有冇小朋友係黃懿倫處學鋼琴

kaka0814

Sindy,

我嘗試以我所知而答
1) 初學我覺得是由老師協助培養興趣, 而不是完全由老師培養, 家長和學生的素質是不可或缺的
2) 到你想找大師級的老師，我諗你少ｄ興趣去搵佢地，佢地都未必會收你。我自己也試過, 並不容易, 但有機會再講吧。
3) 不會, (衰D咁講), 你估0個 D 老師好得閒咩?! 唔令自己出名咁佢點開飯?! 所以, 絕大部份大師級的老師, 都一定要學生交足功課。你絕可以是但一個有番咁上下, 但係未去到大師級的老師試下。我深信, 就算只是管弦樂團的成員, 都一定會要求多多。

APA junior should also be teaching by professional teacher. 其實, 早排有家長話佢地係俾 讀緊 dip / 學位的學生教, 我都唔夠膽 sure... 因為我幾位朋友都係跟大師級的老師學 (以前), 就算依家剛剛考入去0個個都係跟Miss Wong 的。 如果 junior 都只係八級琴行老師, 我諗你點都唔信會有個張x晴。單是學生已經不止八級了，何況老師？！

不過，收費其實真的很貴。$2xxxx 其實是不足夠每星期上一課。我朋友以前要俾$600 一課給老師，相信現在應該不止這個數了。但他們己包括樂理＋聽音＋演奏＋樂團訓練。單是樂理一科，已經是教八級樂理範圍，就算在琴行學，也要$400一堂，何況是那些老師。

Sindy

kaka0814 寫道:
Sindy,

我嘗試以我所知而答
1) 初學我覺得是由老師協助培養興趣, 而不是完全由老師培養, 家長和學生的素質是不可或缺的
2) 到你想找大師級的老師，我諗你少ｄ興趣去搵佢地，佢地都未必會收你。我自己也試過, 並不容易, 但有機會再講吧。
3) 不會, (衰D咁講), 你估0個 D 老師好得閒咩?! 唔令自己出名咁佢點開飯?! 所以, 絕大部份大師級的老師, 都一定要學生交足功課。你絕可以是但一個有番咁上下, 但係未去到大師級的老師試下。我深信, 就算只是管弦樂團的成員, 都一定會要求多多。

APA junior should also be teaching by professional teacher. 其實, 早排有家長話佢地係俾 讀緊 dip / 學位的學生教, 我都唔夠膽 sure... 因為我幾位朋友都係跟大師級的老師學 (以前), 就算依家剛剛考入去0個個都係跟Miss Wong 的。 如果 junior 都只係八級琴行老師, 我諗你點都唔信會有個張x晴。單是學生已經不止八級了，何況老師？！

不過，收費其實真的很貴。$2xxxx 其實是不足夠每星期上一課。我朋友以前要俾$600 一課給老師，相信現在應該不止這個數了。但他們己包括樂理＋聽音＋演奏＋樂團訓練。單是樂理一科，已經是教八級樂理範圍，就算在琴行學，也要$400一堂，何況是那些老師。

thanks.

summer媽媽

我想回應APA junior 絕不會比  讀緊 dip / 學位的學生教的, as my child is an APA junior student, 我同入面好幾位老師都好熟的, so I am sure about this

Sindy

summer媽媽 寫道:
我想回應APA junior 絕不會比  讀緊 dip / 學位的學生教的, as my child is an APA junior student, 我同入面好幾位老師都好熟的, so I am sure about this

即佢地既資格係更高?

我想問

Smiile

小小題外話 : Sindy, 我很懷念您之前的大頭照 (即您囡囡穿芭蕾舞衣的相片那幅呢 !)

Smiile

Ruby1219

summer媽媽

I'm interested to know : what's the age requirement for APA Junior ? how old is your kid ? how do they admit the kid ?

Thanks,
Ruby

CSL123

kaka0814,

Do you know how many Junior students would be admitted by APA each year? Is the piano most competitive? If my sons are not under tuition of famous teachers, do they have small chance to get admitted to APA?  My friend's P.4 son who have grade 5 dist in clarinet failed in last year's admission in clarinet. What do you think the crux of talents would APA's dean look for? Do you think the auditon's two songs lasting for about 6 mins can find out the appliant's talents?  Do you know how APA select their Junior Programme tutor? From the prospectus, most of the tutors are graduated from overseas in music-are they really famous in their field?

If my sons are failed in this year's application in piano, do you think how to prepare them for next year's auditon? It seems that Ms. Wong was indifferent to my son's performance during audition. Sorry for so many questions.

kaka0814

Just for your information:
Some of my friend was Junior & Pre-Junior Student, I try to tell what's their major & grade & age when they got admitted.

10 years old, piano, grade 7
8 years old, piano, grade 6-7
9.5 years old, violin, grade 5
7.5 years old, clarinet, grade 3-4
8.5 years old, piano, finished grade 5 at 7 years old
I know some other friends / students in other instrument, but I am not sure about their age when admitted.

Grade in fact doesn't mean anything. They look for someone's quality rather than $$. 6 mins in fact is TOO MUCH for audition. Professional will be able to know whether you are really good or not in 5-10 seconds!!!

If you really want to prepare your sons for the audition, get a better teacher. They will not only telling you correct / wrong, but would be able to push children further up in understanding the pieces.

In fact, for APA, they usually look for younger students. One of my students who is going to apply APA next year is also playing Clarinet. He is right now in P.5, but surely he will be in around grade 8 in next Mar-April (Audition Time!). It would be hopfully he will be admitted, as in fact, I am not good to teach him further.

Sindy

kaka0814,
咁果兩首歌應點預備呢?thanks

kaka0814

一隻快一隻慢
不同時期 - 睇樂器啦呢個
不同作曲家
不同風格

仲應該準備埋viva voice
因為個考官隨時可以問野, 雖然機會好細

anyway, 你個老師應該可以幫你選到曲
如果選唔到, 我諗你可能要考慮第二位老師
呢 d audition 係咩時候都會遇到
應該唔會有問題

lulubabies

[quote]
kaka0814 寫道:

<你絕可以是但一個有番咁上下, 但係未去到大師級的老師試下。>~~
想找一個這樣的老師都不易...

<不過，收費其實真的很貴。$2xxxx 其實是不足夠每星期上一課。我朋友以前要俾$600 一課給老師，相信現在應該不止這個數了。但他們己包括樂理＋聽音＋演奏＋樂團訓練。單是樂理一科，已經是教八級樂理範圍，就算在琴行學，也要$400一堂，何況是那些老師。>~~
$2xxxx是一年還是一個月學費呢? 謝謝!

kaka0814

一年

但... 不是 52 個星期的
因為當中有聖誕/新年/復活同暑假
所以這些假期中上課是另需交費的

wanleung

kaka0814

想請教你我囝囝學琴己9 months, 佢先生use do re me fa so la ti teach him rather than use CDEFGAB.  請問有冇問題?  我覺得我囝囝唔係好色看譜(豆豉).  佢係use do re me fa so la ti 唱出來.  我覺得佢係記歌rather than 記豆豉.

pls help!!

Wanleung

CSL123

Thank for your information. Are you a clarinet teacher? Sure you are a wonderful music teacher!
Bytheway, my neighbour advises my P.2  son to learn bassoon. How can I find the bassoon teacher?  

kaka0814 寫道:
Just for your information:
Some of my friend was Junior & Pre-Junior Student, I try to tell what's their major & grade & age when they got admitted.

10 years old, piano, grade 7
8 years old, piano, grade 6-7
9.5 years old, violin, grade 5
7.5 years old, clarinet, grade 3-4
8.5 years old, piano, finished grade 5 at 7 years old
I know some other friends / students in other instrument, but I am not sure about their age when admitted.

Grade in fact doesn't mean anything. They look for someone's quality rather than $$. 6 mins in fact is TOO MUCH for audition. Professional will be able to know whether you are really good or not in 5-10 seconds!!!

If you really want to prepare your sons for the audition, get a better teacher. They will not only telling you correct / wrong, but would be able to push children further up in understanding the pieces.

In fact, for APA, they usually look for younger students. One of my students who is going to apply APA next year is also playing Clarinet. He is right now in P.5, but surely he will be in around grade 8 in next Mar-April (Audition Time!). It would be hopfully he will be admitted, as in fact, I am not good to teach him further.

哈里波特

APA told, they do not bound how many students they accept, only if they are qualified, they will accept them.  The teacher listed on the hand book, they will not use the teacher who is not on list.  However, the list for the coming year is not yet issued.  The recent hand book only shows the teacher on list during 2004-2005.

If you want to have higher chance to be APA student, besides the kid has performed very well in audition but better to seek a famous teacher.  

kaka0814

哈里波特 寫道:
If you want to have higher chance to be APA student, besides the kid has performed very well in audition but better to seek a famous teacher.  

這點也很同意, 名師總有他的原因。  

CSL123, please check your PM.

kaka0814

wanleung 寫道:
kaka0814

想請教你我囝囝學琴己9 months, 佢先生use do re me fa so la ti teach him rather than use CDEFGAB.  請問有冇問題?  我覺得我囝囝唔係好色看譜(豆豉).  佢係use do re me fa so la ti 唱出來.  我覺得佢係記歌rather than 記豆豉.

pls help!!

Wanleung

Wanleung,
是學鋼琴嗎 ?

那種方法叫 FIX-DO 方法, 就是把 C 唱成 Do, Re, Me, Fa, So...etc

當小朋友學習轉調時, 可能會遇上少少麻煩, 但卻會幫助小朋友的aural 部份。所以很難講有好還是不好，我有一個樂理學生也是從小開始使用Fix-Do, 對他來說, CDEFG 是麻煩的, 樂理的進度也有點困難, 但看來他的音準很好, 也唱得不錯。所以我深信這個方法對弦樂器和部份管樂也很有用, 鋼琴就好像還是用音名會比較好吧。

也許也應待其他音樂老師多給意見

wanleung

kaka0814

是學鋼琴.  我問了好多朋友, 佢d小朋友use CDEFGAB instead of Do Re Me Fa So La Ti!!!

Wanleung  

yuanli

請問:

有冇人真係試過請琴老師幫忙選曲和準備參加APA audition?
我這樣問的原因是萬一apa收了，即代表老師會少了一個學生，一般的鋼琴老師會這樣神心幫你，而倒自己的米嗎？

另外，請問apa的課程是幾多級開始的呢? I mean if my daughter 只係得一級，可否參加apa 的audition? 有冇這樣junior 的級別? if 冇，咁仲有咩途徑跟到一些大師級or famous teacher?

kaka0814 寫道:
一隻快一隻慢
不同時期 - 睇樂器啦呢個
不同作曲家
不同風格

仲應該準備埋viva voice
因為個考官隨時可以問野, 雖然機會好細

anyway, 你個老師應該可以幫你選到曲
如果選唔到, 我諗你可能要考慮第二位老師
呢 d audition 係咩時候都會遇到
應該唔會有問題

kaka0814

坦白講, 身為一個好的老師, 是應該有責任推薦自己的學生去給另一位(更好的)老師的。你沒理由看著學生的天份浪費了吧。

至於初級到甚麼程度會收, 我聽講過有人 grade 2 也被收了, 當然, 那個小孩子真的很年少, 好像只有五歲。

至於跟大師, 我自己的經驗也不算多, 主要也是請人轉介。也許你的琴老師可以給你一點意見。