放棄 SPC 選 港同, 會有人支持我嗎?

cow

Dont' dream that any new style DSS schools is better than the traditional eltie schools.

After studying 6 years at an Elite English girl school, she will have a very good foundation in English.

Do you think the peagsus parents are happy about 臻美 taken over by 福建? Why did they prefer 福建?

easydad

Those who are concerned solely on brands, past school reputations and trying to rank schools in orders will never understand how others think.
  
Education is only a very small part of our life.  School names are not significant after a while.  Yet, the value and personality developed will be hard to change.  There are certain schools, regardless of how good they are academically, I will not consider.  I bet they are great school but I also see higher probability of being mentalily eroded (usually hidden very well).  A plus and a minus always come together.  Certain risks I don't mind taking.  Certain risks I will avoid at high cost.  (I am not taking about St. Paul Convent by the way.  This school is a good school but not the so-call top notch ones I have in mind.)

Just like restaurants, there are plenty around us.  We pick what we like.  No absolute right or wrong.

Yes, I may be dreaming.  Yet, at least, I still have a dream.  

[ 本帖最後由 easydad 於 10-12-13 14:37 編輯 ]

ricenoodle

Very often this kind of comparing of 2 schools thread cannot be objectively discussed as most of the replies are from both schools' parents.  No one will have a child studied in both schools before, right?

You have made your decision already, why care what others (such as your daughter's classmates' parents) think and say?  If you ask those SPN/ SPK parents, 99% will support SPC as their children have spent 3-4 years studying there, at least one of their purpose is to promote to SPC disregard some might end up in DGJS or SPCC (more demanding traditional schools).  

From your post, it is easy to tell when you hear people supporting HKUGA, you will feel relief that you have made the right choice for your daughter.  When you hear people supporting SPC, you will feel defensive and say how your girl doesn't fit SPC's style.  You have your answer right from the beginning.  

Just a side note, it is judgmental to say all SPC girls are under 1 style, which is bookworm.  I reckon there are more active talkative girls in school than sit still bookworms!  

Good luck!

ricenoodle

fujitasze,
That's what I think too.  When we compare a well-known school to a not so well-known one, many who cannot get into the well-known school will support the not so well-known school.  The majority enjoy seeing someone will give up a well-known school seat for a not so well-known one.  2 schools are totally different, cannot compare.
A note for clarification:  SPC is more well-known as it has longer history than HKUGA, that's what I mean, don't try to argue why SPC is more well-known etc...

原帖由 fujitasze 於 10-12-11 00:00 發表
School A is much much more famous than School B, academic result of School A is much much better than School B. . In this forum, I always hear that some parents would select School B because the schoo ...

motherotk

People standing in different positions with difference lens, so meaningless to compare...but still good to voice out opinions, do not interprete for others, only state your own opinions unless you have go through youself..

原帖由 ricenoodle 於 10-12-14 18:04 發表
fujitasze,
That's what I think too.  When we compare a well-known school to a not so well-known one, many who cannot get into the well-known school will support the not so well-known school.  The majo ...

yantabo

this topic is quite meaningful,as i am a new comer i can learn so much from each of u,everybody's opinion is worth for reference!!!

calcalcal

樓主：
自己想清楚就下定決心吧！
有時聽得太多人講反而重難決定！

cow

原帖由 ricenoodle 於 10-12-14 17:34 發表
No one will have a child studied in both schools before, right?

The answer is 'left'.

Sumyeema1

樓主已決定讀港同，作為外人，我們應尊重他/她的決定。 有時過分的比較兩家學校， 會造成無形傷害。

to 樓主，你是否已通知 SPC 小學部放位，相信 waiting list 上的小朋友會多謝你。

cow

SPC -> HKUGA (easy, especially if talking about HKUGA College)
HKUGA -> SPC (??)

CFaHB

我不是 SPC 學生家長 / waiting list 學生家長, 完全無利益衝突, 是以事實來提出意見

SPC 是一間非常優質的學校, 因"港同"放棄, 極是可惜 ...

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 10-12-15 11:03 發表
樓主已決定讀港同，作為外人，我們應尊重他/她的決定。 有時過分的比較兩家學校， 會造成無形傷害。

to 樓主，你是否已通知 SPC 小學部放位，相信 waiting list 上的小朋友會多謝你。 ...

Sumyeema1

我也覺得可惜。

現在唯有呼吁樓主盡早放 SPC 個位出來，等 waiting list 上的小朋友/家長受益。

artroboy

應該先試SPC, 唔得再考插港同,會否好 d 呢? 試都唔試就放棄...太可惜.  

原帖由 CFaHB 於 10-12-15 13:58 發表
我不是 SPC 學生家長 / waiting list 學生家長, 完全無利益衝突, 是以事實來提出意見

SPC 是一間非常優質的學校, 因"港同"放棄, 極是可惜 ...

ricenoodle

motherotk,

That's what I am doing here, stating my own opinions and thoughts.  

原帖由 motherotk 於 10-12-14 21:44 發表
People standing in different positions with difference lens, so meaningless to compare...but still good to voice out opinions, do not interprete for others, only state your own opinions unless you hav ...

[ 本帖最後由 ricenoodle 於 10-12-15 16:00 編輯 ]

Crabmeatsoup

SPC的確是一間很好的學校。尤其是轉了直資後﹐家長和同學質素也提高了很多。在我心中﹐SPC 和港同是有很大距離的。放棄SPC實在好可惜﹐請三思。

[ 本帖最後由 Crabmeatsoup 於 10-12-15 23:03 編輯 ]

youma

原帖由 Y2KChild 於 10-12-15 19:06 發表
我本來短期內不想在BK發表意見，但眼見樓主的決定對女兒影響深遠，不得不發表一些自己的心得及意見。

首先很欣賞樓主凡事從女兒着想出發，希望為女兒找到合適女兒特質的學校，而不是盲從品牌。

可是在作出選擇之前，必先作出 ...

Good Analysis!

學術相差一截, 再加上spc的舊生和家長網絡,...
如果係我, 根本不用考慮, 一定選spc.

Crabmeatsoup

十分同意﹗ 非常客觀和全面的分析。

原帖由 Y2KChild 於 10-12-15 19:06 發表
我本來短期內不想在BK發表意見，但眼見樓主的決定對女兒影響深遠，不得不發表一些自己的心得及意見。

首先很欣賞樓主凡事從女兒着想出發，希望為女兒找到合適女兒特質的學校，而不是盲從品牌。

可是在作出選擇之前，必先作出 ...

sheep30

Can't agreed more! Detailed and excellent analysis.

原帖由 Y2KChild 於 10-12-15 19:06 發表
我本來短期內不想在BK發表意見，但眼見樓主的決定對女兒影響深遠，不得不發表一些自己的心得及意見。

首先很欣賞樓主凡事從女兒着想出發，希望為女兒找到合適女兒特質的學校，而不是盲從品牌。

可是在作出選擇之前，必先作出 ...

newbkmember

SPK is very difficult to get in.  SPC is also very difficult to get in if you're not from SPK.  Take this opportunity to learn more about this school, a few years later, you'll have more concrete information to decide which type of school suits your girl.