討論完結, 謝絕留言, 謝謝 !

ddmmyyyy

like_travel 發表於 12-2-15 13:59
i did some survey.... most 叻學生 (academic within top ten with sport / music awards but did not get ...

like_travel,

from another topic your said that:

"sorry, my daughter also be top three student always, she also got 2 swimming medals (HK Inter-Primary School swimming competition) + english speech solo verse (champion, HK Inter-Primary School -Speech Festival), piano solo (second place, HK Inter-Primary School Music Festival), Australian math (distinction) etc.
During the process of interview, i was strongly senses that they are only interested to take the elite student, if your kid without any special skill, they will not place an offer for your kid, that's what i want to say. 教育唔應該係咁

My daughter will receive 2 DSS offer (u have mentioned above) because i got their phone for verification."

So, did you r daughter get the offer from HYS?

santander

原帖由 mgtmgtmgt 於 12-02-15 發表==

santander

原帖由 ohnono 於 12-02-15 發表
呢d可能被阿媽阿爸所累都唔定！

==

ohnono

santander 發表於 12-2-15 18:14
有無咁多呢種父母

又要父好，又要母好，又要學生好，都唔難揀！

like_travel

回復 vanover 的帖子

i like the result

mgtmgtmgt

其實協恩未轉值資前, 都將家長及同學玩弄, 年前有位同學運動成績不錯, 學界有獎, 學業區內band1頭, 協恩一值將她當作後備之選, 不正面回覆, 只說有位通知她, 害她差點放棄區內自行分配名校學位.  同時, 協恩絕對是一所好講關係的學校, 年中拍肩頭入讀, 大有人在.

ohnono

如果out of ten係名小學都唔差架！

like_travel

i like the result

mgtmgtmgt

回復 like_travel 的帖子

吾出奇, 有前科, 是鐵一般事實, 您地放心, 協恩好快會反"dau"您地, ,所以話協恩最鍾愛搶同鬥囉

ohnono

mgtmgtmgt 發表於 12-2-15 18:37
回復 like_travel 的帖子

吾出奇, 有前科, 是鐵一般事實, 您地放心, 協恩好快會反"dau"您地, ,所以話協恩 ...

所以協恩真係好唔成熟，明知要反"dau"，做乜要網上公佈呢。全部用信件，甚至先電話後信件，分批或階段取錄。這樣好比自己也給別人有下台階！而家真係回頭我也不愛他！

cellon

tiffanytc 發表於 12-2-15 16:37
不過我認為就算讓那些top10 的學生入協恩，他們也不會入吧！

說對了。

不只是家長這樣想，小學老師也會這樣勸。派六年級上學期成績表時，老師都對家長說，要小心衡量，值不值得為某間直資而放棄入讀成績和環境更好的官津學校，尤其要留意一些成績正在退步的直資中學。

esmond88

正在退步的直資中學 =  HYS ?

jessc

有個case仲得意，話說三年前某校有個成績中規中矩(不知名次)的同學被協恩收左(而家仲讀緊)
但之後試過仲正, 收左個考第100名的

當然兩個都有體育成績做support.

like_travel

jessc 發表於 12-2-15 19:30
有個case仲得意，話說三年前某校有個成績中規中矩(不知名次)的同學被協恩收左(而家仲讀緊)
但之後試過仲正, ...

How strong their sport performance is ? Would you tell us more detail , pls?

like_travel

avon888 發表於 12-2-15 16:55
我仔仔的同學,她由p1-p6都是全級第一。她面試完第二次試, HYS 已暗示收她做學生。同時,DGS她都有2nd Interv ...

i like the result

cellon

esmond88 發表於 12-2-15 19:15
正在退步的直資中學 =  HYS ?

可以仔細的看看近幾年的學校報告，或者簡單些，看看 khmama 的資料：

2009年：排位: 16，6科14分: 75.7%，人均優良率: 4.8。

2010年：排位: 28，6科14分: 69.0%，人均優良率: 4.3。

事實勝於雄辯。

又或者問問自己：你認為學校突然要轉直資的主要原因是甚麼呢？

avon888

My son is through the school nomination ( Financial Aids).

esmond88

Hi avon888 請查看pm

like_travel

avon888 發表於 12-2-15 19:54
My son is through the school nomination ( Financial Aids).

i like the result

KiuKiu-Mama

回復 like_travel 的帖子

囡囡學校都有一批同學上月已優先見咗SPCC, 上星期已有5位獲通知取錄但佢地都唔係under "Financial Aids" 嘅!