用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 幼校討論 青衣LH (pm 英普) vs 民生pm
發新帖
查看: 2726|回覆: 15
go

青衣LH (pm 英普) vs 民生pm [複製鏈接]

Rank: 4


757
1#
發表於 18-12-17 18:54 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印
本帖最後由 nightstalker 於 18-12-17 18:55 編輯

青衣LH (pm 英普) vs 民生 pm
家住青衣, 男仔
雖然學之園課程似較優勝, 似較有機考到1st tier 小學 如男拔 spcc yw
但怕做唔到精英 最後小一考唔到比民小更好既小學
好難揀請賜教
   1    0    1    0

Rank: 3Rank: 3


155
2#
發表於 18-12-17 19:05 |只看該作者
nightstalker 發表於 18-12-17 18:54
青衣LH (pm 英普) vs 民生 pm
家住青衣, 男仔
雖然學之園課程似較優勝, 似較有機考到1st tier 小學 如男拔  ...

唔使諗,當然係MS

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3400
3#
發表於 18-12-17 20:02 |只看該作者
Ms for sure

Rank: 4


503
4#
發表於 18-12-18 08:11 |只看該作者

回覆樓主:

有龍校ㄧ定揀,免卻好多煩惱及擔憂

Rank: 4


911
5#
發表於 18-12-18 09:44 |只看該作者
我會揀LH
1) 語境好
2) 雖然未必入到1st tier 小學,但民幼都未必上到民小 (青衣英普班好難入, 你小朋友應該好smart)
3) 屋企住青衣,交通時間短

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3695
6#
發表於 18-12-18 09:45 |只看該作者
LH係好...不過都係要經考小學呢一戰.....
MS就起碼85%可以上民小.....

不過睇下你目標

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1586
7#
發表於 18-12-18 10:20 |只看該作者

回覆樓主:

如果心儀民小(尤其係讀完LH都打算去考民小),當然先入民幼,85%直升機會總比公海考入民小大。
另外,可考慮下,除左民小,仲有無其他心儀小學,會否願意為民小放棄其他心儀小學(雖然民幼亦可考直私,但我覺得龍幼生考小未必有大優勢,除非小朋友係非常出眾)

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1474
8#
發表於 18-12-18 10:39 |只看該作者
xoshan1025 發表於 18-12-18 09:45
LH係好...不過都係要經考小學呢一戰.....
MS就起碼85%可以上民小.....
MS係小學預留85%位比其幼稚園, 正確來說, 應該係大約70%MS幼稚園生可直升小學。

Rank: 4


757
9#
發表於 18-12-18 17:04 |只看該作者
謝謝意見
冇話特別心儀邊一間
不過官津就冇行, 兩公婆都係得廿分
直私方面會覺得top tier 果幾間如spcc, yw, 男拔, tsl 會較佳
只係如果揀LH 就要全獸咁谷
黎緊果2年半要地獄式訓練
雖則睇返上年青衣LH升小成績確實不錯
8x graduates 有3x 人入到top tier 果幾間
不過我覺得小兒係有d小聰明但未至於最top 果浸
至少未係有耐性咁睇書 (甚至齋掀都冇耐性掀完一本)
要係2年半內成功改造非易事
唔知LH既功力勁d定阿仔既魔性勁d la

如果aim 2nd tier 直私仲不如民生算

唔知咁樣分析是否正確

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1586
10#
發表於 18-12-18 17:40 |只看該作者
nightstalker 發表於 18-12-18 17:04
謝謝意見
冇話特別心儀邊一間
不過官津就冇行, 兩公婆都係得廿分

你是否LH現讀生?
不要期望LH(或其他幼稚園)可幫你'改造'一個小朋友,學校可提升小朋友既學習興趣,但閱讀方面,始終靠家長伴讀去培養小朋友閱讀習慣先最實際。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3448
11#
發表於 18-12-18 18:30 |只看該作者
我會揀ms, 想入1st tier, 讀邊間都要再額外努力架啦。係ms努力完,入唔到1st tier 都仲有70%上小學。LH真係出公海

Rank: 4


572
12#
發表於 18-12-18 19:01 |只看該作者

回覆樓主:

https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3722702

Rank: 8Rank: 8


18325
13#
發表於 18-12-18 19:16 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 73662710 於 18-12-18 19:23 編輯

No matter how great your ambition is, MS is still a better choice!
During the first round of P1 place allocation, MSPS gives around 230-240 places to MSK., this figure approximates to around 70% of MSK students. As some of those with MSPS offers may go to other dss/private/government/subsidized schools, in order to fulfill the promise of 85% places to be given to MSK, MSPS will admit more students from MSK in the second round. Let's say 15% of MSK students will go to other schools, and 70% of them will go to MSPS, around 15% will have no offers and will join the lucky draw in June. This is just my estimation, but I do think it is very close to the true figure.
Concerning the competitiveness, its a matter of the backup from families rather than which school kids are from. During the first round interview of P1 admission, teachers will choose a few hundreds out of a few thousands in a couple of minutes, so they will delete those who are shy, not outspoken, academically apparent to be not good. The naughty ones will be kicked out immediately no matter how clever/smart he is. As there are too many applicants, the teachers will screen out as fast as possible without checking which schools the kids are from. At the second in, excluding 2-3 schools, the academic standard of kids will be checked, the kindergartens again is not important. So, at the end, the performance of kids matters the most!

No matter in LH or MS, if you want your kids to go to top schools, both parents and kids need to work very hard.

LH have better support for P1 applications while MS has none as most of its students will go to MSPS.

Idont know the curriculum of LH, for the one in MS, I think the level of difficulty is appropriate and the workload is not heavy。

Put me in your shoes, I will choose LH as you are livng in TY.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


407
14#
發表於 18-12-18 22:51 |只看該作者
wg_ann 發表於 18-12-18 10:20
如果心儀民小(尤其係讀完LH都打算去考民小),當然先入民幼,85%直升機會總比公海考入民小大。
另外,可考 ...

其實點解咁多家長都覺得龍幼考小一會差,其實唔少龍幼生考到唔錯既offers!! 仲要係神校或其他一線小學!

我小朋友雖然唔係讀民幼,但民幼真係唔錯,我一定會㨂民幼!

Rank: 4


757
15#
發表於 18-12-18 23:13 |只看該作者
回覆 73662710 的帖子

Thanks for your insight 🙏🏻
Not LH student at the moment so I m not familiar with its curriculum as well

I also need to take my younger daughter into consideration.  It seems that the top tier primary would be down to 2-3 if looking at mixed gender ones (spcc, tsl, cky)

Maybe MS is a more reasonable pick for us by comparing the 70% p1 direct placement versus 4-5% admission by the top tier ones

How's the chance of younger sibling being accepted by MS kg? Any advantages? I heard that the kg would place sibling at waiting list regardless of how outstanding they were during interview 🏳

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1912
16#
發表於 18-12-19 07:15 |只看該作者
本帖最後由 nhi 於 18-12-19 07:23 編輯
nightstalker 發表於 18-12-18 23:13
回覆 73662710 的帖子

Thanks for your insight 🙏🏻

The first round admission is based on performance of students, not taking into consideration the influence of siblings. During the period of call waiting, priorities go to siblings. As the smart kids usually have quite a few offers, at least 2 classes of students ( I guess) will reject msk offers, so the chance of siblings being accepted is quite high.
‹ 上一主題|下一主題