聖方濟各 或九龍塘小學的決擇

Fishmama

原文章由 SandyWu 於 07-11-29 17:58 發表


hi gracechung,

同妳既case一樣,我都有間有英中既小學ok左,我又係一個好緊張阿囡既媽咪,kum我係咪應該選有中學back up既學校呢 但我又好怕埋沒左阿囡既潛力,妳點睇

謝謝

Sandy ...

Hi, Sandy,

我同你的Case 也一樣 , GHS收了的女囡囡 , 雖然有中學back up, 但我較like 男女校 , 而且聽說SFA英文程度比GHS高一些 , 我也不知點揀 ? 家距離SFA較遠, 要6:40am 上校車 , 我怕她太倦了 , I argee with Grace Chung too, Academic Result is more important.  If not, we will not choose KV, right? I think my girl will fail in SFA but she really got a place.  Would Sandy and Grace kindly give me some advice?

Cutema

原文章由 Siutakmama 於 07-11-29 14:37 發表


Cutema

咁想請問德育方面邊間好d,學生邊間乖?

S.T.MaMa

Indeed I have no idea for SFA in moral development.

From my past observation in P.1 to P.2, KTS quite concerned in training the student regarding good manner to teacher and class discipline. The teacher will also try to assign the duties to each student as class moniter, sub-moniter, 行長，科長....etc.

Peterfan

原文章由 gracechung 於 07-11-29 12:31 發表
真係好難取捨，呢兩間各有優點。但我自己來講，我會揀sfa，事關我覺得自己個仔係谷得，而幼稚園又過左幾年谷的生活，開左個頭，我會唔想浪費，所以條路會行到尾。

校網我唔擔心，第一，如果個仔真係谷得上，好多時1st round自行收生已經 ...

Now you say here you chose sfa and someothers thread you say yw? Do you have two son?
I think the school you want to go most is DB,but failed!

charwes

Based on Gracechung's previous message, I think she's talking about IF she has to choose from SFA and KTS, she would prefer SFA. Correct me if I'm wrong.

原文章由 Peterfan 於 07-11-29 20:57 發表


Now you say here you chose sfa and someothers thread you say yw? Do you have two son?
I think the school you want to go most is DB,but failed!

gracechung

我覺得你想聊交嗌，不過唔緊要，隨便你點講。
各位媽咪，我已經講過，我係跟別人的前設，代入自己的情況及邏輯來討論，好似一個case咁比其他人知道我的思路，等其他人多一種思考，當然，別人可以同意或唔同意，最緊要別人最後的決定適合自己！

呢個thread講緊KTS同SFA，咁我就在兩者中選sfa，再解釋我揀sfa的原因，咁有咩唔妥？既然有家長問我點揀yw/sfa，咁我咪再從呢兩者中選囉。

我份人從來唔吝嗇同媽咪/c9討論仔女，呢個係我在呢度出現的原因。早在大半年前有媽咪pm我問有某學校的問題，我長篇大論將我所知全部分享。甚至唔識的人pm問我KV的問題我都一一分享。

唔該呢位家長唔好阻住我同c9們搭訕啦。

原文章由 Peterfan 於 07-11-29 20:57 發表


Now you say here you chose sfa and someothers thread you say yw? Do you have two son?
I think the school you want to go most is DB,but failed!

gracechung

Bingo!!!
You are soooooo clever!

原文章由 charwes 於 07-11-29 22:38 發表
Based on Gracechung's previous message, I think she's talking about IF she has to choose from SFA and KTS, she would prefer SFA. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Peterfan

原文章由 gracechung 於 07-11-29 23:20 發表
我覺得你想聊交嗌，不過唔緊要，隨便你點講。
各位媽咪，我已經講過，我係跟別人的前設，代入自己的情況及邏輯來討論，好似一個case咁比其他人知道我的思路，等其他人多一種思考，當然，別人可以同意或唔同意，最緊要別人最後的決定適合 ...

But lot of people talk at your back say you like to show
off your son instead of just "share and talk"

Dont try to be representative of KV, many others boy have much better result in the interview and their moms are much more low profile.

Outsider might think you are so "helpful",  but your real intention is well known in lot of kv moms!

No need to tell people where to go for holiday and how smart your son is anymore,we known already..my god

SandyWu

原文章由 Fishmama 於 07-11-29 20:08 發表



Hi, Sandy,

我同你的Case 也一樣 , GHS收了的女囡囡 , 雖然有中學back up, 但我較like 男女校 , 而且聽說SFA英文程度比GHS高一些 , 我也不知點揀 ? 家距離SFA較遠, 要6:40am 上校車 , 我怕她太倦了 , I argee wi ...

Fishmama,

Hello, our cases are so similar.   If you think your
daughter is good enough and well prepare for fighting for more choices (good English Secondary Schools), you can try to consider SFA, otherwise, you can take GH since
two of them were traditional schools.  However, my
daughter does not like to study in Girls' primary schoo.  
So, I did not apply GH for her.

gracechung

原來你地中意背後講人架，真係唔講我唔知tim
唔緊要，唔同人當然有唔好睇法，自己係咩人，睇既世界咪係點架lor。
我份人一向都唔虛偽，有乜野照直講，不卑也不亢，如果你覺得我講既說話將你比下去，我誠意地向你道歉。對唔住。

可能我個心太單純，睇既世界亦好單純。我認為講下放假去邊係好平常，好多人都有講去過邊架啦。我亦從來冇話自己個仔smart，我反而記得我話亞仔講說話唔清唔楚，又唔識講學校的事比我知，而且無乜日常生活的常識。

好多KV仔女成績出色當然係好事，我好開心架，至少可以沾下光。唔通自己處身於弱勢圈子好咩。有冇聽過"雙贏局面"？水漲就自然船高架啦。我好喜歡"鄧"人高興。

一句到尾，KV老師們好認真教學，KV仔女好醒目又健康。
真係唔好意思，借左個位賣廣告tim

原文章由 Peterfan 於 07-11-29 23:42 發表


But lot of people talk at your back say you like to show
off your son instead of just "share and talk"

Dont try to be representative of KV, many others boy have much better result in the interview  ...

Peterfan

原文章由 gracechung 於 07-11-30 00:47 發表
原來你地中意背後講人架，真係唔講我唔知tim
唔緊要，唔同人當然有唔好睇法，自己係咩人，睇既世界咪係點架lor。
我份人一向都唔虛偽，有乜野照直講，不卑也不亢，如果你覺得我講既說話將你比下去，我誠意地向你道歉。對唔住。

...

Yes,like to talk at your back because you have nothing值得拿出來表揚

ＡｎｄＹｏｕｈａｖｅ　ｎｏ　ｃｈｉｏｃｅ　ｂｕｔ　ｍｕｓｔ〝鄧”人高興，ｂｅｃａｕｓｅ　ｙｏｕｒ　ｓｏｎ　ｎｏ　喇沙／男拔　唔鄧人高興可以點。

仲有我接受你的道歉，不過唔會原諒你 你說話〝口氣咁大〞（好臭）點夠你比


ｌａｓｔ　ｂｕｔ　ｎｏｔ　ｌｅａｓｔ　唔好成日借ｋｖ個名出來作威作福，你的一句〝唔通做弱勢社群好咩”已經將你口話清高但睇唔起人的性格表露無遺

晚安．．純真的你．．記得擦牙同用李ｘ得林

gracechung

隨便你點講。

原文章由 Peterfan 於 07-11-30 01:40 發表



Yes,like to talk at your back because you have nothing值得拿出來表揚

ＡｎｄＹｏｕｈａｖｅ　ｎｏ　ｃｈｉｏｃｅ　ｂｕｔ　ｍｕｓｔ〝鄧”人高興，ｂｅｃａｕｓｅ　ｙｏｕｒ　ｓｏｎ　ｎｏ　喇沙／男拔　唔鄧人高興可以點。

仲有我接受你的道歉，不過唔會原諒你 你說話〝口氣咁大〞（好臭）點 ...

Yuhinba

Hi parents,

SFA is very good but also very demanding to your kids. KTS is less stress but still good in academic, the environment is much more better than SFA, however, the school fees is more expensive than SFA.

My 1st elder daughter also got the letter of acceptance from SFA & KTS but I will give them up because I already get the 1st round offer from a good school with a better secondary school net than SFA. I am very lucky. Then, my other 2 kids can follow to enter without any stress to me or my wife. All my kids are not studying in KV or St. Catherine but in a more happy kindergarden in Kowloon Tong. (The related PS also receive KV or St. Cat student.) They feel more happy & not too much homework la. I don't want to give them a bad impression on learning.:( will prefer to give them more resources & time on sport & music which they already start in K2.   

To be honest, even study in SFA, their graudates going to famous traditional secondary school (like DBS, LS, etc...) is only around 1/3 or less. Next year, LS will become also a "direct subsided school", then less kids will have chance to study if they want to get the seat from lucky draw.

If your kids need to start very very hard since 3 years old & also hell training in the coming 6 yrs in PS. I think that both the parents & kids are extremely exhausted. What a wonderful life to a family? So, my thinking is: try to give them a happy life with a good school which can let them to build up their self-confidence :D . Will let them have fun B4 P3.

If I take SFA, oh my god, must wake up at 6:00am . Both my wife & me need to work & will prefer our kids can hv a happy life, to apply private schools is just because we worry that cannot get a seat in 1st round or lucky draw.

B. R.

redhot

"LS will become also a "direct subsided school"

Is this true?

CHTmami

Yuhinba,

Are you sure that LS will be DSS next year?  Where did you get this info?

gracechung

各位家長，"KTS RECEIVED RESULTS"條thread度有KTS的在學家長留言，不妨收集多些真實資料，以便參考。

charwes

Where did you get this information from? Please state your source. Thanks.

I got this source from atnext.com:

喇 沙 書 院 拒 轉 直 資

近 年 多 所 傳 統 英 文 中 學 紛 紛 轉 為 學 費 數 萬 元 的 直 資 中 學 ， 資 助 模 式 類 同 津 貼 學 校 的 補 助 學 校 喇 沙 書 院 ， 表 明 未 有 計 劃 轉 為 直 資 ， 將 來 轉 制 成 數 也 低 ； 該 校 校 監 指 轉 制 只 會 趕 走 貧 窮 學 生 ， 即 使 提 供 獎 學 金 ， 也 不 是 解 決 方 法 。 該 校 會 向 家 長 和 校 友 尋 求 捐 款 ， 以 增 聘 師 和 推 行 小 班 學 來 提 升 學 質 素 。

教 育 對 象 不 論 貧 富

今 年 創 校 75 周 年 的 喇 沙 書 院 昨 日 舉 行 校 慶 活 動 動 禮 。 校 監 Thomas Lavin 修 士 表 示 ， 多 所 傳 統 名 校 轉 直 資 後 ， 校 方 留 意 到 有 關 情 況 ， 但 至 今 未 有 計 劃 轉 直 資 ， 也 沒 有 轉 制 急 切 性 。 他 表 示 ， 該 校 將 來 會 與 直 屬 的 喇 沙 小 學 結 成 一 條 龍 學 校 ， 若 然 轉 直 資 ， 現 時 同 屬 補 助 學 校 形 式 的 喇 小 也 須 轉 制 ， 否 則 不 能 結 龍 。

Thomas Lavin 指 出 ， 喇 沙 育 對 象 不 論 貧 富 ， 「 我 們 不 是 為 富 裕 的 人 ， 而 是 為 所 有 人 ， 我 們 必 須 保 持 這 原 則 。 」 他 擔 心 一 旦 轉 為 直 資 ， 高 昂 學 費 會 令 到 只 有 富 裕 人 士 才 會 入 讀 該 校 ， 「 提 供 獎 學 金 並 不 是 解 決 辦 法 。 」

原文章由 Yuhinba 於 07-11-30 07:32 發表
Next year, LS will become also a "direct subsided school", then less kids will have chance to study if they want to get the seat from lucky draw.

[ 本文章最後由 charwes 於 07-11-30 10:36 編輯 ]

kammielam

我路過咋..
不過我印象中..gracechung為人又的確幾鐘意無意間晒命..
之前見佢係kv發言話....
自己每個月供6000蚊教育基金比個仔,又話自己鋼琴造詣有幾高,又話自己細個學琴有幾叻..又話呢代既鋼琴老師唔合水準.....
又話放假同老公亞仔去邊去邊.又話自己而家唔使do..
真係好大口氣...
所以我對佢都好有印象

原文章由 Peterfan 於 07-11-30 01:40 發表



Yes,like to talk at your back because you have nothing值得拿出來表揚

ＡｎｄＹｏｕｈａｖｅ　ｎｏ　ｃｈｉｏｃｅ　ｂｕｔ　ｍｕｓｔ〝鄧”人高興，ｂｅｃａｕｓｅ　ｙｏｕｒ　ｓｏｎ　ｎｏ　喇沙／男拔　唔鄧人高興可以點。

仲有我接受你的道歉，不過唔會原諒你 你說話〝口氣咁大〞（好臭）點 ...

20020116

呢d名校家長認真………失禮！
行為另人爆笑
呀係喇，你覺得人地show off，何不show埋一份？

溏心風暴特別版！

[ 本文章最後由 20020116 於 07-11-30 10:40 編輯 ]

holywood

[/quote]
其實好難比較，你自己要考慮清楚，唔好受人影響。
如果係我，我話如果係我，我會揀kts，原因係即使冇中學，從畢業生去向睇來，估計將來有得博，博一間比TN更好的中學

。

原文章由 gracechung 於 07-11-29 12:31 發表
真係好難取捨，呢兩間各有優點。但我自己來講，我會揀sfa，事關我覺得自己個仔係谷得，而幼稚園又過左幾年谷的生活，開左個頭，我會唔想浪費，所以條路會行到尾。


Mdm Grace
到底你記唔記得自己講過乜？我都係路過，見你成日發言，鍾意認叻唔緊要反正當笑料黎睇，但講對學校睇法一時一樣，咁就好影響人。成日話如果係你會點點點次次不同，你最想都係正如之前
Peterpan講，入男拔同喇沙，不過其實入到英華你都應該掩住嘴笑

holywood

原文章由 20020116 於 07-11-30 10:36 發表
呢d名校家長認真………失禮！
行為另人爆笑

咁又唔好用呢d來一慨而論！好多都唔會係咁