IB 係咪比較容易攞高分？定本身讀的都係尖子?

medicine

Poyau 發表於 21-7-20 10:53
DSE 日校生上年取5科5*+比例
與 IBDP 今年取滿分45比例相若

咩耶叫"取5科5*+比例"

Poyau

Band5 發表於 21-7-20 10:07
其實講幾多個狀元真係冇乜意思，如果DSE最高嘅grade係5星唔係5星星，咁DSE狀元應該會多過IB。

究竟DSE咩gr ...

DSE 日校生上年取5科5*+比例
與 IBDP 今年取滿分45比例相若

DSE 2020年 5科5*+
日校 579 / 44,127 = 1.31%
全體 584 / 50,809 = 1.15%

IBDP May 2021 滿分45
本港 130 / 2,193 = 5.93%
全球 1,155 / 87,307 = 1.32%

小時了了

medicine 發表於 21-7-20 10:39
覺得有個別會員,直接少少講,"自己的小朋友已/將考IB",我估,沒乜人會有意見.但偏偏在不同POST不斷以歪理或似是而非的詞語甚或至假設條件企圖去掩飾或淡化IB狀元汎濫以及分數過高的事實,這是咩耶思維/行爲?
PS:引用並不代表是指閣下

我仍然不斷重覆嗰句,  IB 係咁俾人插, 個人感受覺得好慘而已

Band5

小時了了 發表於 21-7-20 10:25
相信你 EK 爬文爬得少吧! 唔係個個讀 IB 必定有 40分 以上. 相信, 仍有IB 學生成績係 2X - 3X 之間吧! 真心 ...

**仍有lB學生成績係2X - 3X之間**

係，有網友講過唔係個個適合讀IB，如果佢哋讀DSE，話唔定多幾個DSE狀元！

medicine

PeterWong2021 發表於 21-7-20 09:17
香港IB 考生，近乎100% 取得入讀香港3大及世界各地大學入學資格，未聽過有IB 考生會要報SSSDP 或伸請NMTSS  ...

覺得有個別會員,直接少少講,"自己的小朋友已/將考IB",我估,沒乜人會有意見.但偏偏在不同POST不斷以歪理或似是而非的詞語甚或至假設條件企圖去掩飾或淡化IB狀元汎濫以及分數過高的事實,這是咩耶思維/行爲?

PS:引用並不代表是指閣下

小時了了

PeterWong2021 發表於 21-7-20 09:17
香港IB 考生，近乎100% 取得入讀香港3大及世界各地大學入學資格，未聽過有IB 考生會要報SSSDP 或伸請NMTSS 資助
唯一係報考國內大學確實有困難，因國內大學未必接受香港學生以IB 報讀 (香港是中國的!!)
反而海外其他國藉的外國人，可以用IB 報考內地大學
香港IB 學生，不能報考國內大學，只好退而去報長春藤盟校（Ivy League），可惜！

相信你 EK 爬文爬得少吧! 唔係個個讀 IB 必定有 40分 以上. 相信, 仍有IB 學生成績係 2X - 3X 之間吧! 真心想問問, 同一道理, 係香港讀 Band 1A 中學必定 DSE 成績一定高分?

呢個討論帖樓主孩子當年 IB 22分 https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3659709&highlight=IB 要報副學士 or CU scope

呢個討論帖 non jupas 分都唔太好的 https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3735384&extra=page%3D10

我印象中仲有幾個討論帖有請教 Non Jupas 課程 e.g. IB / GCEAL … 分數唔高問 EK 網友有無其他讀書出路. 我記得有一個帖樓主孩子 IB 分數又係好低, 其他網友你一言我一語, 令樓主好唔開心咁講 IB 低數莫非就無書讀要出來工作類似傷心說話, 我試吓再搵吓嗰個帖

我仍然嗰句, IB 係咁俾人插, 純個人感受覺得好慘!


大家作為家長, 作為父母, 作為爸爸媽, 最最最愛錫自己心肝寶貝兒女, 大家都想自己兒女條順啲, 好行啲. 選IB / GCEAL/ SAT/ AP / HD / Asso Degree / OSSD..... 又或者 DSE 家長都係咁樣看待自己孩子吧

利申: 孩子不是讀 IB 課程

Band5

其實講幾多個狀元真係冇乜意思，如果DSE最高嘅grade係5星唔係5星星，咁DSE狀元應該會多過IB。

究竟DSE咩grade等同IB同GCEAL咩grade幾時都係外國人話事，唔通人哋會話你香港學生比佢哋優秀？佢哋大學set到幾高要求都有過量嘅香港人報讀，兼且當佢哋唔夠錢時隨時又可以為你“降低”要求！

hkpapa852

PeterWong2021 發表於 21-7-20 00:30
用IB 成績報讀本地大學的本地學生，每年大學學費和用DSE 成績報讀本地大學的本地學生並沒有不同，一樣係有 ...

Non JUPAS 收生包括

1. 所有以非DSE 成績（如INDP, IAL……) 去報考既本地學生
2. 所由以AD/HD資格申請既本地學生
3. 所有係香港專上學府就讀緊其他degree課程申請轉科既本地學生
4. 持有香港永久居民身分以mature student資格入讀first degree既人

總之佢地全部都有一個共通點：擁有香港永久居民身分

咁點解唔可以有資助讀書？

但係要報SSSDP，申請NMTSS資助，兔試直升國內大學，反而未必有佢地份喎？

Ivan_s

joyce76123 發表於 21-7-19 16:49
正確講IB為部分人子女提供了一個同外國人公平的競爭分數，然後不公平的同大部分DSE生競爭本港學位，好比國 ...

父母覺得個dse制度有問題, 以考ib去追求公平對待自己子女真係無咩問題, 其實不太需要理會其他小朋友面對既問題...


根本香港學生好鬼慘, 語文中英都要勁, 已經比外國讀得辛苦! 點知仲要考個難d既dse, 同叻d既學生去比, 出黎既兢爭力又唔見俾ib好....

古語有云

if you can't beat them....join them

小時了了

Canada 有開中文科 ( Mandarin / Chinese) 科目嘅 IB 學校如下：
公立學校 (State Schools)
1) Britannia Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/school/000624/ & http://britannia.vsb.bc.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://www.vsb.bc.ca/School/directory/Pages/default.aspx

2) Cobequid Educational Centre https://www.ibo.org/en/school/002914 & https://sites.google.com/gnspes.ca/cecib/ib-courses-at-cec/cec-pre-ib
呢個 Shool Board https://ib.ednet.ns.ca/IB-in-NS/schools

3) Henry Wise Wood High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000954 & http://school.cbe.ab.ca/school/henrywisewood/Pages/default.aspx
呢個 Shool Board http://www.cbeinternational.ca/apply_fees.htm &  https://www.cbe.ab.ca/schools/school-directory/Pages/default.aspx & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/ & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/homestay.htm

4) John G. Diefenbaker High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000955 & http://school.cbe.ab.ca/school/johngdiefenbaker/Pages/default.aspx
呢個 Shool Board http://www.cbeinternational.ca/apply_fees.htm & https://www.cbe.ab.ca/schools/school-directory/Pages/default.aspx

5) Lillian Osborne High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/006389 & https://www.osborneschool.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://epsb.ca/schools/register/deadlines/ & https://epsb.ca/schools/goingtoschool/fees/ & http://internationalprograms.epsb.ca/internationalstudentprogram/schoolprofiles/

6) M.E. LaZerte High School https://www.lcc.ca/global-education/ib-diploma-programme & http://melazerte.epsb.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://epsb.ca/schools/

7) McNally High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000176 & http://mcnally.epsb.ca/
呢個 Shool Board  https://epsb.ca/schools/register/deadlines/ & https://epsb.ca/schools/goingtoschool/fees/ & http://internationalprograms.epsb.ca/internationalstudentprogram/schoolprofiles/

8) New Westminster Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/001188 & https://nwss.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://newwestschools.ca/our-schools/new-westminster-secondary-school/

9) Port Moody Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000428 & http://www.sd43.bc.ca/School/portmoody/Pages/default.aspx#/=
呢個 Shool Board http://www.sd43.bc.ca/Schools/SchoolSites/Pages/default.aspx

10) R.E. Mountain Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000148 & https://remss.sd35.bc.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://www.sd35.bc.ca/schools/secondary/

11) Richmond Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000322 & http://rhs.sd38.bc.ca/
呢個 Shool Board https://www.sd38.bc.ca/schools/secondary/Pages/default.aspx#/=

12) Ross Sheppard High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000162 & http://rosssheppard.epsb.ca/
呢個 Shool Board  https://epsb.ca/schools/register/deadlines/ & https://epsb.ca/schools/goingtoschool/fees/ & http://internationalprograms.epsb.ca/internationalstudentprogram/schoolprofiles/

13) Sir Winston Churchill High School, Calgary https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000130 & http://school.cbe.ab.ca/school/sirwinstonchurchill/Pages/default.aspx
呢個 Shool Board http://www.cbeinternational.ca/school.htm & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/apply_fees.htm

14) Sir Winston Churchill Secondary School, Vancouver https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000277 & http://go.vsb.bc.ca/schools/churchill/Pages/default.aspx & https://intered.vsb.bc.ca/year-long-study
呢個 Shool Board https://www.vsb.bc.ca/School/directory/Pages/default.aspx

15) St. Francis Xavier Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/001096 & https://www.dpcdsb.org/STFXS
呢個 Shool Board https://www3.dpcdsb.org/schools/school-directory

16) West Vancouver Secondary School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000358 & https://westvancouverschools.ca/westvancouver-secondary/
呢個 Shool Board https://westvancouverschools.ca/our-schools & https://westvancouverschools.ca/international/apply/ & https://westvancouverschools.ca/international/10-reasons-to-choose-west-vancouver/

17) Western Canada (Senior) High School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000177 & http://school.cbe.ab.ca/school/westerncanada/Pages/default.aspx
呢個 Shool Board http://www.cbeinternational.ca/school.htm & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/ & https://www.cbe.ab.ca/schools/school-directory/Pages/default.aspx#  & https://www.cbe.ab.ca/registration/fees-and-waivers/Pages/find-my-school-fees.aspx & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/ & http://www.cbeinternational.ca/homestay.htm

私立學校 (Private / Independent Schools)
1) Ashbury College https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000055 & https://www.ashbury.ca/bursaries

2) Branksome Hall https://www.ibo.org/en/school/001437 & https://www.branksome.on.ca/admissions/tuition

3) Brookes School Canada Society https://www.ibo.org/en/school/006561 & https://westshore.brookes.org/international-boarding-students/

4) Elmwood School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000103 & https://www.elmwood.ca/admissions/international-students

5) Glenlyon Norfolk School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000911 & https://www.mygns.ca/admissions/tuition-and-financial-support

6) Halifax Grammar School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000743 & https://www.hgs.ns.ca/admissions/tuition-and-fees

7) Lower Canada College https://www.lcc.ca/admissions/tuition-fees & https://www.lcc.ca/admissions/international & https://www.lcc.ca/global-education/ib-diploma-programme & homestay http://www.canadahomestaynetwork.ca/lcc.shtml ; homestay fee http://www.canadahomestaynetwork.ca/ServicesFees/Services&Fees_LCC.pdf

8) Ridley College https://www.ibo.org/en/school/041012 & http://www.ridleycollege.com/admissions/tuition--fees

9) St John's - Kilmarnock School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/001950 & https://www.sjkschool.org/admissions/tuition-and-fees

10) St. John's School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/004622 & https://www.stjohns.bc.ca/admission/international-applicants & https://www.stjohns.bc.ca/admission/tuition--fees

11) Stratford Hall https://www.ibo.org/en/school/001938 & https://www.stratfordhall.ca/admissions/tuition-fees

12) The York School https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000998 & https://www.yorkschool.com/admission/tuition--financial-information

13) United World College of the Pacific/Lester B Pearson https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000034 & https://www.pearsoncollege.ca/student-experience/admissions/

14) Upper Canada College https://www.ibo.org/en/school/000838 & https://www.ucc.on.ca/admission/affording-ucc

15) White Rock Christian Academy （基督教） https://www.ibo.org/en/school/051558 & https://wrca.ca/admissions/tuition-fees/

16) Pacific Academy （基督教）: https://www.pacificacademy.net/international-program & https://www.pacificacademy.net/homestay  

小時了了

IB Chinese B SL vs IGCSE second language Chinese https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3800493&fromuid=1539350

IBDP vs DSE https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3658964&fromuid=1539350

IB School in IB School in Canada BC省 www.bcaibws.com & https://bcaibws.ca/schools/dp-diploma-program/


IB School in Canada
https://www.ibo.org/programmes/find-an-ib-school/?SearchFields.Region=&SearchFields.Country=CA&SearchFields.State=&SearchFields.Keywords=&SearchFields.Language=&SearchFields.BoardingFacilities=&SearchFields.SchoolGender=

加拿大公立中學Canada Public School Boards & Priviate Boarding Schoolhttps://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3789614&extra=page%3D1&page=1

medicine

joyce76123 發表於 21-7-19 16:54
即係spcc學校讀IB班叻過讀DSE班？喇沙 皇仁尖子唔夠男拔尖子叻？

對於某啲以歪理盲撐某個觀點的會員,當睇唔到最好.

joyce76123

meimei小朋友 發表於 21-7-18 18:00
其實 IB 和 DSE 好難可以直接比較，本身讀IB班人已是尖子，成績當然高好多。其實大家有無諗過讀DSE 班學生 ...

即係spcc學校讀IB班叻過讀DSE班？喇沙 皇仁尖子唔夠男拔尖子叻？

joyce76123

Ivan_s 發表於 21-7-18 12:39
有人追求全港考生公平, 但實情係香港既考試制度, 令本地考生一直受到不公平既對待...

IB正正為子女提供左 ...

正確講IB為部分人子女提供了一個同外國人公平的競爭分數，然後不公平的同大部分DSE生競爭本港學位，好比國家乒乓球隊想出線代表國家打比賽的，一定自己隊伍里打贏先，如果係同香港隊或者其他國家隊打贏就可以出線代表國家，咁可能整隻隊伍人人都可以做到，你話其他隊員願唔願意呢

joyce76123

hkpapa852 發表於 21-7-19 15:02
香港堆大學, 對國際課程既收生要求, 其實一向都仲高過牛劍
香港MBBS收IBDP要43-45, 人地牛劍醫科可能40分都 ...

咁又唔可以咁样比较，外國好多國家地廣人少，與中國和印度尼兩國家考試制度的殘酷性冇得比，外國好多大學全球收生，尼個我啲又真係做唔到，，香港院校始終都一樣競爭大，IB又好，其他又好，都係收國際生一個途徑，但而家已經變成港人入院校的捷徑，又有限制，僅部分人有權讀。一些基層尖子升中時完全有能力入兩間直資，但因為經濟問題選擇津校，或者其他原因沒選擇這幾間的，咁就少左個機會。 如果此不公平只是屬於極少現象，當然翻不起浪花，始終是容易競爭的一條路只比少數人行，當得益人數量龐大到影響到DSE考生，咁其實也要預左會有好多人不滿，始終大部分市民子女是讀DSE。

hkpapa852

小時了了 發表於 21-7-19 14:14
MBBS 唔係我杯茶嘛, 孩子無本事啊. Non Jupas 唔係只係申請神科

香港堆大學, 對國際課程既收生要求, 其實一向都仲高過牛劍
香港MBBS收IBDP要43-45, 人地牛劍醫科可能40分都已收

所以有時拗嚟都無謂, 做人要多D留意週圍既嘢, 唔好只做夜郎