今年九龍城區派位簡報

BillyM

3kidsma 寫道:
BillyM,
war 真是英雄所見略同. 你的分析十分專業.
今年大仔獲派第二志願band 2, 但已很開心了.
另想請教,明年二仔派位,41網, 正band 1生, 第一志願想考華仁 或  伊利沙伯中學 哪一間較好或容易呢?

哈里波特
你囡囡派哪所中學? 不見你報料.可否與我們分享吓!

I don't think WYK is available to the Kln City net.  Usually there are only a few QES spaces for Kln City (really A FEW, like 3-5).  Not optimistic.

Anyways, as you have asked, let me say a few words on these 2 schools.  I would choose QES over WYK.  I don't have any hard data, but from various sources of gossips, WYK is slipping big time these few years.  I have talked a F1 WYK kid this year.  The teachers don't seem to have much enthusiasm to teach.  A Maths teacher was on-leave for months and the replacement didnt teach at all.  Is there any insider here to give some WYK updates??

哈里波特

Yes, so my friend choose
1st : Tang Siu Kin
2nd : Methodist
For band 2 students, these 2 choice not bad.

BillyM 寫道:
[quote]
哈里波特 寫道:
Is it the problem on the approaching?  We are Yau Tsim Mong net, kids allocated to 循遁/鄧肇堅 EMI even they are in the middle of band 2 (we guess, may be band 2 頭, sure not in band 1).  They placed them in the 1st and then 2nd may be DSS EMI, then 3rd on are the good reputation CMI.

This is the observation of our school only, but not for the whole net in Yau Tsim Ming, that why I said it may be the problem on the approaching.

I know a BAND2 girl in Yau Tsim Mong district who got into Tang Shiu Kin too.[/quote]

WYmom

BillyM 寫道:

I don't have recent info on HFCC.  From what I saw a few years back, she should be on par with Wa Ying or Hoi Ping, a little bit higher than Carmel and WFN.  But as I said, I don't have much recent data on HFCC.  See if others can provide more info.

Wa Ying and HYS are two different type of schools.  In academics, Wa Ying might be better than HYS. (I don't have hard data.  Just from plain observation.)  But I like HYS more.  She can provide a more complete "package" for a girl in the form of sports, academics, culture, and spirit.  I love schools with a strong spirit.  

BillyM,

Thanks.  I also agree with you that HY can provide more all-rounded education.  If my kid from Holy Family ranking within top 20% (2x/13x), do you think she has chance to be accepted by Heen Yunn in first round ?

BillyM

WYmom 寫道:

BillyM,

Thanks.  I also agree with you that HY can provide more all-rounded education.  If my kid from Holy Family ranking within top 20% (2x/13x), do you think she has chance to be accepted by Heen Yunn in first round ?

Hard to say.  HYS receives loads of 1st round application each year.  The school looks at more than academics.  Your daughter will have a better chance if she plays a few sports (and plays them good) and has some other awards.  

To be honest, a twenty something finish in HFCS may not get you a space in 傳統名校 unless your daughter is also strong in other areas like sports or music.  

But if you like HYS you should give it a try.  Go with it in the 1st round and simply put HFCC as #1 in the central allocation.  You wont lose much.

bettymomo

我仔派到第一志願, 沙田循道衛理. 佢班同學派到唔錯, 60%以上派第一志願, 最差派第四志願.
any comment about 沙田循道衛理?

3kidsma

3kidsma 寫道:
BillyM,

另想請教,明年二仔派位,41網, 正band 1生, 第一志願想考華仁 或  伊利沙伯中學 哪一間較好或容易呢?

I don't think WYK is available to the Kln City net.  Usually there are only a few QES spaces for Kln City (really A FEW, like 3-5).  Not optimistic.


BillyM,
多謝你的意見!
不好意思令你誤會了, 我講的"第一志願"應是第一次自行收生, 可跨區果隻. 我想九華有好多聯係小學, 所以伊利沙伯會否易入de?

3kidsma

哈里波特,
你囡囡派的如何? 可吾分享吓.

哈里波特

3Kidsma,
See PM

BillyM

3kidsma 寫道:

BillyM,
多謝你的意見!
不好意思令你誤會了, 我講的"第一志願"應是第一次自行收生, 可跨區果隻. 我想九華有好多聯係小學, 所以伊利沙伯會否易入de?

我想是掉轉，QES有幾間聯系學校（馬官、農官、九官等），反而WYK沒有。

自行派位從來不易，無論是QES或WYK都難，你不如選一間適合自己仔仔的去試比較實際，如果你仔仔係強的便甚麼名校都大機會，反之就無分別---都係等電腦派位。

siu_wai_01

我的仔仔獲派入華仁，華仁是否真的大不如前？有沒有華仁家長能分享多些你們的看法？？

大媽

華仁冇乜功課，高度自由，但勝在名氣兼男校掛？

siu_wai_01 寫道:
我的仔仔獲派入華仁，華仁是否真的大不如前？有沒有華仁家長能分享多些你們的看法？？

大媽

這是九龍華仁書院網頁Forum內一位家長自白的感受：
我是一名家長
讓我告訴大家這幾年我對華仁感受:
未入華仁我好想個仔入
入左華仁我叫自已要忍
華仁仔應係有能力自學
但一年二年係咁過
睇完開放日後我決定叫個去外國
好心痛所有華仁仔
因為佢地個個一腔熱誠想為華仁增光

siu_wai_01 寫道:
我的仔仔獲派入華仁，華仁是否真的大不如前？有沒有華仁家長能分享多些你們的看法？？

大媽

伊中今年只有87個位掟出泥抽獎,阿仔個女同學自行考都冇得收到信面試，競爭好大，後來大抽獎時唯有揀銘賢做第一志願，但我聽人講QES自行時喜歡收女仔架

kabee

大媽 寫道:
這是九龍華仁書院網頁Forum內一位家長自白的感受：
我是一名家長
讓我告訴大家這幾年我對華仁感受:
未入華仁我好想個仔入
入左華仁我叫自已要忍
華仁仔應係有能力自學
但一年二年係咁過
睇完開放日後我決定叫個去外國
好心痛所有華仁仔
因為佢地個個一腔熱誠想為華仁增光
[quote]
siu_wai_01 寫道:
我的仔仔獲派入華仁，華仁是否真的大不如前？有沒有華仁家長能分享多些你們的看法？？

[/quote]

其實學校勁不是因為老師勁,而是學生勁.(叻的就收,想唔叻都唔得)

BillyM

kabee 寫道:
其實學校勁不是因為老師勁,而是學生勁.(叻的就收,想唔叻都唔得)

一半一半啦，好學校可以令學生增值，差的學校亦可以糟蹋學生。如果收到的學生全是BAND3尾，可以令他們不變壞已算成功。我好相信一個超班學生，在DGS或DBS所能得到的培育會比在一間普通學校優勝。

照你咁講，九華盡收油尖旺以至九龍區BAND1學生，應該好掂。

uncleedward

Let's face it, band one is so broad. It accounts for 1/3 of the total student population. They cannot be all elitie students. While we are complaining about some of these schools, the teachers there are also complaining about the standard of the students they have been dumped with from the central allocation every year.

The contributing factors to a good school are first the students, second the parents, and last the teachers. The education of our kids should first lie with us as parents.

kabee

BillyM 寫道:
[quote]
kabee 寫道:
其實學校勁不是因為老師勁,而是學生勁.(叻的就收,想唔叻都唔得)

一半一半啦，好學校可以令學生增值，差的學校亦可以糟蹋學生。如果收到的學生全是BAND3尾，可以令他們不變壞已算成功。我好相信一個超班學生，在DGS或DBS所能得到的培育會比在一間普通學校優勝。

照你咁講，九華盡收油尖旺以至九龍區BAND1學生，應該好掂。[/quote]

有沒有留意這個趨勢,
30多年前考升中試的年代分左8級,８級後就自己比錢找私校,第1級的(即現今band1中的band1)入哂傳统名校,當時唔會有一些不知名的中學(如華英,開平等)會出狀元,因為沒有叻學生.
接着分5級,名校開始降級,雖然仍然收第一級的學生,但是比以往已不是全部尖子,不知名的中學開始升級,收2,3級的學生就是當年的2,3級.
現在分三級,電腦抽獎,更多尖子錯配,叻學校開始無咁叻,中等學校開始出狀元.
九華盡收BAND1學生,其實只是當年的第一,二,三級學生.
名校轉直資,大若理由就是這樣.

kabee

仲有一樣,幾廿年前,學校係唔會同學校鬥搶學生,
真實例子,有一學生在A校(都唔差)上了一天中六課,同一時間B校(更好的)打電話話收他,第二天學生走去B校見校長,校長說你已經在A校就讀,若果收你便像和A校爭學生,這樣好像不是太好........

現在中學爭叻學生就唔洗講,連大學都是這樣就有些少兒那個,我個姪女A-level考得好成績(唔講幾多個A la)某大學某學院個 dean 親自打左幾次電話話收,選完科之後種打多次來...

做教育的應該有高尚的情操....

tungfung

Dear 哈里波特:

Please see your PM

Tungfung

ALAL

just pass by.
I have a friend graduated from WAH YAN about 5 years ago. He said teachers are really bad but students are really bright. Teachers can ask students to ' open the light'. Actually students are not too listening to the teachers.

He is a bad example of their graduates. Band 1 primary graduate but when he is F7 his academic is bad, and most importantly, not very confident. The school is too liberal, not suitable to student that lack power of self-control.