祇選一問BRAND 1 ?

LAMLAMMUM

請問囡囡讀邊間?

LAMLAMMUM

STCCMC, 多謝你的提醒.
信靠主是永不移, 但神從沒有要我們甚麼都不用做.
所以我才在這空氣中,與各位家長交流資訊和心得! THANKS

virgokaren

stccmc 寫道:
virgokaren,
//最緊要記住如 BillyM 所言：BAND1學校也有難入與易入之分，如果頭五名(我保守d，五名好啦) 全是喇沙拔萃Maryknoll之流，因住慘淡收場。//
根據派完band 1 生才派 band 2 生的原則, 如果 band 1 生一味選band 1 學校, 一定會輪到, 因無 band 2 生爭。  那麼, 為何頭五名全是喇沙拔萃Maryknoll之流，因住慘淡收場?

stccmc：
你問我的問題，好多人代我答左了。

我補充少少啦！以我最熟悉的北區為例：
中學通常以英中最搶手，而北區英中只有三間，每間200個位，合共只有 600 個中一學位(未扣自行收生收左的學額)，但北區的 band one 學生共有1300人以上，如果每個人都以這三間英中作頭三個志願，結果也有55% 的 band one 學生落空，接下來便流入區內的 band one 中中 和 band 2 頭的中學了。
所以一個 sure band one 的學生，在此機制下應該最差也只是落在 band 2 學校之中，除非他的選校策略有異。(例如他只選 band one 中學，其他留空不填，咁....恭喜你！band 3 尾的中學等緊你。)

用以上的例子代入名校區來說：
假設你的囝囝，選擇頭六個志願順序是：皇仁(跨區)、喇沙、拔萃、華仁、英華、東華三院黃笏南、 華英，我估計如果頭獎唔中的話，二三四五六志願都是浪費。
好運的話第七志願揀間 band 2 中(唔太hit)個隻或者會入，因為你是 band one，點都會比 band 2 生優先派位。

【以上僅是本人之愚見，大家大可不必認同和認真看待。】

LAMLAMMUM：

Sheila 的分析也有道理，可能藍循往績不佳，派區內搶手的band one 中學人數不多，所以老師的建議會保守一點，因為學校也不想見到學生失望。
又或者如 stccmc 所說：the school want to have a high percentage of "First three preferred schools"。

所以其實每間學校、每個區都不盡相同，真的要小心選擇。

希望你囡囡一擊即中，入到心儀的學校！

lamba

Lamlammum,

the first thing is to confirm with your kid's teacher that your kid is really in BAND one before you can formulate your strategy !

your kid's teacher should be clear about that !

哈里波特

Lamlammum,

I understand your situation because I'm living in Kowloon East, this net only a few places of EMI band 1 school for lucky draw.  Last year, I have a friend who's daughter is falled into band 1 group.  She choose St. Catherine, but her daughter did not have even interview chance in round 1.  You know, a lot of other nets top girls also apply St. Catherine & St. Paul Lam Tin.  After that, she choose 1st St. Paul & 2nd St. Catherine for lucky draw.  Before result announced, she told me she made wrong decision because both of them are so top in Kwun Tong net, if 1st place loose, her daughter may go to "n"th place.  Her daughter's school also suggest her to take only one band 1 EMI in the 1st place & the rest choose CMI band 1.  Finally, she's luckily BINGO to St. Paul Lam Tin.

This is a solid case why student fall into Kwun Tong net is not advised to choose more than one band 1 EMI.  And that why I sent my daughter to Yau Tsim Mong studying primary school.

In fact, Kwun Tong net is very keen competition.  I know St. Cat & St. Paul are very good school but I do not have confident to let my daughter try these 2 schools in 1st round, even I think my daughter is good enough, but too risky.

哈里波特

藍循唔係咁差je compare in Lam Tin District. 倫理念, 會好過LSK.

Sheila 寫道:
LAMLAMMUM,

原來你囡囡讀藍循,唔怪得班主任叫你只選一BAND1,因為藍循往積不佳,我睇過去年派位結果,多數派羅陳楚思同基孝,認真麻麻,派聖言,觀瑪,聖傑靈,藍田聖保祿的只有少數

不過,你囡囡既然讀精英A班,全級考23應該都係BAND1,所以你不妨考慮揀聖傑靈或藍田聖保祿在第1位,梁式芝這類BAND1尾BAND2頭的女校在第2,咁就穩陣D啦!

純粹個人意見,只供參考,最重要係同班主任同囡囡商量下,因為你囡囡應該有心頭好,而班主任就比較了解學校與同區其他學校的質素,囡囡banding的問題及學校派位往績

祝你好運! 勿忘督促囡囡考好最後一次報分試呀!

  

sheila

tchownyc

vigrokaren,


  Re: 祇選一問BRAND 1 ?  
vigrokaren,

大家閒聊

tchownyc

華英是BAND1的嗎?

哈里波特

But you never know other parents how to approach the first 3 places.  This is not the same each year.  A ex-school mate of my daughter who put :
1st - QE (100 seats)
2nd - Marymount (only 5 seats)
She finally got Marymount.  In this case, we guess her random # is 排得好後 or huge students put QE in the 1st place.  Who knows.

tchownyc

哈里波特,
打中文!!
              

哈里波特

你唔知其他家長怎樣選校, 年年唔同, 看你命運.  有時得一個位, 係你就係你.  多與學校相量, 多參與BK吹水, 保証有著數.

tchownyc 寫道:
哈里波特,
打中文!!
              

BillyM

Wa Ying is a top band 1 school.  I have seen students (in Kln City) who picked Wa Ying as #1 and Wong Fut Nam as #2.  She got into Wong Fut Nam.  That means the number of students who picked Wa Ying as #1 is already more than what she can accept.  So, don't pick Wa Ying unless you put it as #1.

tchownyc 寫道:
華英是BAND1的嗎?

LAMLAMMUM

華英是藍循姊妹校,有機入. 但老何師唔贊, 說機會不大.  可能小女唔夠top

LAMLAMMUM

tchownyc,  請問若在第一輪選校, 我不著眼東九, 那區機會較大?

virgokaren

stccmc：

大家一齊研究下，三個臭皮匠可能會勝過一個諸葛亮，所以我經常上來閒聊架！

你所講【一個 band one 的學生最佳的選校策略】及【在A 組找二間填進第一二志願(比較進取)...】 ，我完全同意，這是個幾穩陣的組合。
我不是也舉例說了不要把一藍子搶手 band one 填滿前五個志願嗎？
如是我的話，我頂多都只會博兩個咋！
其實我覺得去到第三志願都好危險架啦！

我所指的"因住慘淡收場"是有點誇張，不過，你每年不是看到有名校小學生在電視畫面上哭哭啼啼，說什麼：派果間學校我都無揀過！
我相信他們就是過份進取，可能填埋跨區的 band one 學校都不肯填一個 band 2 的學校在他的志願內。

不過正如哈里波特所說，每一年的機數都可能有變，你的A 、B 組策略也只能大路的計算。
誰能預知今年的家長喜歡 QE 多點，還是 Marymount 多點呢？
以哈里波特提出的例子，對我來說，第二志願放一個只有五個位的跨區名校，可說是兵行險著，也正正是因為這個想法，可能沒人敢跨區博彩，所以她便中獎了。

所以我說每人的想法，每區的學生人數和學校 banding 都不同，要進取，要保守，自己衡量。尤其是要肯定自己的 banding，所以我強調是 sure band one 學生至好嘛！

tchownyc：

華英當然是 band one。
香港的 band one 學校何其多，有英中，有中中，有老牌名校，有新興名校......

哈里波特：

原來你是 living in Kowloon East，咁你會清楚d。
是否你也覺得這區選二間英中作第一二志願都危險呢？
你朋友一擊即中喎！有無其他例子呀？

哈里波特

我聽已畢業的家長說, 我校會有個統計, 但不會公開.  在未落實填上表格之前, 校方會看有多少人報某某校, 若有d band 2學生想try band 1 英中 but 發現已有大量band 1 生入飛, 佢會建議你修改去其他好的band 1 中中, 博一博.  That's why we need to follow primary school strategy.  The parent who put Marymount as 2nd choice that's also advised by our school.  Of course, final decision will be made by the parents.

stccmc 寫道:
哈里波特,

填志願時我們如何也要做些資料搜集, 推測, 問人等等。  何不有策略地估計?  

哈里波特

哈里波特：
原來你是 living in Kowloon East，咁你會清楚d。
是否你也覺得這區選二間英中作第一二志願都危險呢？
你朋友一擊即中喎！有無其他例子呀？
**************************************
My friend told me 全級第一名都係去梁式芝(中中), she also put St Paul Lam Tin as 1st choice.  Their school totally 4-5 students put St. Paul Lam Tin in 1st choice but only draw 2 from her school.

Another example :
My niece 全級第一名 in 聖馬太, a top primary school in Kwun Tong Net, 佢都等唔到放榜, 就入佐 St. Paul Co-ed.佢呀媽話don't want to rely on lucky draw.  同年全級第二名個同學, 都係抽到band 1 中中, luckily, 叩門入埋 St. Paul Co-ed. at last.

Kwun Tong net ----keen competition.  A lot of top students (like my niece who is also above average in St. Paul Co-ed now) in this net but they have no choice in 2nd round because not enough EMI for them.