為甚麽自行不考慮替孩子選皇仁?

motherotk

各位家長,

如果孩子有能力, 為甚麽自行不考慮替孩子選皇仁? 聽了很多正面聲音和意見, 想了解另一面的看法..

ccpsg

請問你的孩子現在是六年級嗎？

leoncf

所有官校都是要靠學生自律，老師和學校的所用很小。如果你的孩子入了中上兩班當然好。但如果入了補底班就不如低就其它學校較好。記得幾年前有QC生打劫仲要笨到留下錢包証件給人按圖索驥下捉拿。

motherotk

So QC have classified students into 中上 and 補底班?

qyeternity

回復 motherotk 的帖子

There are a lot of considerations when you choose the TWO schools during 自行 stage

First of all, there are only 40 to 50s places at one school,

you have to see how many students in your child's primary school will choose the same secondary school and taking into consideration their banding and academic results too

just like my son's case, he ranks top ten at his school, but at least 5 or 6 of the top ten choose Cheung Chuk Shan, then I did not choose CCSC for him as I don't think CCSC will take 7 students from the same school while my son did not rank no.1

To 皇仁 , we have the same concern, finally we did not choose it neither

QuestionMa

too competitive during自行 ,  還有很多好學校適合小兒
too far away from home, 由家出發齋搭車要一粒鐘未計步行

motherotk

回復 qyeternity 的帖子

Very thoughful considerations. So you have to understand your child well, especially the rankings. thanks for this advice, really practical.

motherotk

回復 QuestionMa 的帖子

That's a consideration as well. Yes...thanks

jessimm

1. 減班後自行位太少
2. 官校的資源已無復昔日的多
3. 仲要面對「國民教育」科的試辦


* QC,KC,BPS都有同樣境況

lugano

如果個仔能力有, 一定俾佢試皇仁, 始終是心目中最強成績的男校

dbbp

kenfu 發表於 12-3-30 12:29
I like co-ed more than boy sch, thus 1st is CCSC & 2nd is QC.

i'd prefer co-ed schools too!

ANChan59

回復 kenfu 的帖子

I took in other way round.

Fong23fong

jessimm 發表於 12-3-27 10:59
1. 減班後自行位太少
2. 官校的資源已無復昔日的多
3. 仲要面對「國民教育」科的試辦

為何官校的資源已無復昔日的多?

elbar

motherotk 發表於 12-3-25 13:45
各位家長,

如果孩子有能力, 為甚麽自行不考慮替孩子選皇仁? 聽了很多正面聲音和意見, 想了解另一面的看法. ...

始終都是全港最多頂尖小六男生競爭官津男校,

退一步選另外兩間官津男校也相差不遠

mrsjacky

i will!! 如果三次呈分考到全級三甲之內的話！

motherotk

If St Paul Co-ed and QC, which one do you prefer?

lugano

motherotk 發表於 12-3-30 21:58
If St Paul Co-ed and QC, which one do you prefer?

如果兩間都收........
如果錢又唔係問題.......
如果 factor 埋小朋友將來的 Networking 效應 ，我會選擇 St Paul's Co-Edu.....

cellon

ccpsg 發表於 12-3-25 20:40
回覆：motherotk 的帖子請問你的孩子現在是六年級嗎？

motherotk，

你已經問了很多問題，
禮貌上可否回答ccpsg的問題呢？

jessimm

lugano 發表於 12-4-1 00:02
如果兩間都收........
如果錢又唔係問題.......
如果 factor 埋小朋友將來的 Networking 效應 ，我會選擇  ...

直資可以先收生係詬病,應該用「平行時空」讓學生自由地選校,學校公平地使用接收資源