高主教小學 vs 港大同學會小學 邊間好

AHO8681

家住筲箕灣，父母都是在職父母, 以上2間邊間比較適合呢? 此兩校的舊生父母可以比D意見嗎?

ziyi

唔應該係Savoy嗎???
她的小朋友才是由港同小升左港同中wor
iwff的小朋友跟我們一樣是小學

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 11-7-13 16:38 發表
學校有安排呈分, 有D學生(特別係最叻果批)都會考慮更上一層樓, 每年約有廿幾個學生會走, 都係去一般所謂BAND ONE名校(或者BAND ONE超級名校都有)
而其他人, 好似我咁, 唔好攪咁多喇, 直升啦
而家P1係$2100/1個月, 一 ...

bwm

Charlott_mum,

Thanks for your sharing on hkuga. do u think the kids can adapt normal traditional secondary school after 6 years study in hkuga? will you plan to let your girl to study in hkuga's secondary school?

btw, how much is the school fee for primary1 now?

thanks a lot for your help!

iwff

我小朋友係港同讀小三。小一及小二雖然冇考試,但老師平時都會給評估卷小朋友去做的,只是冇通知家長,學生已習慣堂上有卷做,但又冇需要事前溫習,好靠平時吸收幾多而去做的, 所以壓力一點都不大。

到小三學校有考試範圍給學生溫習的 , 仔仔都沒有不習慣, 因為小一小二已習慣有卷做,只是小三定為"考試"要事前溫習。另外小三考全港性系統評估(TSA)都沒有問題。

iwff

原帖由 WanSze 於 11-7-13 14:31 發表
謝謝!另想請問, 小學概覽2010的資料提到: 小一、小二不設考試；小三至小六每年兩次總結性評估。 不知道小三至小六所提到的總結性評估是指測驗,考試嗎?因擔心小一至小二沒有考試,到小三才有,家長及小朋友適應不來....再 ...

WanSze

謝謝!另想請問, 小學概覽2010的資料提到: 小一、小二不設考試；小三至小六每年兩次總結性評估。 不知道小三至小六所提到的總結性評估是指測驗,考試嗎?因擔心小一至小二沒有考試,到小三才有,家長及小朋友適應不來....再次謝謝你的資料.....

WanSze

Charlotte_mom
請問港同p1-P2係咪都係做project 多,不知p3-p6如何?謝謝!

BBBKing

請問有無人可以分享下簡介會後感? 邊類型小朋友較為適合呢?

BBBKing

Charlotte_mom 你好!! 請分享一下當初報讀此校原因, 點樣去衡量? 有咩地方吸引你, 而又覺得適合你小朋友呢?  知道你小朋友入讀後好開心... 我正consider報讀這間, 看看是否真的適合自己小朋友... 謝謝!

Sunnyland

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 11-7-11 12:10 發表
港同有提供有限度既gifted programme(我唔講大話, 有就係有, 不過真係唔會好似部分直資咁豐富)
數學去到高年班會分流教, 將4班分5組, 最叻同最唔叻果2班會較少人(10幾個), 等老師可以睇住黎教, 而"高b班"會較多高階 ...

Charlotte_mom,

Thank you so much for your sharing!!  It’s really inspiring!!

My son is at K2 now and is going to apply for primary schools later on.  He’s ok in learning, creative, curious but sometimes too active in behaviour.  He learns new things quickly, but easily gets bored with repetitive work (e.g. copying / writing / repeated calculations).  After he gets familiar with given writings / calculations, he would become reluctant to continue the same repetitive job and we need to try a lot of methods to make him proceeds.

I had been interested in RC.  But I got hesitation when I heard RC has a lot of repetitive writing
assignments.  I’m not only concerned if my kid would lose interest in doing assignments, but also afraid he might be labelled by the school as a naughty student in which case his psychological development may be risked.  So I think I have to asceertain carefully which kind of schools and which specific school would match him well.  I always know HKUGA is a very good school.  After reading your sharing, I've learnt much more about HKUGA!!  It seems that the school would allow more room for students' behaviour and has measures to control such behaviour without hurting students' feelings.  Perhaps, this is a measure of 'positive reinforcement'?.  I really like this concept!  For sure, I will help my kid apply for HKUGA!!

It's so nice to learn that there is school which could kindly understand and accept the non-regular behaviour of my kid.  Thanks God and Charlotte_mom!!

May God let all our kids have the best developments.


[ 本帖最後由 Sunnyland 於 11-7-12 21:50 編輯 ]

Sunnyland

May I ask if HKUGA has any support to gifted children?  For example, for children who are advanced in Maths, would the school provide corresponding teaching arrangement?

How strict is the school towards student behaviour / discipline?  Any room they provide to active / energetic students?

For RC, I heard that they have quite much "repetitive copying / writing" type of assigments.  Could any RC parents comment?

Thanks a lot for sharing!

Piyoma

港小的老師流轉快，不太穩定。