推薦信中隻字不提她的行為,只會說是主動,活潑好動.....如果大家想學校會"幫"你的,可以考慮SC吧!但我又想,小朋友有樣學樣,大半班小朋友也這樣"活潑好動"又怎樣可以學習呢?

HuiTung

alc 寫道:
我朋友個女,讀咗三年,仍然一D小朋友MANNER都冇,去街食飯會捐落枱攪大家隻腳,在餐廳周圍跑,有客人到訪會躲著拉你的衣裙,直言說你到訪的朋友(大人)醜樣,我個人忍受不了這些活潑及自由創意.....

呢d應該是父母教子女的態度.  我姪女也在SC, 但佢父母就乜都話要manner, 個女搶人d野, 話下教下咪ok lor!  點解要用"陰波功" "鵝"到佢喊 (係戚下戚下咁喊, 妳話佢幾"益壓"), 還可以講什麼活潑及自由創意?