St Clare (聖嘉勒) vs S K H (聖公會幼稚園)

aerogeo

Scenreio as follows, pls comment.
(1) Our girl gets an offer in SKH kindergarten (聖公會幼稚園) am class.
(2) SKH is closer to walking distance from our home while St Clare pm near Bonham Road
(3) No P1 connection for SKH while 80% connection for St Clare's to St Clare Primary.
(4) Difference: SKH, no more 學卷, ie paying 2.6k per month.
(5) St Clare, 有學卷……no need to pay
(6) Clare Primary is a private for 6 years, which is a good backup school
(7) With St Clare, school bus is 1K per month hence 1.6K difference between SKH (on foot) and St Clare

aerogeo

原帖由 aerogeo 於 14-07-07 發表
Scenreio as follows, pls comment.
(1) Our girl gets an offer in SKH kindergarten (聖公會幼稚園) am c ...

Sorry, moved back to Kindergarten discussion forum. Please comment St Clare Primary if possible.

Jane1983

St Claire小學要交學費，錢系咪考慮的重要因素？

你一心大抽獎，定系想考私小直資？

ffaye

原帖由 aerogeo 於 14-07-07 發表
Sorry, moved back to Kindergarten discussion forum. Please comment St Clare Primary if possible.



  ...

My niece studies at st Clare primary now. I compared their syllabus with another 津校 and their materials are more difficult, especially English. Nowadays dragon schools is more attractive than most famous schools. Although st Clare is no longer a full dragon school, it's still higher chance to get into st Clare primary.


Their kg syllabus is also getting more difficult in the last couple years and no need to worry about the gap between government subsided kg and private primary school.

Skh is a very good school too but the P1 allocation quite rely on the parents because they are alumni of the famous primary schools. Given st Clare is also a band 1 school, I would say st Clare is a better and safer choice.

Siusammama

Agree. My vote goes to St Clare

NatalieBaby

which  school net you live in

aerogeo

Net 11

NatalieBaby

原帖由 aerogeo 於 14-07-11 發表
Net 11

St Clares primary (Bonham Rd) and secondary school (摩星嶺) 是好学校 但要考慮咗校車時間和車站位置, 有些小朋友最終想唔掂校車所以放棄学位. 讀佢幼稚園無非想升小一secure些. 如你住 Net 11咁選St Clares 好似好些, 雖唔比大抽奘但你可考直資私校. 除非自問女兒超醒有信心考到神校咁就好似skh每年都有d考到(but not sure because of connection or not), 否則st clares已經不錯.

NatalieBaby

況且讀sc你可照考私直.

NatalieBaby

另你想抽sacred heart pm or st Stephen girls of net 11?

NatalieBaby

自行你又有幾多分和哪一間

doggy2013

原帖由 aerogeo 於 14-07-07 發表
Scenreio as follows, pls comment.
(1) Our girl gets an offer in SKH kindergarten (聖公會幼稚園) am c ...

of course st clare

ffaye

啱啱响fb見到d數據可以俾你參考下。2008年出生( 今年升小一)有 78751人。2011年出生有955XX,將會係戰況最激烈的一年。如果無25分，無connection, 到時真係要好好運。

14-7-11 13:12 上傳

下載附件 (92.25 KB)

kyleebc

兩間都喺好學校，明白樓主好難揀。試考慮以下：
1 st Clara是女校，適合你個孩子嗎？我覺得可能對性格發展方面有少少影响
  （但不一定的）。
2 SKH講明冇保證入邊間小學，嗰份心理壓力你會怎樣處理？你會為阿女怎樣
安排？唔讀SKH會不會好後侮？(尤其喺上午班？）SPCC的校長正是𠳔哋校監，你是否認同其理念？

LPN

如女的話，個人選擇St. Clare.

利申：小兒讀聖公會

kyleebc

回覆 LPN 的帖子

Hello.  剛剛完成K1.  仲派埋成績表，班主任提K2會陸續多功課。

neogeo1111

原帖由 ffaye 於 14-07-11 發表
啱啱响fb見到d數據可以俾你參考下。2008年出生( 今年升小一)有 78751人。2011年出生有955XX,將會係戰況最激 ...

這個數據很重要！

ffaye

原帖由 kyleebc 於 14-07-12 發表
回覆 LPN 的帖子

Hello.  剛剛完成K1.  仲派埋成績表，班主任提K2會陸續多功課。

St clare這幾年已經把課程調深。早幾年的k2是沒有默書的，但今年k2下學校已經有。目的是要跟st Clare primary課程拉近，將之前的差距收窄。

mouse_tomato

ffaye 發表於 14-7-13 18:47
St clare這幾年已經把課程調深。早幾年的k2是沒有默書的，但今年k2下學校已經有。目的是要跟st Clare prima ...

St. Clare 今年K2 無默過書，只係認字。但聽聞有家長去教育局投訴，連今年K3下學期中已經無再默書 (上學期仲有默)。
基本上課程係深過以前，日日都有功課做。

mykate

原帖由 mouse_tomato 於 14-07-14 發表
本帖最後由 mouse_tomato 於 14-7-14 14:05 編輯

K3 唔系冇，系改變形式