沙田培基VS體藝

sarawonghk

大家好!想問上述兩間學術邊間比較好?
謝謝

lctang

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:05
回覆 gn00127187 的帖子

請問有無兩間學校學術數據可看?

體藝2023 DSE (校網School Report公佈):
https://www.tic.edu.hk/en/site/view?name=School+Documents


Academic Performance
- Public Examination Performance – HKDSE 2023
Percentage of students meeting the General University Entrance Requirements (Core subjects with 3322 or better) 64.3%


Percentage of Students eligible to local sub-degree programmes/relevant civil service appointment (22222 or above)(5 subjects including Chi Lang & Eng Lang) 94.6%


- Profile of Graduates 2023
Local studies 88.5%
Overseas studies 6.2%
Part-time employment / part-time study 3.5%
Others 1.8%

kkmm22

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:44
回覆 lucia6119 的帖子

阿女本身係體操港隊。佢呈一, 二既成績老師話佢屬1B, 佢英文成績比中文好.培基又多 ...

如果你女玩開體操一定係體藝啦，我朋友女兒今年體藝S 2，她也是體操港隊的，我見她差唔多每日放學都要過去體院訓練，為了多啲休息時間她入住了學校宿舍，見她間中也會飛外地比賽

lctang

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:05
回覆 gn00127187 的帖子

請問有無兩間學校學術數據可看?

Sorry! 上帖我技術上出現故障，又不懂怎樣del post, 現重新再發

培基2023 DSE (培基官方校網公佈)
https://www.spkc.edu.hk/spkc-diary/fruits-of-devotion-and-diligence-class-of-2023/

Congratulations to the Class of 2023 for their remarkable achievements in the 2023 HKDSE! Today, the unparalleled perseverance of our S6 students as well as the unremitting devotion of our teachers bore fruit. We are proud to share their achievements:

Around 80% of our students have fulfilled the general requirements for university admission (33222), while the overall average for Hong Kong is 42.3%.

Over 95% of our students are eligible for sub-degree programmes (22222), while the overall average for Hong Kong is 71.4%.

The average passing rate in all subjects is 98.0%. The rate in all subjects with Level 4 or above is 53.0%, while the overall average for Hong Kong is 36.8%.

17 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 3 or above.

13 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 4 or above.

10 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 5* or above.

The results of English Language, Liberal Studies, BAFs (Business Management) and Economics surpassed the territory averages in all levels.

Yim Pak Ho (6L) attained an exceptional HKDSE result of 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5*, 5*, scoring a total of 47 in 7 subjects.



S6 Pooikeinians truly deserve a pat on the back for their resilience in the past three years of disruption and uncertainty. Congratulations to our students who excelled in the 2023 HKDSE Examination!

Class

Name of Students

HKDSE Results

6L	YIM Pak Ho	5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5*, 5*
6L	HUNG Sum Wing	5*, 5*, 5*, 5*, 5*, 5, 5
6P	LIU Chun Lok	5**, 5*, 5*, 5, 4, 4
6L	FUNG Ching Yan	5**, 5*, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4
6J	LAM Ka Yu	5*, 5*, 5*, 5, 4, 4
6P	KWAN Tsz Yau	5*, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5

Once again, congratulations to the Class of 2023, and we wish them every success in their future endeavors!

tpmon

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 14:52
大家好!想問上述兩間學術邊間比較好?
謝謝

以體育方面培訓+成績不錯，當然選體藝。

培基比不到你細路體育發展方面的照顧。

lctang

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:05
回覆 gn00127187 的帖子

請問有無兩間學校學術數據可看?

3176

培基2023 DSE (培基官方校網公佈) https://www.spkc.edu.hk/spkc-diary/fruits-of-devotion-and-diligence-class-of-2023/ Congratulations to the Class of 2023 for their remarkable achievements in the 2023 HKDSE! Today, the unparalleled perseverance of our S6 students as well as the unremitting devotion of our teachers bore fruit. We are proud to share their achievements: Around 80% of our students have fulfilled the general requirements for university admission (33222), while the overall average for Hong Kong is 42.3%. Over 95% of our students are eligible for sub-degree programmes (22222), while the overall average for Hong Kong is 71.4%. The average passing rate in all subjects is 98.0%. The rate in all subjects with Level 4 or above is 53.0%, while the overall average for Hong Kong is 36.8%. 17 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 3 or above. 13 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 4 or above. 10 subjects outperformed the territory averages in attaining Level 5* or above. The results of English Language, Liberal Studies, BAFs (Business Management) and Economics surpassed the territory averages in all levels. Yim Pak Ho (6L) attained an exceptional HKDSE result of 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5*, 5*, scoring a total of 47 in 7 subjects. S6 Pooikeinians truly deserve a pat on the back for their resilience in the past three years of disruption and uncertainty. Congratulations to our students who excelled in the 2023 HKDSE Examination! Class Name of Students HKDSE Results 6L YIM Pak Ho 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5**, 5*, 5* 6L HUNG Sum Wing 5*, 5*, 5*, 5*, 5*, 5, 5 6P LIU Chun Lok 5**, 5*, 5*, 5, 4, 4 6L FUNG Ching Yan 5**, 5*, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4 6J LAM Ka Yu 5*, 5*, 5*, 5, 4, 4 6P KWAN Tsz Yau 5*, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5 Once again, congratulations to the Class of 2023, and we wish them every success in their future endeavors!

10090

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-28 10:50
佢雖然係港隊，但唔係大項運動，所以神校試左，但無offer.
宜家阿女就偏向培基，佢覺得除左運動佢都想試唔 ...

體藝校舍大培基兩倍幾，培基仲要一級有六班，好迫㗎

sarawonghk

佢雖然係港隊，但唔係大項運動，所以神校試左，但無offer.
宜家阿女就偏向培基，佢覺得除左運動佢都想試唔同既野，同埋培基多左IAL課程，到高中又多個choice.
不過我自己就仲係1516中，當初我幫佢揀體藝既原因，其一係成個運動氛圍都好好，阿女自己當初都認定體藝，估唔到宜家轉呔(emoji)

itamama

我小朋友一線小學1B生，Toefl Junior 金，但佢只鍾情體藝，佢入咗好開心。而且高中唔一定要修PE或VA, 最緊要小朋友喜歡又合適。體藝近年收band 1為主。

mimwing

10090 發表於 24-3-27 20:59
我認為在絕大部份情況下，難入即係多人鍾意，多人鍾意嘅嘢即係好

非常同意
有b1b 成績，英文又較好，又港隊，去考神校都大機會

10090

TAIOU4 發表於 24-3-27 20:22
講到難入就一定體藝難入D
不過唔通難入就等於好?

我認為在絕大部份情況下，難入即係多人鍾意，多人鍾意嘅嘢即係好

TAIOU4

10090 發表於 24-3-27 20:07
體藝成績一定好啲喎，B1先有可能入到，資源又較多，根本係重點學校，一般直資學校無可能贏佢

...

講到難入就一定體藝難入D
不過唔通難入就等於好?

10090

體藝成績一定好啲喎，B1先有可能入到，資源又較多，根本係重點學校，一般直資學校無可能贏佢

adriantai

小朋友意願？

lucia6119

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:44
回覆 lucia6119 的帖子

阿女本身係體操港隊。佢呈一, 二既成績老師話佢屬1B, 佢英文成績比中文好.培基又多 ...

同意樓上那位 , 如果不是日後想在體育行業發展 , 真的不用選體藝 ( 尤其是 1B 成績)
就算真的想在體育行業發展  , 升大學時選相關科系就可以了
其實 1B 成績 , 可以選比 培基更好的中學 , 沙田區應該有很多選擇

samhongkong

两間的收生成績也差不多，但最終公開試成績培基好D，但又不是差距很大。其實中學生的成績是看個人努力，和學校無關，两間都有學霸，都有唔讀書的。為什麼體藝公開試成稍遜，是因為原本可以兼顧體育和學習的同學到高中時兼顧不了，唔想放棄體育成績就會滑落。
兩間既學生卻好唔同，可能平時訓練辛苦，體藝學生自信D，刻苦D同 social D，培基學生就書生D，宅男多D，可能平時多電子學習，玩Ipad 多過出街。

體藝已經轉變，收生以成績為先

sarawonghk

回覆 gn00127187 的帖子

謝謝.

gn00127187

回覆 sarawonghk 的帖子

你GOOGLE學校名,會有D文憑試概要相關既網站顯示出黎,你點落去就會搵到D該校近年已公佈既DSE相關資訊出黎,唔難搵

我個人覺得呢兩間學校既DSE成績都有D差距,
如果你小朋友唔係特別一心想向體藝方面發展,我覺得培基可能會比較適合佢,
好好考慮下!加油!

sarawonghk

回覆 lucia6119 的帖子

阿女本身係體操港隊。佢呈一, 二既成績老師話佢屬1B, 佢英文成績比中文好.培基又多左IAL選擇,我宜家都十五十六.

lucia6119

sarawonghk 發表於 24-3-27 15:23
回覆 lucia6119 的帖子

其實我知兩間係好唔同既學校.

運動成績唔錯: 是指 體育科 比較高分 ? 還是已經有專長? 例如 游泳已經是某些游泳CLUB的而且經常參加比賽 / 某項運動已被選入總會的青少年計劃裡的培訓運動員?
如果只是體育科 比較高分 那種 , 就可能會比較辛苦


培基成績 (我兒子已是比較久遠 , 都 10 年前了 , 那時 都是 BAND 1C - BAND 2 A-B 生 , BAND 2B 的讀得比較辛苦)
不過看近2/3 年 培基的風評好像比以前更好