深圳摘星2025DSE成績

PTL_L

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 15:27
Hk govt 一定要將non jupas IB al 嗰班原生已經係for 銜接海外大學嘅學生入讀本地大學比重大副降低到最多一 ...

師兄，今次非常認同你不過我會建議non jupas位唔洗減少，只要班local student 又讀IB IAL既，一律收國際生價錢，一來揀讀另一學制既家庭，個個都認為家境富裕，一定係俾得起而讀既，所以用國際生價錢交本地大學費用，對於佢哋係冇壓力！二來，揀讀呢兩個學制原定係for海外升學，但用local身份起香港讀又太優惠喇，令到班父母1516，如果可以收國際生價錢，其實係促使班父母更加大決心俾小朋友出國讀書，咁就更能有效發揮開設海外課程既目的！

mcl233

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 15:27
Hk govt 一定要將non jupas IB al 嗰班原生已經係for 銜接海外大學嘅學生入讀本地大學比重大副降低到最多一 ...

無忘初衷？IB AL原意係為提供多一個繁學制比放洋生，冇人提好多年啦喎，仲拎出黎翻叮？～～～

ireneyklo

cclemon2009 發表於 25-8-8 13:22
我記得之前網上曾經有一封信有關釐清香港本地生的信件，共同聯署簽名並發送到政府部表達意見，但真係記不 ...

是一班家長自己發起的，他們找立法會議員，在立會提出，不然政府和教育局都不做野，真係要多謝他們。但可惜當時本地家長不是太在意，不是太多家長參與。

KikiDaddy

mcl233 發表於 25-8-8 15:52
無忘初衷？IB AL原意係為提供多一個繁學制比放洋生，冇人提好多年啦喎，仲拎出黎翻叮？～～～
...

The Dual Curriculum arrangement for DSS schools is supposed to be a transitional measure when the NSS / DSE was introduced as some prarents raised the concern about the recognition of the new system by overseas universities.

This interim policy should have been abandoned after the NSS / DSE is widely recognised by the international community. Right now many local students applying local universities via Non JUPAS is not aligned with the original intention of the policy.

ireneyklo

Dylanli2017 發表於 25-8-8 07:07
我有網上睇過新聞報導，新聞報導過佢只是廣東省內生源，所以，睇下資料再評論。我肯定是信新聞多過你講。 ...

新聞可以只給他們想你知道的事，你不信可直接上去深圳摘星今年招收２６年那屆的考試場地，有時要親自去探究一下。

KikiDaddy

KikiDaddy 發表於 25-8-8 17:32
The Dual Curriculum arrangement for DSS schools is supposed to be a transitional measure when the N ...

Many "new school" DSS schools obviously cannot handle the Dual Curriculum arrangement as their DSE results are just medicore and even worse than other similar banding Aided schools.

happyjaguar

ireneyklo 發表於 25-8-8 17:29
是一班家長自己發起的，他們找立法會議員，在立會提出，不然政府和教育局都不做野，真係要多謝他們。但可惜 ...

希望本地家长接力把SBA公平性再争取一下吧。否则从未有过SBA的自修生平白获得15%-50%分数，太不公平了。

Nbranson

KikiDaddy 發表於 25-8-8 17:32
The Dual Curriculum arrangement for DSS schools is supposed to be a transitional measure when the N ...

to be fair......  when parents opted for "International schools" "International Baccalaureate", I don't think their intentions were to be enrolled to local uni right?  The mission statements of the establishment made it clear the international schools are to facilitate expat to have their kids seamlessly to move on to foreign uni upon their graduation from the international schools.  Why do HK uni need to entertain them while more and more competent dse jupas students are striving for the HK uni Bach degree needless to say including the medical dental.... Major

Nbranson

KikiDaddy 發表於 25-8-8 17:44
Many "new school" DSS schools obviously cannot handle the Dual Curriculum arrangement as their DSE r ...

It is the costs and audit requirement of ib which prohibited the schools to have dual stream.... To be honest average IB score of 36 among all esf schools don't sound too impressive for their so called IB students.  When you look at the local uni degree the avg 36 scores entitled to, they are comparable to average band 1a 1b local schools.... An average band 1a school in hk has avg 10 students joining medical schools every year...... (Needless to say the spcc has avg 30 to 40 entries every year) When you look at the total number of medi acceptance esf schools have every year they don't outperform la.

poonseelai

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 18:18
to be fair......  when parents opted for "International schools" "International Baccalaureate", I do ...

ESF mission:
https://www.esf.edu.hk/vision-and-mission/

CDNIS mission:

https://www.cdnis.edu.hk/about-cdnis/vision-missions-values

CIS mission:

https://www.cis.edu.hk/about-us/mission-values

None of these mentions destinations of further studies.

UniKitty

關於DSE自修生，有家長建議對19歲以下首次參加DSE考試的學生，要求使用英文卷應答。這樣對日校生沒有影響，對本港自修生影響有限，還可以堵大陸自修生漏洞。不知各位有何看法？

Nbranson

UniKitty 發表於 25-8-8 18:46
關於DSE自修生，有家長建議對19歲以下首次參加DSE考試的學生，要求使用英文卷應答。這樣對日校生沒有影響， ...

如果司法覆核一定輸，香港嘅本地生都可以選擇用中文作答啦。雙非兒童喺香港法律上同本地出生兒童係冇分別。

Nbranson

poonseelai 發表於 25-8-8 18:36
ESF mission:
https://www.esf.edu.hk/vision-and-mission/

You r right. 英童教育的《一九六五無教育政策白皮書》
2.2 一九六五年，根據《一九六三年教育委員會報告書》（註10）及《英童教
育檢討小組報告書》，政府發表了《一九六五年教育政策白皮書》，作為規
英基學校協會於一九六七成立
2.3 因應《一九六五年教育政策白皮書》的建議，《英基學校協會條例》在
一九六七年制定，而英基是根據該條例成立的。

The establishment of esf was based on the education needs of the expat from UK and other countries as outlined in the 1965 white paper while I think the preference to take IB instead of DSE exam made it clear the intention is to pursue study abroad as Local uni have never confirmed IB is the preferred exam standard over or on par with DSE?

KikiDaddy

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 18:18
to be fair......  when parents opted for "International schools" "International Baccalaureate", I do ...

International schools are different from local schools. They charge very high tuition fees and do not receive any subsidy from HK government. Their students apply for local universities via Non JUPAS is no difference from overseas students.

DSS schools are different. They are in fact local schools for local students receiving government subsidy. They are allowed to offer dual curriculum just because of the new NSS /DSE was new to overseas universities at that time and it is already a history. No offence, but some DSS schools seems to be giving up the DSE curriculum and delivering mediocre examination results. If a DSS school cannot achieve decent results for both curricula, EDB should consider to deprive its dual curriculum right. It can choose to continue receiving government subsidy and offer DSE or transform to a private school like CKY and offer IB/IAL. Otherwise, it is just wasting the government subsidy for the 2/3 DSE students.

mcl233

KikiDaddy 發表於 25-8-8 17:32
The Dual Curriculum arrangement for DSS schools is supposed to be a transitional measure when the N ...

咪講左無忘初衷囉，不過，現在已經變成行山徑，可以走一條平穩之路，反正都可以去到目的地～

KikiDaddy

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 18:33
It is the costs and audit requirement of ib which prohibited the schools to have dual stream.... To  ...

DSE and IB are totally different and you need to hire two separate teaching teams for the two curricula. Only SPCC, DBS and SSC can deliver good results for both curricula due to their superior student intake and extremely rich resources.

DSE/IAL dual curriculum is easier to handle. In fact, a Band One DSE student is capable of preparing IAL by self study with some support from tutorial centre.

Vincegogogo

而家先知道，摘星創始人之一，經常開直播的駱老師，是DGS和CUHK畢業生。

UTB

「摘星」廣告在部分社交平台下架　議員稱若涉影子學生當局會懲處
https://news.rthk.hk/rthk/ch/component/k2/1817218-20250807.htm

名為「摘星」的內地補習機構，聲稱與本港私校崇正中學合辦中學文憑試DSE課程。教育局回覆指，並無收到相關營辦學校或開辦教育課程的申請，勸喻家長及學生，切勿上當，誤信可以「假學生」身分符合居港規定，局方正採取適當的執法行動，並已聯絡崇正中學負責人要求交代事件。

「摘星」近日在內地社交平台刊登招生廣告，聲稱位於長沙灣的崇正中學是「摘星」的「香港校區」。廣告指，招收對象是中四至中五學生，聲稱可為他們提供升學路徑，在校中六學生可用「學校考生」身份報考DSE，每年學費16萬至19萬元，上課時間連同課後託管為早上8時至晚上8時，又聲稱計劃與香港酒店合作提供住宿，每月額外費用1萬元。

本台其後發現，有關宣傳在部份社交平台已經下架。本台就事件聯絡「摘星」及崇正中學，暫未有回覆。

教育界立法會議員朱國強表示，考評局早前修訂內地自修生報考本港DSE的規定，要求他們持有學校提供的學歷證明，內地補習社難以安排學生以自修生身份報考DSE，因此懷疑有人利用迂迴方法讓學生透過本港私校取錄，從而取得本地日校考生身份。

朱國強又說，如果相關學生根本沒有來香港上課，就牽涉「影子學生」問題。若事件屬實，相信教育局會按嚴重程度，作出懲處。

聖士提反堂中學校長麥偉麟表示，近年內地家長對本港學制的了解加深，他們大多掌握一定資訊，才為子女來港報讀學校，相信今次事件對這批家長影響不大。他相信教育局會認真處理今次事件，否則可能影響香港教育制度的公信力，令外界留下不好印象。

poonseelai

Nbranson 發表於 25-8-8 19:10
You r right. 英童教育的《一九六五無教育政策白皮書》
2.2 一九六五年，根據《一九六三年教育委員會報告 ...

ESF's change to IB - also no mention of study abroad:

https://www.scmp.com/presented/news/hong-kong/education/topics/esf-first-50-years/article/2115915/ib-journey-which-leads
"After more than four decades of offering the UK’s GCE A-level curriculum, the English Schools Foundation’s (ESF) transition to the International Baccalaureate (IB) system, which began in 2004, was a strategic move designed to provide students with a broader and more internationally focused education."

"In early 2000’s, ESF saw the need to offer a more international curriculum in view of changes in their student demographic."


"While the old curriculum had students learning about the Vikings and Victorians, the IB focused more on having students acquire and improve important skills to make them life-long learners. "Ever since we started adopting inquiry-based learning, our students have built stronger links with the local community and care more about environmental issues,"

poonseelai

UTB 發表於 25-8-8 20:25
「摘星」廣告在部分社交平台下架　議員稱若涉影子學生當局會懲處
https://news.rthk.hk/rthk/ch/component/ ...

我見到只要求日校生身份, 無居港日數要求, 真可以部分時間香港上课, 部分返內地上課