放棄SC, 選擇MUNSANG

jessyleung

有無家長為了民生有小學(不是一條龍),而選民生幼稚園,放棄ST CATHERINE.

家長可否對此兩間有什麼評價及意見,應如何決擇?


萬分感謝給予寶貴意見!

kerkermui

如果你鍾意民小, 就應該讀民幼, 因為直升嘅機會好大
但係如果你心儀嘅唔係民小嘅, 3年後會報其他直資私小, 就應該SC好d (競爭能力大d)

Winnietao

我會揀民生,再出去考私小/真資,入sc唔代表一定考到私小/真資,如果覺民生學術唔夠,可以出去補其他,始終學費平,同叫有一個backup

peter_pan

Agree.
With >600 students in SC, not all can get into a good 私小/真資.
With 民生, at least you have a decent (though not top) primary school as backup.

原帖由 Winnietao 於 11-1-3 17:02 發表
我會揀民生,再出去考私小/真資,入sc唔代表一定考到私小/真資,如果覺民生學術唔夠,可以出去補其他,始終學費平,同叫有一個backup

anteater

民生有很多戶外活動,發展很全面,如果你想要學術性高D,就SC

karen55407

我當年就係放棄民生揀St. Cat，我覺得St. Cat真係一間好好、好好嘅學校，唔讀St. Cat我會覺得好可惜。

kyliejet

I prefer 民生!

幼稚園教得好全面, 活動多, 每週均有四堂NET 教英文, 三堂普通話, 程度不算淺.

小學亦是一間傳統名校.

[ 本帖最後由 kyliejet 於 11-1-4 10:38 編輯 ]

sansan2008

Agree too! The competition for primary school is more tough, it is better to have a back-up first.

原帖由 Winnietao 於 11-1-3 17:02 發表
我會揀民生,再出去考私小/真資,入sc唔代表一定考到私小/真資,如果覺民生學術唔夠,可以出去補其他,始終學費平,同叫有一個backup

BBQ008

如果讀民幼,再有民小offer,照計可以參加大抽獎,因為民生是私小,不是直資,但為何有家長說不可以呢?

kyliejet

民幼可以參加第一輪自行分配及考私小/直資, 但不可以參加第二輪地區大抽奬.

民小是私小, 收生不受管制, 是有權取消參加大抽奬的民幼學生的小一學位的.

[ 本帖最後由 kyliejet 於 11-1-4 13:03 編輯 ]

hosuper

If I were you, I would choose SC.

nataliepsc

朋友個仔都頗醒目, sc k3, 報成10間直資/私小都好彩但亦只有一個offer, 好多間連2nd in都無, 三年後競爭更大(2008年生人數接近2005年生即現今k3的人數之double), 唔係一條龍既話對報小一"著數"不多, 所以一d都唔奇怪選ms唔選sc

我會一與winnietao策略一樣, 讀民幼然後搏其他直資/私小, 超碼打左底先, 無offer 既"寒"法你係難以想像..

仔仔錫錫你

你list 10間直資/私小出來，如果一間都無民小份，咁就讀sc喇！我上年list 10間直資/私小出來，一間都無pc 份，所以放棄pc offer.

oneone11

我會選民幼,雖然唔係全部上民小,但都算有個backup,sc學術好過民幼,但民幼有學券,慳返o的錢可以去補習,咁樣都可以彌補學術方面o的不足,08年出生率咁高,小朋友競爭太大,除非你既小朋友真係好叻,如果唔係,讀咗sc都唔等於考到好既直資/私小

GoodGrief

I think that it depends on whether you prefer to adopt an “aggressive” or “conservative”approach to planning your child's path for proceeding with the primary school.  If you are uncertain to help your child to secure a school place of a "renowned” school through the Discretionary Places Allocation,Munsang primary school as a backup for most of its Munsang Kindergarten students can let conservative parents relax as their little children no longer need to facethe fierce competition in the primary one placement exercise three years later. Certainly, Munsang is not your cup of tea if parents aim at allowing thier little children to go to some famous private/DSS schools and parents believe that their children will "win" in the "competition".  


[ 本帖最後由 GoodGrief 於 11-1-4 19:05 編輯 ]