小西灣- 中華基金中學 - 升中派位

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

42^#

發表於 13-10-9 23:28 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-9 23:36 編輯

我也認同這一刻的中基平均在b1尾。
如似abcd0001所說，學校大部分收邊緣人及2a來計，36%的入U成績還是不錯的。我會看她為一所增值力強的學校（eg. 入是b2a》》出是b1b）

而且她明顯在進步中。

...

CircleOne

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1950

43^#

發表於 13-10-9 23:51 |只看該作者

回復 abcd0001 的帖子

Abcd0001你好，同意B1A有很太多好選擇!
你提出有一㸃，可以拿出來給今年派位家長研究：-
為什麼聖馬可是B1a，能夠在第三志願仍然有位？
在上年，以我兒的小學看, B1a的張祝珊和B1b中婦，排第二志願, 是不可能被抽到的。
B1b的筲官就不清楚。

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

44^#

發表於 13-10-10 08:14 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-16 08:14 編輯

其實一所學校除了看數分之差的banding頭、中、尾之外，也是看軟件的。例如老師的熱誠、校長的眼光魄力、整體學校的願意嘗試、革新等等。這些方面中基都做得很好。
好像中基常常給人偏執科學的形像，可能是學校聆聽了回響，願意嘗試擴濶領域。今年開學至今短短個多月，學校就舉辦了到polyU的美術設計參觀、中秋及Chinese opera等分別的觀賞及攝影活動。昨日又收到一本由中基自己出版，印刷精美的有關本地及國際音樂、美術與文化的月刊，內容豐富,培養情操！還有午間cultural programme 集會，互動介紹藝術與文化。

我入到來中基所看見的是，除了已打好基礎的科學，學校也正嘗試發展文化美術。這種善於聆聽、革新、完善的取態，可能就是中基比傳統名校優勝的地方。
看得見學校是有心辦校的。

點評

CircleOne 贊同發表於 13-10-10 09:17

...

pris626

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3506

45^#

發表於 13-10-10 08:33 |只看該作者

引用：谷的具體情況如何？ +

原帖由 hangsing 於 13-10-09 發表
谷的具體情況如何？

多功課，默書和測驗。由於要兼顧課外活動，朋友囡囡平均11時才可上床睡覺。小朋友個個能力唔同，自己應付倒就冇問題。
其實好的學校有很多，朋友囡囡喜歡中基多活動，我囡讀傳統官校一樣多姿多采，活動多多但讀書氣氛依然濃厚，家長和小朋友可參觀多幾間學校了解多啲。最緊要都係考好個呈分試，成績好時就係你揀學校，成績唔好就學校揀你。

abcd0001

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3059

46^#

發表於 13-10-10 09:08 |只看該作者

CircleOne 發表於 13-10-9 23:51
回復 abcd0001 的帖子

Abcd0001你好，同意B1A有很太多好選擇!

St Mark 的事在很多 post 都有討論。在東區較年長的家長都會聽過，我不多說。用 search key 爬下 EK 便知。

位多人少是事實。本區 b1 大都去搏張祝珊, BPS 和中婦, 2nd choice of course no way! 其他的EMI, 2nd or 3rd choice 便有可能！看運气了。

但最差也會派 EMI! 位多嘛！那些令人討厭的 EMI 便會低一点排位也派到。

成績是重要，但辦學的手法也須家長認同。有錢就吾怕米貴，考第一就吾須要考慮其他人的待遇。

最重要是孩子有本事。

CircleOne

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1950

47^#

發表於 13-10-10 09:22 |只看該作者

回復 pris626 的帖子

同意，我也喜歡筲官!孩子上了中學，學的是管好時間，培養積極的學習態度!選的課外活動多，不能應付就要學取捨！

abcd0001

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3059

48^#

發表於 13-10-10 09:24 |只看該作者

mesmerising 發表於 13-10-10 08:14
其實一所學校除了看數分之差的banding頭、中、尾之外，也是看軟件的。例如老師的熱誠、校長的眼光魄力、整 ...

我認同你的看法。這也是直資在 DSE 中的优勢。資源上的、自主上的變通。

可惜是收生、減派都是困局！直資是計人頭資助；官津是包底！

所以不少直資都有直小, 以穩定生源和質素。成績才有望再上層樓。

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

49^#

發表於 13-10-12 10:58 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-12 15:00 編輯

Abcd0001: 所以不少直資都有直小, 以穩定生源和質素。成績才有望再上層樓。

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

剛經過學校街道想起，冇直小都唔一定比有直小的輸洩在生源及成績方面。

就以隔離間漢華為例，有不錯直小提供穩定生源，但中學還是以無直小的中基辦得明顯優勝（以成績Banding,出路論）。

所以我覺得還是看回間中學辦得好唔好，好就自然吸引到好學生。

...

ANChan59

珊瑚宮

Rank: 14


	119087

50^#

發表於 13-10-12 14:53 |只看該作者

回復 mesmerising 的帖子

除了生源，還要考慮理念及家長目標，及學校的政治背境，有得選擇，可必被標韱。

God grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

51^#

發表於 13-10-12 15:14 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-12 15:20 編輯

回復 ANChan59 的帖子

對。以上你提及的各㸃，中基都辦得不錯。家長期望及配合方面可望未來數年更進一步。尤其想澄清中基是沒有任何政治背景的。

...

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

52^#

發表於 13-10-12 15:34 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-12 15:36 編輯

回復 ANChan59 的帖子

我有一個問題關於「減派」，想問問你。原來減派是如abcd0001所説，學校迫於無奈要接受的？

以中基為例，我多方得到的資訊都是説她的減派是因為學校辦得好，有信心自己可收更佳生源才自願選擇的。
那個版本才是真相？謝。

...

abcd0001

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3059

53^#

發表於 13-10-12 21:16 |只看該作者

mesmerising 發表於 13-10-12 10:58
Abcd0001: 所以不少直資都有直小, 以穩定生源和質素。成績才有望再上層樓。

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

http://www.edb.gov.hk/attachment/tc/sch-admin/sch-quality-assurance/reports/cr-report/Hon_Wah_Coll_Cum_Pri_Section.pdf

This is school report of 漢華 from EMB

p.5

2012/13
            class          student number
P.1          3                      84
P.2          2                      42
P.3          2                      47
P.4          2                      39
P.5          2                      53
P.6          2                      66

total       13                   331

How good the school can be in terms of enrollment? if it is not backup by someone, I would wonder how it can still be here. Why do you think the student are good at academic? small class?

They enrolled 122 student in F1. ie almost 50% is from outside. 漢華 is a weak market player but has strong backup.( money)

On the other hand, 中基 does not have such strong finanical backup. Can 中基 cut the enrollment down below 100 student to maintain the student standard ?( a number I come across in another DSS ) Each student means 60K ( roughly, 40K from gov + 20K school fee ), 50 student mean 3000K annually ie 18M for six years. Who pay the balance within those years? If not, how to cut cost or teachers?

Because of dropping of student number carries on for several years, the further cut in student number to maintain standard is possible !! Most of all, who pay the bill?

Or, I believe, keep the enrollment number(~150) and meet the balance, in return, let the average standard goes down ....poorer standard means difficult to get better exam result, exam result makes parents not to pick up the choice! It is a negative cycling down!

In fact, I also attained their enrollment talk 2yr ago. I agreed they might think their student were on the right track and the exam result was going up. Parents are very materialistic businessmen, I believe they all want their kids entering U. We all want to know the number of Jupas!  Not just the vision of education. If it is 70% up , you can sell your enrollment form @$500 each. But now is 3x!!  漢華 is 2x (2012).... I think they are over estimated their results. Maybe they will strike back in the coming year!!!!! I hope they can make it.

.......if goes down to 漢華 level.....( maybe  漢華 goes up) ...it is much harder.....why I do not pick a b2 school with eng class which is also have ~2x% Jupas???? and no need to pay!

Exam result is not the only thing we consider but it is realistic and solid.

The only way out of DSS is to push their DSE result up! Otherwise, they are at the lower side of the market.

Dream about that

DxS says her Jupas is around 3x%. Will so many girls want to go there, deadly?

I just have those wild guess.

Don't take it serious but think over it.

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

54^#

發表於 13-10-12 23:57 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-13 05:27 編輯

The only way out of DSS is to push their DSE result up! Otherwise, they are at the lower side of the market.

Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxc

While boosting exam results are always favourable, I was stunned by the second half your sentence which put DSS at the lower end of the market except for guru like DXS, SPXC and the like.

With more and more of them being built in the field, I always thought DSS is the trend of tomorrow, the flourishing one?

...

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

55^#

發表於 13-10-13 05:41 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 mesmerising 於 13-10-13 06:00 編輯

Sorry, with its small form size and political background, 漢華 might give a sensitive example.
With 漢華 and maybe Rosaryhill (private), I was just trying to show that having linkup primaries DON'T necessarily guarantee you advantages in receiving decent student feeds over stand alone secondaries.
In defining a good primary, students' virtue, activities and academics, all counts. But class/form sizes should not be one of them.

...

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

56^#

發表於 13-10-14 23:23 |只看該作者

更正：根據綱友hinhin0204 提供的中學banding 綱址： http://www.schooland.hk/ss/

原來中基是B1b.

...

Dedemom

別墅

Rank: 4


	736

57^#

發表於 13-10-16 12:18 |只看該作者

回復 mesmerising 的帖子

係呀, 中基是B1b.

ANChan59

珊瑚宮

Rank: 14


	119087

58^#

發表於 13-10-16 13:00 |只看該作者

回復 mesmerising 的帖子

好嘢嚟㗎，因為低調及冇乜人吹捧！

God grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	10185

59^#

發表於 13-10-16 15:52 |只看該作者

回復 ANChan59 的帖子

多謝鼓勵。
返學兩個月，我對學校很是欣賞。我覺得功課不算太多。反而測默就真的頻密。不過能保持常常溫習，也有其好處。

昨日學校為中一、二生安排了午間cultural programme. 昨日主題是古典音樂。當中有音樂介紹及問答遊戲，答中獎糖果。：）
我囝很是投入，搶答了兩條問題。晚上把獎品拿出來，帶起話題，和我們分享當中趣事。原來，除了老師在場，校長也來一起參與，作發問者，和孩子一起玩。：）

十一月尾又有全體中一成長營。三日兩夜。主題係：建立團隊精神，尊重他人。

...