DBSPDvs喇沙vs培正vs宣道vs英華vs拔小

ykwong

我冇記錯的話，現時P.1係一樣85%入。P.2及以上肯定係。不過我有老人痴呆，呢度多數人都知。

另好似仍會留番10個8個位做聯繫。

猴子爸

如果新生有85%可入DBS,又很不錯,那么DBS就變相少了位給其他學校.另外,DBS是不是會轉直資?請各位給些資料.

培正 - 中中稱王,論REPUTATION,強過民生
民生 - 英中TIER2,論英文教學,強過培正,但強幾多是一個問題.如果只是課本是英文,老師是說港式英文,但學生根本沒有什么機會講英文... 有沒有民生 的家長/學生?
看你要什么.

WYmom

As I know, 85% can go to DBS only apply upto existing P.1 now, and will no longer apply to P.1 students since Sept 05 onwards.  I have a friend whose son studied P.1 in 04, his parent said that those 04 P.1 boys is the last batch directly linked to DBS. Starting 9/05, DPS will accept both boys and girls and there will be no more direct linkage with any secondary schools.

WingPa

猴子爸,

謝謝你的意見.

彥彥媽咪

猴子爸 and/or others:

After I have read through all your discussions above, they somehow reinforced my projection which I had for a long time....pls correct me if I am wrong:

若以政府依家嘅小學派位方法 (i.e. 計分+搞珠), 純靠關係同運氣, 咁以前的"名校" 會因為冇得揀學生而被淡化其"名校"特質 (即可能課程深d..又或d學生質素高d...etc) ...即長遠嚟講, 所有 subsidized schools will become "average" then?!

而 private school/DSS 就因為可以有自主收生權而可以控制收生質素從而有較佳嘅成績, 尤其係個d出名私校/直資, 佢地可以利用其名氣去吸引高質素學生...

若上述推論正確, 咁係咪即係將來要將小朋友送入私校/直資咁佢嘅成績先會有跡可尋???

:-|  :-|  :-|  :-|

WingPa

彥彥媽咪,

Actually, this may be the secret agenda behind the Government scheme.  Some persons do think that the scheme will result in elitism again.

Through this way, the Government may attain the following objectives :

1. Save money; and
2. Get away from the path to mediocrity.

WingPa

It depends.

While elitism does have its merits, overemphasis on it may lead our children to our old path : those talented ones will get into better schools and receive better education while those average ones may be labelled as a failure.  On the other hand, overemphasis on even opportunity for all children without taking into account their own abilities may lead to another form of unfairness.

The issue is really a complicated one!