用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 國際學校 AIS vs ASHK vs Stamford 求用家經驗分享
發新帖
查看: 9566|回覆: 8
go

[其他] AIS vs ASHK vs Stamford 求用家經驗分享 [複製鏈接]

Rank: 3Rank: 3


141
1#
發表於 21-10-19 11:41 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印
因為小朋友對STEM較有興趣而我地又想培育佢係呢方面發展, 加上暫計劃日後去美國升學, 所以想小朋友讀美國際國際學校.
希望AIS/ASHK/Stamford Amercian用家分享下讀呢幾間學校嘅第一身經驗分享 (我都有睇每間學校website同睇舊BK 論壇, 但因有d文係較舊, 所以想要一d較近期經驗分享)

1) 學術方面
    - 上堂形式
    - 功課深淺程度 (對比其他IS/LS)
    - KG/Elementary level, middle school, high school
    - assessment 形式 (e.g. 多唔多test)
2) 師資 (e.g.教學有無愛心? 形式化?定真係做到student oriented?)
3) culture (e.g. 師生相處? 同學之間相處? 多唔多bully? 成績競爭係良性定惡性?)   
4) 疫情下上課安排
5) 同學多元化? (多內地生嗎?)

(以上只係我暫時諗到想多了解的地方, 歡迎分享更多你認為好與唔好的地方 :))


十分感謝!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


   1    0    0    0

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4119
2#
發表於 21-10-19 17:41 |只看該作者
manmankiss 發表於 21-10-19 11:41
因為小朋友對STEM較有興趣而我地又想培育佢係呢方面發展, 加上暫計劃日後去美國升學, 所以想小朋友讀美國際 ...
我可以簡單講講 Stamford。 我小朋友由 G4 讀到而家grade 8。 小學極少功課,基本上返到屋企都冇功課做。G6 中學開始忙, 差不多每日個幾兩個鐘功課, 示乎做得有幾仔細。


1. 功課深淺程度: 冇讀過其他國際學校同傳統學校比較唔到。不過 science /humanities 課程唔淺。 老師要求高, 要攞高分都要落唔少功夫。亦知道有同學要外補揾老師教功課或者要家長搵人幫手先識做。


每年2次MAP  assessment。平日好少test。間中有 Quiz。 成績表分數主要靠功課同project。

2) 師資方面: 大部分老師都持有碩士學位,亦都經驗豐富 。多數都係外國請返嚟。 之前有家長分享過覺得學老師係極度有愛心。 我自己極少同老師聯絡,所以無特別留意呢點。

3) Bully 每間學校都總會有個別例子,不過無發生喺我小朋友身上。 完全唔覺有成績競爭。 咁多年同學相處都好融洽。

4) 以前教育局宣佈停課嗰陣係 Zoom 全日。 而家已經全日回校上課。

5) 香港同大陸佔大部分, 當然亦有外國人。

我同你一樣都係想小朋友讀美制學校, 將來去美國升學, 但香港提供美制學校極少。ASHK 同 Stamford 課程應該幾相似, 不過學費較貴而且地點遠所以冇考慮。AIS 完全唔會考慮。Stamford 讀咗幾年我都好滿意,加上而家已擴建新校舍更加吸引。

Rank: 3Rank: 3


141
3#
發表於 21-10-20 10:20 |只看該作者
回覆 ckmammy 的帖子

多謝你嘅資料

想問多少少, 點解會話唔考慮AIS?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4119
4#
發表於 21-10-20 10:48 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 ckmammy 於 21-10-20 10:51 編輯
manmankiss 發表於 21-10-20 10:20
回覆 ckmammy 的帖子

多謝你嘅資料

主要係校舍舊,雖然辦學數十年,但不見得學術成績卓越。STEM 方面唔特出,無 IB。 一向比我感覺校風麻麻,唔知而家有幾好 ,所以寧願選新校都唔會考慮。

Rank: 3Rank: 3


157
5#
發表於 21-11-3 15:08 |只看該作者
想問下行美制中學,除咗呢3間仲有冇其他? Thanks

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4119
6#
發表於 21-11-3 15:20 |只看該作者
dreambk 發表於 21-11-3 15:08
想問下行美制中學,除咗呢3間仲有冇其他? Thanks
HKIS, ICS, Harbour school

Rank: 3Rank: 3


157
7#
發表於 21-11-3 18:06 |只看該作者
ckmammy 發表於 21-11-3 15:20
HKIS, ICS, Harbour school

Thanks, let me check them out

Rank: 3Rank: 3


120
8#
發表於 21-11-6 15:14 |只看該作者
我個仔仔剛剛入咗 AIS, 我好滿意, 我仔仔之前成日唔想反學, 但佢轉校之後佢返學返得好開心, 家長之間個個都好NICE. 老師又有愛心. 係 AIS 我學校比較舊DD, 因為佢有咁多年歷史. 但係咁我反而覺得更加似美國本土學校. 有一種總純樸的味道, 老實講, 如果而家反美國讀都真係E D STYLE.

Rank: 6Rank: 6


7743
9#
發表於 21-11-29 22:30 |只看該作者
manmankiss 發表於 21-10-19 11:41
因為小朋友對STEM較有興趣而我地又想培育佢係呢方面發展, 加上暫計劃日後去美國升學, 所以想小朋友讀美國際 ...

本帖最後由 conniewktang 於 21-12-2 20:25 編輯

My son’s amazing changes when he was in Grade 6 as a new student in ASHK

My son studied in a local Chinese primary school before, the best one in a district of Kowloon. His academic results were good in P5 as he once came first in form. However, with too much drilling in Primary 5, he lost interest in his studies though the school is a good one,and he was addicted to playing video games to reduce his pressure and anxiety. Because of COVID-19, we both stayed at home, I worked from home and he attended online lessons. We chatted more and he would like to have a change in his life as he disliked the local school system and he wanted to study in an international school for his secondary school life.
We like the American style of education and after getting a lot of positive comments from my son’s godmother who is a foreigner with clients’ kids in ASHK, I decided to apply for a place in ASHK only as it seemed to suit him well. ASHK has strong student support both academically and emotionally. Special care will be given to new students. The curriculum is well-designed and classes are taught by teachers with good qualifications. Also, students canlearn Chinese by using traditional characters. The best group in Chinese can use local Chinese textbooks but the writing is more demanding than most local schools. All these meet our requirements.
My son went to an interview in April 2020,and luckily, he passed the tests in English, Language Arts and Math. We were so delighted. He was admitted to Grade 6 ( first year of secondary school) of ASHK.
It’s just the beginning.
He met a very warm and caring homeroom teacher Ms Tara Store. She is so kind, patient, professional and hardworking. She could take care of the Grade 6 students well beyond our imagination. Her Science and Math classes are so inspiring and my son learnt quite a lot from her. My son learnt Newton’s three laws, periodic table, cell biology, and so on from Science class and some of these are only taught in Secondary Six of DSE in local schools. ASHK can also incorporate STEAM into the Science curriculum in which my son is interested. He designed a machine using Newton’s third law. I was amazed at how much he mastered over the year in terms of knowledge and soft skills needed in the future career. Every day, my son watched the special Math video prepared by Ms Store and he answered the questions one by one. He could progress very quickly. English class has also tailor-made to suit students’ need. Mr Arndt and Ms Curtis can teach students step by step to brush up their English level in modern literature. They have learnt how to analyse a book and he starts to love reading. Mr Arndt and Ms Curtis are so encouraging, their teaching methods can makestudents be interested in learning English.
Who says Social Studies is boring, Mr Mallary is a scholar who could make my son love History and work hard in it.
Mr Suleman is also a good teacher as he helped my son bridge the language barrier when he studies Social Studies and Science in Grade 6. He is really patient and helpful.
My son disliked learning Chinese Language in the local school, however, his interest in learning Chinese has been aroused in ASHK by Ms Emma. He loves learning Chinese now and his Putonghua proficiency has been improved rapidly as he has five Chinese lessons conducted in Putonghua every week.
My son has learnt how to use a computer to do the design work and appreciate art from Mr Poblador. He has learnt how to play the saxophone and compose music by using a computer from Mr Callan. He has also learnt how to stay healthy by learning different kinds of sports from Mr Segraves and now he plays basketball every day in school and loves playing sports. He has learnt coding from Mr Yue and is interested in it.
All the teachers in ASHK are nice and helpful.
One amazing thing is that students in ASHK have started to learn research methods in Grade 6. However, the local students are taught in the first year of undergraduate course in university. They have learnt the method of citation and how to quote information from the references.
In ASHK, my son reads more books and spends less time playing video games. He does not need to use gaming as a means to reduce his pressure in studies anymore as he did before when he studied in a local school. He has more time to develop his hobbies like basketball and photography.
I am delighted to see his changes and growth in ASHK and would surely tell all my friends about it.
I would like to say thank you to all the teachers in ASHK!
One more point, the students in ASHK are well-behaved and teachers will discipline them all the time. Some teachers are even stricter than the teachers in local schools like Ms Tara Store. Even though you are in school, if you enter the classroom late eg only 1 minute late as you go to your locker to get something without noticing the time, it will be regarded as being late.
My son is now in Grade 7 in ASHK. He goes to school every day happily.

‹ 上一主題|下一主題