呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx - 課外活動

登錄 | 註冊

討論區

教育王國: 教育講場; 使用意見

幼兒教育: 幼校討論; 幼教雜談

小學教育: 小一選校; 小學雜談

中學教育: 升中派位; 中學交流; 初中教育

專上教育: 備戰大學; 選科選校

國際教育: 國際學校; 海外留學

知識增值: 課外活動; 教材閱讀; 公開考試; 深造進修

特殊教育: 特殊教育; 資優教育; 自閉寶寶; 智能評估

徵求專區: 二手市場; 誠徵老師; 組班專區; 徵保母車

聯絡管理員

我的中心

教育王國 › 討論區 › 課外活動 › 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx ...

樓主: Bluestar	go 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx [複製鏈接]

Bluestar

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3163

21^#

發表於 06-9-2 19:29 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

YMO,

If your intention is to shed some light, in order to arrive at a more balanced view, please then answer my questions truthfully.

Without your contribution(s), there can be no balanced view.

返回頂部

Bluestar

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3163

22^#

發表於 06-9-2 19:34 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

markwomom,

How long would you expect the journey from Kln City to the "teacher"'s studio ?

How long beforehand should we start off from home would you consider it respectful to such a wonderful "teacher" ?

Furthermore, it is not the basic question.

Don't try to divert attention away.

The fact is, the only thing we learnt was the degree of professionalism of that "teacher" !!

返回頂部

Bluestar

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3163

23^#

發表於 06-9-2 19:38 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

premum2006,

In fact I am already attending to this (tackling the basic "problem"), thanks for your concern.

返回頂部

markwomom

民房

Rank: 1


	6

24^#

發表於 06-9-2 20:30 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

Bluestar 寫道:
markwomom,

How long would you expect the journey from Kln City to the "teacher"'s studio ?

How long beforehand should we start off from home would you consider it respectful to such a wonderful "teacher" ?

上那一小時堂, 遲了半小時, 就是用來 "懲罰" 那位 "不合資格"的老師....

, 佢唔值妳準時上堂?

論點夠新鮮....

本末倒置, 沒人關心妳應預早多少出門, 最重要是否準時到達。

返回頂部

Bluestar

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3163

25^#

發表於 06-9-2 22:20 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

markwomom,

I will never be as expert as you !!

But I'm learning, I'm learning.

返回頂部

YMO

民房

Rank: 1


	3

26^#

發表於 06-9-2 23:52 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

I think you totally miss the point and lean your ladder on the wrong wall...let me get this straight and share my views to all involved in this post so far...

I do think the session is useful as the teacher tried to break down the Chinese writing skills into different sets of pattern and asking kids to practise...the key thing is active participation and practice...if you do follow his instructions and his way of organising a Chinese character...you'll going to find the beauty of wrting some decent Chinese..ideally, you have to accompany the kid so that you know the tactics on-site...so, to me, participation is the gist...and don't expect the teacher has a magical ward to change your kid upside down after 10 sessions or so....at least, this is how I found....my kid does enjoy...I found his way of teaching is fine, at least for the moment...

I'm not going to answer your long-winded questions in your orignal mail (honestly, I thought I was on a trial in the courtroom rather than a BK forum)...as I do think it is not focus of this discussion...no one is interested in any sequence of events nor the exact conversation took place that day....I just want to contribute my views from a different perspective...so that other parents do have a more informative platform to decide...

Do I need to take an oath?!!! Just kidding....

返回頂部

Bluestar

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3163

27^#

發表於 06-9-3 01:04 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

Very well then, to boil it all down to 1 thing :

[size=large]If as you said being a 親子班 a parent MUST attend classes with the kid, why should this "teacher" still collect the fees $$$ and let my son attend such a class without beng accompanied by a parent, if he knew for sure, beforehand, that it would not be possible for there to be any progress / only possible for very little progress without a parent attending the class together ?

That "teacher" never insisted.

So as you said, in order to be fair, with you being the only adult in that room apart from the "teacher", you are the only one who can shed some light on what trasversed and all its hidden meaning.

As for the "break down the Chinese writing skills into different sets of pattern", that is only what you can find in any book on Chinese writing, not his invention.

I do not expect to find Merlin in Kln Bay, just an ECA teacher who teaches what he is supposed to be teaching instead of one who chats like a C9 in a market.

返回頂部

KWT

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1414

28^#

發表於 06-9-4 11:07 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

我想分享去年暑假兩個仔仔參加中國鋼筆字班經驗.

因為仔仔老師說他handwriting差,故上年暑假在一非弁利社區中心報讀鋼筆字班(與另一機構合辦,並不是太平洋...,該機構派員到社區中心教授,)費用每人大約$180-$250(忘記收費),另教材費$80.結果上了四堂,開始時每人派了一本像小學用的啡色部,然後每次上堂派一張A4紙,紙上得幾隻字,算是教筆劃,與坊間隨手可買到的教寫字書一樣(因為熟口熟面,自己都好似有一本,不過,不敢查證,免得跟仔仔發牢騷,影響學習),然後叫仔仔描寫.最後兩堂,如果仔仔不上堂,就一個學生都沒有.上完course,結果一無所得,今年仔仔寫的字,仍舊很難看.所以若要學書法,一定要有口碑,而怎樣才算寫得好字?又很主觀.

返回頂部

梁媽媽

大宅

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3764

29^#

發表於 06-9-10 22:51 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

呢位老師, 真係唔好再比小朋友去讀, 對小朋友的負面影響 , 唔係用學費可以對比。
(乜野自信心都冇晒)

梁媽媽

返回頂部

Boliviaisrael

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	212

30^#

發表於 06-9-10 23:19 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

這位梅ＸＸ老師，知否何謂(有教無類)呢？唉！

返回頂部

brown

民房

Rank: 1


	6

31^#

發表於 06-9-11 01:14 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

遇著人之患，真的很可怕，金錢損失了故之可惜，更重要是傷害了小朋友的自信心。

我也有一個不好的經驗，女兒女跟隨一位女老師習琴數月，近數堂女兒不想再學；因我是在職媽媽，每次由工人姐姐帶去，我曾經帶她去，但老師說不可在門外等 (在3/F, 要到G/F等)，到接放學時，我早5分鐘到，看不見老師，到夠鐘才見她拿著水回來，當時只想她是去了廁所，現在回想起來半小時課，我見到的也不見了5分鐘，是"吞pop"還是去廁所？怪不得家長不可在門外等!
話說回頭，再同女兒了解不學琴的原因，她只說不想學，雖然是課外活動，也不想她做事可半途而廢，我致電老師問清原因，老師說早一堂時她學學下，自己落地行個圈，所以給老師罵，女兒便哭了，我再問女兒是否這原因給罵一次就不想學，女兒說是老師不知去了那裡，等了很久，不知是否已完課，落地想出門口看過究竟，剛巧老師回來，就被責罵。很了解女兒，她是很服從老師的，不會無故的落地行個圈，是否這老師"吞pop"後還罵女兒，已心裡有數。當然現在無學啦，但已經大大打擊了女兒(她是很薄皮的小孩)的自信，到現在還不願再學。盡責，有愛心的良師真的很重要!

返回頂部

豬mailmail

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	142

32^#

發表於 06-9-11 09:12 |只看該作者

Re: 呃$書法班 - 九龍灣太平洋xx中心，烈x書藝，梅xx

這個老師實在太過份了　

brown 寫道:
遇著人之患，真的很可怕，金錢損失了故之可惜，更重要是傷害了小朋友的自信心。

我也有一個不好的經驗，女兒女跟隨一位女老師習琴數月，近數堂女兒不想再學；因我是在職媽媽，每次由工人姐姐帶去，我曾經帶她去，但老師說不可在門外等 (在3/F, 要到G/F等)，到接放學時，我早5分鐘到，看不見老師，到夠鐘才見她拿著水回來，當時只想她是去了廁所，現在回想起來半小時課，我見到的也不見了5分鐘，是"吞pop"還是去廁所？怪不得家長不可在門外等!
話說回頭，再同女兒了解不學琴的原因，她只說不想學，雖然是課外活動，也不想她做事可半途而廢，我致電老師問清原因，老師說早一堂時她學學下，自己落地行個圈，所以給老師罵，女兒便哭了，我再問女兒是否這原因給罵一次就不想學，女兒說是老師不知去了那裡，等了很久，不知是否已完課，落地想出門口看過究竟，剛巧老師回來，就被責罵。很了解女兒，她是很服從老師的，不會無故的落地行個圈，是否這老師"吞pop"後還罵女兒，已心裡有數。當然現在無學啦，但已經大大打擊了女兒(她是很薄皮的小孩)的自信，到現在還不願再學。盡責，有愛心的良師真的很重要!