小朋友幾多歲開始學琴好D呢?

cpmummy

ming2,

thank you for your comments!

cpmummy

lamlam2004

My daugter is five years old. I plan to let her learning piano in the next month.

Umi

ming2,

我個女現在已經轉左老師, 我覺得好好, 現在我係個度練琴時,如果個老師係度都會同我跟一跟佢練, 佢同我講話我個女根本就唔熟d音, 都唔似學左一年琴, 但d書又會一次比一次深, 咁個小朋友會好吃力, 因為小朋友跟本唔識睇譜, 所以佢話, 現在大家都要合作幫幫佢, 每日做2行譜, 唔駛咁多, 慢慢加深佢既記憶, 佢識睇譜, 自然就唔覺得辛苦,  同時佢都話我個女既手指唔正確和太大力, 今個星期兩日去佢個度練琴,佢都係度教我個女, 足足半粒鈡, 真係好用心囉, 現在我個女要轉返d初班書, 好似初學咁囉, 唉....仲浪費左我一年既學費tim, 希望呢個真係好老師啦! 開始時我都驚我個女唔跟佢,因為老板娘都有5-60 years old, 但我個女都幾鈡意跟佢學囉, 咁我都放心d, 現在仲有個好處, 真係如果我唔得閒, 我揾人帶佢上去, 佢地都會幫我執一執佢囉.

mfkhung

I am not sure if my son is on the right track. He is playing the Alfred Library Books, including the lesson book, technic book, solo book, ear training, theory?

Yumom

Hi ming2,

I will read your "column" on and off. My problem is so so so serious! My daughter likes to learn everything, she learns fast, confident .... She's 4 years old, but she just doesn't like to practice.
Maybe the rest she learns, she doesn't need to practice!!

She  had attended the JMC course in Tom Lee for one month but the teacher was... so I quit. She was very happy there so I thought maybe it's time to let her learn piano. She had attended 4 lessons (2 per week) in summer, but she didn't want to touch the piano at home!!!! and she said too much! Start from next wk, just one lesson per wk.

I tried many ways to get her practice piano at home but in vain. I played her songs, she enjoyed being my teacher and said you are right, you are clever you got the right key. She can tell whether I got the rt key. Last time, she practiced the piano, she can play well just once but she just refuses to practice...
I think her performance in piano is not gd while she enjoyed the "felling of success" in other activiites!

Should she quit now? It seems a waste of money as she just played the piano in the teacher's house!She said she liked Tom Lee but Tom Lee said I have to queue up again, another 1 year at least!

What should I do.. Can you offer some expert advise? Many many thanks in advance.

Yumom

ydoris

我個女5歲幾,學了初級年幾.我覺得佢都幾有心機學,都有打算買個琴俾佢.但d琴成3至4萬一部.供50個月都要成700至800蚊一個月.所以想拖住先啦,上星期問琴先生,原來再過半年,我個女要用隻腳tim..咁我係未一定要買琴呀??吾用腳係未練吾到架?佢而家用部好平的電子琴練...我都知吾係咁好啦...買一個琴同買一架車真係無分別架..而家15,16...有無d好意見俾我?

toffeeli

ydoris,

電子琴始終和鋼琴有分別，其實未決定買部貴琴之前，亦可考慮租琴室練或買部二手琴

toffeeli

tunafish

想問下大家,我個女而家學左六堂,佢係識彈幾隻歌,但係跟手拍提示1,2,3,4,5彈的,我見佢d初學琴書裹面都有這種提示法,是否起初學會是這樣嗎?老師話遲些唔會提佢,要個女自己習慣睇,但個女重係唔識睇,唔知要等幾時唔使依賴手指提示呢?有無好方法,可令小朋友易入腦,請大家指教下! thanks!

麟媽媽

大家好！好耐無入來了！
我仔近排轉左新書，是John Thomson - First Grade Book，呢本書又係有數目字的，我發現亞仔開始跟數目字彈，所以把心一橫，用Liquid Paper油晒D數目字，無得跟，焗住要佢睇譜！

ydoris

我都問過琴老師,佢話d平鋼琴不能學到8級.到時再要換琴...點先知道那款琴可以學到8級?咁我可以選個平d...
又如果一星期去琴行練一次琴,咁又夠吾夠呢??我個女而家係屋企一星期最少練3至4次.

tunafish

ming2,
咁本書唔係全本都有數目字指示,係頭幾頁有,後部的都係一段既第一個音囉!

tunafish

想問下,你們的小朋友上頭幾堂係唔係,唔哂睇手字數字架!佢地會睇懂音符嗎?(初學)

toffeeli

Apart from learning to play songs, my son also has to learn the piano theory including rhythm, beats, notes and skills etc. After each lessons, he would have some homework to do on the theory parts as well.

ydoris

小朋友太小,一定要家長帶去琴行,一星期可以去多少日當然是乎家長有多忙啦..我吾想個工人帶去啦,同無練一樣啦..咁似乎買一個新琴是必須了..
咁如果真係買一部中價綱琴,第日想換琴是否可以賣左舊的綱琴呢..成日聽到二手綱琴,是否有一些人專收綱琴的.如果可以好似車咁可以trade in, 咁會好些.
話時話,老師的質數,真係我一個外行人吾多清楚.記得第一次上佢堂,佢拿住本書好惡咁同我講,點解學左成半年仲係睇住1234來彈,以後吾准,即刻同我買左本練習薄同佢認豆豉.我番屋企又同佢練.而家老師話佢認音好快.上堂進步便獎粒糖俾佢..我覺得都ok掛?