約克,st cat及根德園, 你地點選

ac119

我聽人話, 根德園好,但是不是没德學普通話, 我個妹話st cat 的課程好淺. 但我看見好多朋友的子女都選st cat.

睇書同forum 又覺約克好似幾好, 大有好意見, 分析下.
我問老公幫個好考幾多間幼稚園, 佢話最多三間好,但我又怕未必收我個女. 考幾多間有保障一點??

請指教

mr_won9

我會這樣比較兩者:

st. cat 英語環境好,外藉老師較多,女仔較適合

根德好似冇外藉老師,較傳统,根基札實,適合升讀傳统学校

ac119

約克又如何呢, 小學我想考瑪利諾或DGS, 那如何選好

原文章由 mr_won9 於 07-8-16 12:15 發表
我會這樣比較兩者:

st. cat 英語環境好,外藉老師較多,女仔較適合

根德好似冇外藉老師,較傳统,根基札實,適合升讀傳统学校

mr_won9

原文章由 ac119 於 07-8-16 14:30 發表
約克又如何呢, 小學我想考瑪利諾或DGS, 那如何選好

York我冇留意,但想入果兩間英小,應選st. cat 或基督堂幼園了；但只收k2,你要做點功課了

annienorman

原文章由 mr_won9 於 07-8-16 18:39 發表


York我冇留意,但想入果兩間英小,應選st. cat 或基督堂幼園了；但只收k2,你要做點功課了

瑪利諾is by lucky draw, irrelevant to which kindergarten.

elainel_yll

我都覺得好難選擇

Luenluen媽

我都覺得很難選...too

fcatherinehk

kinlee，
多謝你寶貴既意見，
想請教：
１）如果呢３間ｋｇ，撇開英文科，其他科目深淺程度排序如何？
例如St. Cat既中、數比約克既，邊間深ｄ？

２）除左學術，學生既領悟力、理解力、表達．．．等等，呢３間ｋｇ既學生比你既印象如何？

原文章由 kinlee 於 07-8-17 03:18 發表
咁多位家長你地好，我本身做幼稚園的...........

你地所講0個3間幼稚園，我都有同佢地的學生補習

我個人認為，st. cat的確英文幾好，功課亦不是太多，但相對中、數就比較弱

York我個人認為課程太淺，較 ...

mr_won9

原文章由 annienorman 於 07-8-16 20:17 發表


瑪利諾is by lucky draw, irrelevant to which kindergarten.

可在第三階段叩門

fcatherinehk

ac119,
雖然呢３間ｋｇ都有好多位，我都打算報名，不過個人意見都係穩陣第一，搵定１、２間唔差而又大可能收既ｋｇ．試過有個媽咪只報了五間，但五間都係好多人爭既，唔好彩無一間有ｏｆｆｅｒ，之後個位媽咪好徬徨週圍搵學校，但剩餘的只有一些質素較差既ｏｆｆｅｒ了．

我ｔａｒｇｅｔ都係MCS�DGS，其實都唔係只得St. Cat�CCKG既女仔入到ＤＧＳ,我有個學生讀SPK都入到，佢間ｋｇ英文都唔深，只係佢媽咪自己教．另外都有協恩、Victoria既女仔考到．

係啦，可否交流下你個ｐｌａｎ係點呢？
近年都有GHS學生插MCS，所以我ｐｌａｎ定如果考唔到ＤＧＳ�抽唔到MCS,就考GHS/聖方濟各/St. Paul Convert/St. Jonnas，之後插MCS/St. Mary.

另外小女將於下學期入讀安基司國際幼兒班，全英語不過無中文，如果根德、York、St. cat、協恩唔收佢,就原校升Ｋ１，自己教佢中文，我見安基司都有學生升到德望應該都唔差．

你女女有幾多分？我女女有２０分，睇過今年結果，有不少２０分都抽到ＭＣＳ，希望到時我都可以咁好彩啦！
你住４１網？我住大埔，打算２０分唔得就搬去４１網抽Round 2．

原文章由 ac119 於 07-8-16 10:34 發表
我聽人話, 根德園好,但是不是没德學普通話, 我個妹話st cat 的課程好淺. 但我看見好多朋友的子女都選st cat.

睇書同forum 又覺約克好似幾好, 大有好意見, 分析下.
我問老公幫個好考幾多間幼稚園, 佢話 ...

[ 本文章最後由 fcatherinehk 於 07-8-17 07:51 編輯 ]

yoyobb

當然係 SC or KV

back up school先係york

littlekid

kinlee,

您說York的課程太淺，較難考小學，想問一問您是指那一部份太淺呢？

annienorman

原文章由 mr_won9 於 07-8-17 07:25 發表


可在第三階段叩門

To be honest, 叩門位好有限, normally less than 10, so don't expect too much, if you really need to go for 第三階段叩門, you need to equip you BB with few areas of strength e.g. art + sport + music....... and join more public competition or exams to make his personal file "beautiful"!

AnnLeung

原文章由 kinlee 於 07-8-17 03:18 發表
咁多位家長你地好，我本身做幼稚園的...........

你地所講0個3間幼稚園，我都有同佢地的學生補習

我個人認為，st. cat的確英文幾好，功課亦不是太多，但相對中、數就比較弱

York我個人認為課程太淺，較 ...

可否講詳細D,點淺法？和為什麼會較難考小學？難道唔讀KV /st.cat就考唔到好的小學？

87423A

I have two boys, one in SC & one in KV (graduated already), my opinions are:

Don't over-praise SC, if you set your expectation high, I think it will disappointed you. Curriculum is quite simple, always do dot-to-dot practice or coloring, I think a little bit hard to adapt to Primary school work.  (compare with my boys, apparently younger son from KV is much better to adapt to his P1 than his elder brother)

For English, SC k2-K3, NET not always in class, only attend when English lesson, Overall English standand OK la!  But also highly depends on what you feed your child after school, if you want your child to be more advance in English, solely depends on SC or their Sat Phonic lesson is not enough, I found that many SC student have  Chinese-English acent.

Teachers are nice, but 有一部份人興"送禮文化", esp in X'mas.......... may be "西化"

87423A

SC有D學生好有錢,compare屋企有幾多級樓梯!!!

Since curriculum is simpe and easy, so my boy is happy in SC.

KV not really so scare, but really good in Maths and Cinese, apparently my younger boy are good in this two aspect compare with his elder borther.  He has good displine and no need to worry homework at all.  So he can adapt well in his Primary.  For English, OK la, not so bad, as I also put my boy in NET playgroup, so English is not a problem for him.

------Two KG are good, depends on "what you want la!"

rainbowbb

how about Keen Mind ?