觀塘聖保祿 & 聖潔靈 如何比較 ?

chanyukyan

如題

馬媽媽

回覆 Lily2003 的帖子

Hi Lily2003,

You may consider the following:-

a) St Cat  將軍澳線校車好少人搭, 因為一次過要收晒全年二千八百元, 只包括單程車費, 回程要自己唸 , 中途退出不設退費,

The school bus company will refund to the students if they have moved to other areas.

b) 兩者比較一下, 乘校車車程時間, 裕民坊轉車可以訓晏D

裕民坊轉車 may not 訓晏D because there are so many students at 裕民坊 at the same time. One still has to arrive there as early as possible (better on or before 7:30 am). Otherwise, has to take taxi. Besides, the students have to hand in their homeworks on or before 8:05 a.m. and otherwise their homeworks will be treated as late.

c) 如坐將軍澳校車, 時間早到嚇死你, 一早返到學校溫吓書都好

My daughter arrived at school at around 7:20 am and up to now, she has finished two thick books and will continue to do so. I teach her to use that period of time to study or chat with her friends (I think that it is better than waiting at 裕民坊.


d ) 看來, 交通真係大問題, 地鐵有學生價, 但係巴士/小巴 無學生價, 收大人價 !

Whether it is worth to travel for a long time or for more money, it depends on how much you like the school. Some of the students choose to study in Happy Valley where is far away from Lam Tin  because of the good school there.

c) 偏僻都有佢既好處, 唔會咁易浦商場流連, 黎緊25號同 6/12 都會去兩間女子中學睇真D, 因為呢度都無咩家長講詳情細節。  

Agreed. Better to compare. Both schools are good.

Lily2003

St Cat  將軍澳線校車好少人搭, 因為一次過要收晒全年二千八百元, 只包括單程車費, 回程要自己唸 , 中途退出不設退費,

兩者比較一下, 乘校車車程時間, 裕民坊轉車可以訓晏D

如坐將軍澳校車, 時間早到嚇死你, 一早返到學校溫吓書都好


看來, 交通真係大問題, 地鐵有學生價, 但係巴士/小巴 無學生價, 收大人價 !

偏僻都有佢既好處, 唔會咁易浦商場流連, 黎緊25號同 6/12 都會去兩間女子中學睇真D, 因為呢度都無咩家長講詳情細節。  

馬媽媽

回覆 Wing_ 的帖子

St Cat has 2 school buses travelling from Lam Tin and Tseung Kwan O respectively (in the morning only), which are convenient.

Besides, St Cat will have open day on 25.11.2014 (Tue). Any one interested can call the school direct.

TiffanyLing

回覆 yan02 的帖子

近屋企真係重要, 選校部署好有學問. 謝謝您!

yan02

回覆 lam_yau 的帖子

舊年我 2 間都有去 ,你要上他們网頁看時間
ST Cat 不叫升中 講座 , 好像叫 開放日 , 有一班高年班同學帶領參觀學校  ,但要登記左才可以去的 , 要打去問幾時開始登記

St Paul 都有升中講座的

yan02

回覆 TiffanyLing 的帖子

首先  甲部是全港性抽 , 學位大約 占 8% , 抽中的機會是比較少 , 除非超有運的人
所以試下阿女運氣了 , 因我 2 間都中意 , 不想失機會

乙部是本區 , 佔的學位比較多, 相對入的機會大的

我女就是去 in 時參觀了學校 ,都中意那環境 , 加上考慮交通問題, 既然 2 間叮嚀馬頭

當然選間近家的 啦, 所以才在乙部 轉左


好才 , 乙部抽中

avbee

回覆 Lily2003 的帖子

幾年前教育局講過吾好信尼些排名

^曾小姐^

應該大部份觀塘區學校的b1女同學會放st paul乙一,其實係咪好大機會中?放乙二係咪通常梁式芝多?因我見派唔到st paul就梁式芝,梁往往都有成十幾人派到

TiffanyLing

回覆 yan02 的帖子

請問點解到大抽獎時，反而放St. Paul乙1? 因為interivew 的感覺唔同左?

chanyukyan

感謝yan02的分享,看完你的決擇與最後的結果,只可說-估佢唔倒

yan02

回覆 chanyukyan 的帖子

我是 自行和甲一 放 St  Cat 的人家長
自行二 , 甲二  St  paul  

乙 一   St   Paul

我女自行 St Cat 沒份 in ,  St Cat  只in  成績最好的頭 150 名

反而 St paul  有的 in  . St Paul  in 頭 250 人


唉, 有時呢的填表就像賭一樣 ,要看彩數   

lam_yau

請問st paul & st cat今年有無升中講座?

chanyukyan

多謝twinwong 祝福,希望佢有機會面試時順順利利

chanyukyan

真係好開心咁多家長給予咁多寶貴的意見,現在開始有點眉目了

TwinWong

係, 要睇囡囡性格取向係咪配合到學校教法重要D,
始終兩家都係好學校

我識家長有个仔仔1A料, 佢仔仔好好動, 唔肯去1A校,
堅持自己讀1C就夠, 佢好自律, 目前QUIZ 到維持拿FULL MARKS, 無補習
校內活動: 天文學, 數學, 籃球  / 校外: 中樂団, 天文學, 作曲, 游泳, 阿拉伯文
每星期2晚, 要睇/聽唔同嘅藝術同音樂演奏

馬媽媽

回覆 Lily2003 的帖子


My daughter's friend 放聖傑靈女子中學自行第一, 藍田聖保祿中學自行第二。But I think that parents who will choose the above arrangement are few.

I think that St Paul is better than St Cat in terms of academic result. I have seen many St Paul's girls studying along the escalator from Lam Tin MTR. But St Cat can provide a more balanced education to girls and St Cat's girls are playful and cheerful, which I want my daughter to be.

Besides, my daughter's primary school also gave some comments on St Cat, in which I find that not all comments are correct. So, it is better to look at both schools by oneself and compare.

TwinWong

有家長囡囡在BAND 2A中學(英文班), 考試結果好好~有A
媽媽打去ST. PAUL 問中二插班學位, 學校回應是難以收回囡囡,
始終一年后其教法和程度大家都不同

TwinWong

Lily2003 發表於 14-10-23 08:19
聖傑靈女子中學    2013排位    23
藍田聖保祿中學    2013排位    36

我只是覺得ST.CAT 校園大点,我個人較喜歡ST. PAUL