SC 英普PM VS 民生AM

Rainman319

多謝大家嘅提點 我當然唔會傻到以為揀sc 等於有神校， 揀民生就一定長龍直上 揀邊一間都需要家長同埋學生一齊努力，我發問係想多啲用家或者過來人俾啲意見同埋提點；魚與熊掌，我真心相信各有優劣，亦無一間會有一面倒嘅優勢。Anyway, 真心感謝各位，亦希望大家理性討論，我會好好消化各位的訊息，作出對自己、對仔仔最適合嘅選擇

RunningPig

我阿仔個年 DBSPD 無見過從 MS 來的，當然我唔知係好少 MS 學生報，還是好多報而唔收。

EggEgg08

common_cat 發表於 17-12-10 02:59
St. Catxxx開埋Harbour Place, kowloontong多咗好多位了, 可能仲多過 MS. 真擔心步Vict後塵, 甘多位, 神校 ...

St Cat K1一級有 7xx人，可在教育局網頁見到資料。所以其實一級好多人的。比MS多超過一倍學生。

Lingfung813

sure MS

DengCK

Rainman319 發表於 17-12-10 13:03
多謝大家嘅提點 我當然唔會傻到以為揀sc 等於有神校， 揀民生就一定長龍直上 揀邊一間都需要家長同埋學生一 ...

我有LH英普 vs MS pm

我相信我會放MS
因為我偏向新派學校如CKY

73662710

DengCK 發表於 17-12-10 13:57
我有LH英普 vs MS pm

我相信我會放MS

其實我也心儀CKY當年問過一個CKY 很有名的用家家長（他有blog, 網上可找）
所以放了 SC and KV.


當然自己也想保險些！

DengCK

73662710 發表於 17-12-10 14:12
其實我也心儀CKY當年問過一個CKY 很有名的用家家長（他有blog, 網上可找）
所以放了 SC and KV.

所以你是target cky但選了民幼？

73662710

DengCK 發表於 17-12-10 14:38
所以你是target cky但選了民幼？

Yes i am
Not decided yet
As MS is a very good school already, but I want my kid to study in a more relaxing environment and we shall apply only through train dragon schools later. It drives me crazy when reading some posts saying their kids are band 3 students even with an average score of 80+.

I don’t think MS students are in any inferior position when applying for primary schools compared with other famous Ks. But still it is very difficult to get in those famous schools and interview performance is very unpredictable.

MegaKnight

DengCK 發表於 17-12-10 14:38
所以你是target cky但選了民幼？

中學嘅話，兩間都Band1，不過一間C，一間B，睇你口味。

73662710

MegaKnight 發表於 17-12-10 14:57
中學嘅話，兩間都Band1，不過一間C，一間B，睇你口味。

The pressure on learning is enormous in HK, so our first priority is to choose full dragon or at least half dragon schools.
CKY is a local international school with some inborn defect compared with those international schools, but where Chinese culture is still preserved, emphasized and  respected.

MS is a big school with good environment, less pressures is encountered when considering promotion to primary and high schools.  DSE result is in a very secure band 1 B and approaching to band 1 A position.

novelle

回覆 RunningPig 的帖子

去年應該都收了2-3個， 但真係有唔少冇報，或者報咗都冇考...

DengCK

sweetbride119 發表於 17-12-11 04:00
LH 英普好進取，可以考好多直資啊，睇返升小成績教唔錯。

係，特別係語境呢樣，屋企俾唔到，所以我好重視。而且讀左幾個月LH，老師校長都好好，小朋友又讀得好開心。

pat1668pat

73662710 發表於 17-12-10 15:11
The pressure on learning is enormous in HK, so our first priority is to choose full dragon or at lea ...

CKY is not international school, it is private independence school instead.

73662710

pat1668pat 發表於 17-12-11 08:39
CKY is not international school, it is private independence school instead.

The system is more or less the same.

pat1668pat

73662710 發表於 17-12-11 08:41
The system is more or less the same.

The student mix is totally different

70% foreign:30% local - IS

70% local:30%foreign - PIS

73662710

pat1668pat 發表於 17-12-11 08:45
本帖最後由 pat1668pat 於 17-12-11 08:45 編輯

The student mix is totally different

I agree So I emphasize “ Local” international school.

pat1668pat

73662710 發表於 17-12-11 08:52
I agree So I emphasize “ Local” international school.

CKY is a very good school anyway

keikolau

pat1668pat 發表於 17-12-11 08:53
CKY is a very good school anyway

如果想讀cky，我諗讀SC係咪好過LH?我識舊年SC K3家長，Cky收左好多SC學生。