用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 特殊教育 Is band 1 school really 100% good for my kid?
發新帖
查看: 1999|回覆: 7
go

Is band 1 school really 100% good for my kid? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 1


14
1#
發表於 10-11-22 09:23 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印
Is Band 1 school 100% suitable for my kid?

On the release day of Points system for P.1, the night before that day, I was very nervous and could not sleep.  On that day at 7:00am, I started to check the result.  Until 9:00am, it was released and my son was successfully drawn to a band 1 primary school ranking  no.1 or 2 amongst the parents.  I was so excited and would like to tell everyone the good news.  I began to tell my son to make more effort on your study and hopefully he will  be successfully admitted to its secondary school, then HK University and to be a doctor, lawyer, etc.   In the Summer holdiay, I tried to teach him the P.1 Chinese, English and Maths.   At that moment, my son is very much obeyed to me and he sat every morning to learn the three subjects.  
In Sept , my son was very happy to wear the new uniform and studied in that school.  He took around 30-min rest only including taking bath and then immediately did his homework after back to home.  It generally tooks 45 ,mins - 1.5 hours to finish it.  He never leaves any homework to next day.  
Around end of Oct , the nightmare started to me and my son.  My son was complained distraction in the lesson by the class teacher.  Since my son  still has distraction  and he like playing.  On Feb next year, the teacher asked me to accompany him to have  evaluation and even asked me to give him medicine starting from April, then almost every month talked to me and my kid the same.  One time, she told my kid that mother gave harm to you without giving you medicine.  As a mother, I was really very unhappy and my heart is likely hurt by a sharp knife whenever I heard her words. I burst into tears at home every time after her words.  Starting from April, my son was daily punished with the same method - no playing in the recess time (it is very means for an active boy) - and standing in front of the blackboard when there is no teacher in the classroom (it  really deprived of his self-esteem).  My son started to change from a cheerful boy to unhappy boy in May, sometimes he kept quitely and suddently cried.  He started to easily lose the temper and scold his parents.   He like saying the word "dead" in Chinese and some strange behoviour also come out.  In P.2, he started not to pay effort on his study and would not like to do homework also.  He hate going to school.   Sometime he tried to beat himself and said he would like to die.  He is useless and he is not as good as others.    He did not like that school.  The teachers only punished.  There was no encouragemenet.  He could only hear scolding to him or to somebody else in the classroom.         
From then, I knew when selecting school, we must understand the character of the kid.  If the kid is active or has some obstacles, we should find a caring school in which the teachers would like to understand his difficulty and  pay some time  to teach him. If a school only concerns the academic result, it will give too much pressure for the kid and mum.  When you force the kid to do, there will be more argument on both of you.  Once you join the game, you also hope your son can keep the progress and would not like to fall behind. The importance is falling behind also giving the side effect on the kid with losing confident to keep progress.   More pressure and forcement will bring to the kid.
Also, the moral education is more important for P.1 to P3. that the academic achievement.  The kid understands his responsibility and arouse his interest in it.  He will push himself to do instead of being forced by mum.  Forcing only sustains for a short period.  If the kid is active and creative, the traditional school will block some of his merit.
Hopefully, all of you may find an appropriate school for your kid.  Your kid and  you are happy in there
   0    0    0    0

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1263
2#
發表於 10-11-22 14:40 |只看該作者
你的故事給了我們很大的啟發. 這和我所估計的一樣.

大部分主流小學都有一個重大缺點, 就係用一個倒模方式處理孩子.

普通孩子也會感沮喪, 吃不消, 學障兒更甚.

我親眼看到小一名校功課, 係一篇甚難背的唐詩.
孩子如果背誦能力高超, 考試分數超卓.

這亦是大部分自閉兒家長認為小孩係小問題/自傾.
這些孩子言語流利, 能安坐和聽指令.

可惜在社交班中所見, 有六歲大孩子每做一步都要問媽媽(聽指令行事). 有d 係望住導師等提示.

雖然滿足了主流老師的要求, 但其實係會越來越笨, 越來越無信心. 在我眼中, 這些缺乏思考能力的問題, 比起安坐和聽指令更為嚴重.

希望父母用一隻眼睛堅定地對應問題核心, 一隻眼睛緊盯着成效, 逐步地將死結解開.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3186
3#
發表於 10-11-22 18:23 |只看該作者
I heard a lot of sad school stories from my Heep Hong friends' kids. And is nightmare for a mum. I told my son when he grows up he should not be a primary sch teacher because some of them (for some reasons) have to be excessively harsh to their students.

Rank: 1


14
4#
發表於 10-11-23 08:28 |只看該作者
Hi,
Thanks for both of your feedback.
When selecting school, we must find a school suitable for the kid.  We should not keep our eyes closed to chase the famous band 1 school.  The importance is the teachers are kind, enthusiasm and  the students are with good moral.   Let the kid study in a comfort environment.  Once he is interested in school life, he will push himself to study.  
For the mums, we can put some effort how to teach how kid instead of having the pressure from teachers how to change our kid to fit the school' requirment.  Especially, in the band 1 school, all the mothers are very worried for the academic result.  They will gather out of the school when sending the kids to school.  They try to discuss what your teacher taught, what our teacher taught, how to write the Chinese word correctly as it is easily losing marks for the dictation, who got the high mark for the last test, exam..how to get pass paper from students older than our sons,..etc.  That kind of pressure I never find in my job to earn money.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3121
5#
發表於 10-11-23 09:52 |只看該作者
Hi,
How about your son's kindergarten life?  Happy?




原帖由 yyckmy 於 10-11-23 08:28 發表
Hi,
Thanks for both of your feedback.
When selecting school, we must find a school suitable for the kid.  We should not keep our eyes closed to chase the famous band 1 school.  The importance is the  ...

Rank: 1


14
6#
發表於 10-11-23 14:46 |只看該作者
原帖由 baubaulee 於 10-11-23 09:52 發表
Hi,
How about your son's kindergarten life?  Happy?


Yes, he is very happy in the kindergarden life.  Tha't s why it gave me a dream to take the top band 1 school  for Primary.  However, that kind of decision was totally wrong and gave much harm to my son.  It changed my son from a cheerful boy to another face.  I am not sure whether I can recuse him at the moment and how long he can get recovery.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1263
7#
發表於 10-11-23 15:11 |只看該作者

回覆 1# yyckmy 的文章

what is the diagnosis, ADHD or Autism?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3121
8#
發表於 10-11-23 15:50 |只看該作者
Don't worry, just give me LOVE, proper training/treatment, he will be cheerful and happy very soon.

Did teachers in Kindergarten give you any advice ?



原帖由 yyckmy 於 10-11-23 14:46 發表


Yes, he is very happy in the kindergarden life.  Tha't s why it gave me a dream to take the top band 1 school  for Primary.  However, that kind of decision was totally wrong and gave much harm to my ...
‹ 上一主題|下一主題