民生result - 民生書院幼稚園

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1021

1^#

發表於 09-12-12 11:42 |只看該作者 |正序瀏覽 |打印

Just get the reject letter!

0 0 0 0

bobechristy

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1650

165^#

發表於 09-12-23 21:10 |只看該作者

For York & Stafford, I have chosen Stafford b4, just bcoz when York increase the school fee, its similar as stafford (3000 to 3600monthly), but stafford has net teacher all day while york just 25 mins per day ....

For MS & Stafford, now I will choose MS, since MS is one dragon, if I have MS primary school offer, I can still appy for other private school ..... its safe for me

Also , MS do has net teacher for english, 45mins per day (4 days a week) , & 3 days PTH ..

ofcoz for the school fee , is huge different from stafford, 800x10 annual MS, 3700x12 annual for stafford + many other fee .....

I have asked Stafford, the mis fee is around 2000 now, but my friend last year just paid 1450 .... so I think they increase sooo much ...

I paid reg fee for MS, and I saw many extra activities on Sat of MS .... so I think its good school ....

Its my concerns for your reference ..... ofcoz I do think for higher english level, should be stafford , but after 3 yrs, I need to worry again ...

原帖由 frogma 於 09-12-23 14:05 發表
Hi Bobechristy,
I have also got the offer from York, Stafford and ManSang; personally I like Stafford much better than others. Given Mansang is a one dragon school, how will you choose?

catlam1314

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	397

164^#

發表於 09-12-23 15:35 |只看該作者

My boy performed similar as your girl, but we got a reject letter, even it is not under waiting list.

I believe it is by Lucky Draw now.

原帖由 frogma 於 09-12-23 14:17 發表
I think family background doesn't count a lot for Mansang as both of my husband and are neither professionals nor alumni. We have no connection about this school. My girl is a super small baby 0712, ...

frogma

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	128

163^#

發表於 09-12-23 14:17 |只看該作者

I think family background doesn't count a lot for Mansang as both of my husband and are neither professionals nor alumni. We have no connection about this school. My girl is a super small baby 0712, Mansang gives her am class offer. I think Mansang prefers children with good discipline and friendly attitude. In the interview day, my girl was very shy, it needed some time for her to warm up before she could answer the questions. She did OK, as most of the kids. I guess my girl could get the offer becasue she did very good "after" the formal interview, i.e. Q&A session. The teacher was observing her and other kids in the table play. I was talking with another kid next to me, my girl talked to the kid beside her, she said "hello" and waved her hands a few times with the kid next to her. Then, she shared her toys with the kid later. I saw the miss (interviewer) smiled at her. Also, my girl was well behaved even though other kids take away her toys. So, I guess Mansang like well-behaved kids.

frogma

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	128

162^#

發表於 09-12-23 14:05 |只看該作者

Mansang vs Stafford

Hi Bobechristy,
I have also got the offer from York, Stafford and ManSang; personally I like Stafford much better than others. Given Mansang is a one dragon school, how will you choose?

SNOWPUI

Rank: 4


	626

161^#

發表於 09-12-21 23:14 |只看該作者

原帖由 B.B.BaBa 於 09-12-15 17:00 發表
有乜可能 lucky draw 呢？

我唔知佢地把尺係點，但始終都會有佢自己的一套準則。

大家覺得自己個小朋友 interview 表現好好，其實已經好叻了，大家記得要讚下個小朋友。 ...

點解? 因為小朋友interview時, 連老師叫佢個名都唔知, 無反應, 甚至其實一條問題都無睬/答過老師! (老師是說普通話的)
我自己亦因為老師~ 一來唔記得左in我地, 二來原來要講普通話而嚇傻左, 表現好差
不過收左, 第一志願, am class...

如果有尺, 那把尺當天一定"壞"左

講出事實真相都只係想大家分享下~

[ 本帖最後由 SNOWPUI 於 09-12-21 23:18 編輯 ]

conniew117

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1648

160^#

發表於 09-12-15 21:52 |只看該作者

坦白講, 每間學校一定有長短. 視乎家長你自己點幫小朋友去行佢地既路.

基本上, 到時你去考任何直資或其他私學就無人會理你. 學校無互通既network. 但係如果K3你放棄可以上民小既機會, 就可以去玩大抽獎. 而你去外面考直資是收了你的話, 你一樣無得玩大抽獎.

原帖由 bobechristy 於 09-12-15 17:36 發表
我想問　YORK/STAFFORD 同民生簡，會讀邊間? d 朋友話民幼考出面直資唔夠　．．．．　

但民小係唔係一間好私校？　因學費一ｄ都唔平呀！　

民幼ｋ3時上民小，如果肯要番，係唔係冇散機會考其他直資／私校？　 ...

bobechristy

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1650

159^#

發表於 09-12-15 17:36 |只看該作者

我想問　YORK/STAFFORD 同民生簡，會讀邊間? d 朋友話民幼考出面直資唔夠　．．．．　

但民小係唔係一間好私校？　因學費一ｄ都唔平呀！　

民幼ｋ3時上民小，如果肯要番，係唔係冇散機會考其他直資／私校？　

B.B.BaBa

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	7728

158^#

發表於 09-12-15 17:00 |只看該作者

有乜可能 lucky draw 呢？

我唔知佢地把尺係點，但始終都會有佢自己的一套準則。

大家覺得自己個小朋友 interview 表現好好，其實已經好叻了，大家記得要讚下個小朋友。

SNOWPUI

Rank: 4


	626

157^#

發表於 09-12-15 15:13 |只看該作者

原帖由 rubyrubylau 於 09-12-15 15:09 發表
因三年後又要考私小同直資, 我覺得我個仔同我都不是太LUCKY的人, 其實我在民生返更PLAYGROUP, 第二期都話收我, 但我收到RESULT後唔JOIN LA, 因我覺得小B好喜歡返民生, 唔知係咪有我陪. 我唔想返了一年後小B不在此讀 ...

大家唔好咁, 我諗真係唔關大家本身既事, 可能真係lucky draw

rubyrubylau

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1160

156^#

發表於 09-12-15 15:09 |只看該作者

因三年後又要考私小同直資, 我覺得我個仔同我都不是太LUCKY的人, 其實我在民生返更PLAYGROUP, 第二期都話收我, 但我收到RESULT後唔JOIN LA, 因我覺得小B好喜歡返民生, 唔知係咪有我陪. 我唔想返了一年後小B不在此讀書而唔開心, 真的不是因為佢唔收我才不JOIN, 因佢PLAYGROUP教的好好.

我有PLAYGROUP +有1個表舅父+1個表衣民生幼至中畢業+表衣現在在民生幫忙做英文戲劇翻譯都係WAITING LIST. 我都無話可說, 可能係我媽媽IN得唔好啦.

原帖由 fishmaruko 於 09-12-15 12:29 發表
why do you say if you study at York, 3年後又來失落LA. ???

conniewww

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	212

155^#

發表於 09-12-15 14:57 |只看該作者

AM offer (Mar 07) too.

原帖由 tinghinmama 於 09-12-15 00:18 發表
today got the letter....
:) PM offer ( Mar 07)

fishmaruko

Rank: 4


	692

154^#

發表於 09-12-15 12:29 |只看該作者

why do you say if you study at York, 3年後又來失落LA. ???

原帖由 rubyrubylau 於 09-12-14 16:36 發表
阿仔又係WAITING呀, 只有YORK收咋, 好失落呀. 馬鞍山靈糧, 根德園, SC, 同民生都WAITING呀. 如果讀YORK, 3年後又來失落LA.

BBG1

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3555

153^#

發表於 09-12-15 11:36 |只看該作者

我個女果日in得好差都有waiting(我唔會寄回條去lu!)！我想問其實有無人收reject letter架！

NICOLE123

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	7794

152^#

發表於 09-12-15 10:44 |只看該作者

係架.其實我覺得有好多學校係睇家長
唔一定話係睇你做咩住邊
可能係睇你既衣著, 答問
好多時問題唔係出係小朋友身上
家長應先自我檢討

如果發現自己都無問題
未自可以講天外有天,人外有人

我識人作哂假地址,職業....問卷搵埋人幫手.最後...reject..so..

conniew117

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1648

151^#

發表於 09-12-15 10:41 |只看該作者

其實, 討論區之前大家都有討論過, 每一間學校收生一開始就會鎖定佢地既目標家長&小朋友. 好多家長常常話自己小朋友表現好又唔收; 表現唔好就收左. 有時, 小朋友既表現只係佔一部份, 家長既表現都同樣重要. 唔收都唔駛失落, 反正你都有SC這個OFFER.

原帖由 21oct07 於 09-12-15 09:27 發表
完全認同--失落

我哋嗰日in得都好好, 我以為會收, 點知係唔收, 仲話如果想做waiting 就要填番張回條寄返去先可以waiting, 我老公好好笑咁話: 我哋唔恨讀呢間, 好彩我哋都交咗sc留位費.

今年開始搵幼稚園時都充滿信 ...

21oct07

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	236

150^#

發表於 09-12-15 09:27 |只看該作者

完全認同--失落

我哋嗰日in得都好好, 我以為會收, 點知係唔收, 仲話如果想做waiting 就要填番張回條寄返去先可以waiting, 我老公好好笑咁話: 我哋唔恨讀呢間, 好彩我哋都交咗sc留位費.

今年開始搵幼稚園時都充滿信心, 因為我囡囡唔怕陌生人, 又識講好多嘢, 1歲多啲就比佢返學, 基本上啲面試都無咩問題, 面試表現都ok, 但真係唔明點解會唔收或waiting 囉, 當收到呢啲信時個人好無信心，好down, 慨嘆香港小朋友嘅競爭由細細個已經開始咁激烈, 真係慘

原帖由 rubyrubylau 於 09-12-14 16:36 發表
阿仔又係WAITING呀, 只有YORK收咋, 好失落呀. 馬鞍山靈糧, 根德園, SC, 同民生都WAITING呀. 如果讀YORK, 3年後又來失落LA.

jean2003

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	203

149^#

發表於 09-12-15 09:24 |只看該作者

原帖由 mimimomo6 於 09-12-15 07:43 發表

唔會掛, 攪珠??? 咁得左係咪 = 中六合彩呀 ??:D

....要唔要東叔出山呀...
"嘟~嘟~嘟~......嘟~嘟~嘟~嘟~嘟~" (六合彩背景音樂)
The first draw number is.................. your son
The second draw number is.................. your daughter

mimimomo6