research article 從主流小學到國際小學

mattsmum

教育改革的核心問題:學習的性質. 從主流小學到國際小學. http://www.fed.cuhk.edu.hk/~hkier/content/document/OP/Op26.pdf

本文探討本港幾位學生由主流小學轉讀一所國際 ... 結果顯示,學生轉讀國際學. 校後較有自信、更自發及獨立地學習,而學習動機的. 性質亦更為以通達目的為取向。

Happy小米

mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

mattsmum 寫道:
教育改革的核心問題:學習的性質. 從主流小學到國際小學. http://www.fed.cuhk.edu.hk/~hkier/content/document/OP/Op26.pdf

本文探討本港幾位學生由主流小學轉讀一所國際 ... 結果顯示,學生轉讀國際學. 校後較有自信、更自發及獨立地學習,而學習動機的. 性質亦更為以通達目的為取向。

WYmom

Happy小米 寫道:
mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

As far as I have experienced with local schools, the cases described are true and common.

mattsmum

when I read this article I had to say that it is like describing the last few years. that is why i post thin link for anybody not fully aware of what our scholars did say about education reform.

WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Happy小米 寫道:
mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

As far as I have experienced with local schools, the cases described are true and common.


[/quote]

MarcusD

Dear mattsmum

Thanks for your sharing.

Do you know, who is the author?

MarcusD

mattsmum 寫道:
when I read this article I had to say that it is like describing the last few years. that is why i post thin link for anybody not fully aware of what our scholars did say about education reform.

[quote]
WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Happy小米 寫道:
mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

As far as I have experienced with local schools, the cases described are true and common.


[/quote][/quote]

agneslth

我也看過這論文。

文章的大部份觀點我也認同。

但個人認為這文章有點把問題「兩極化」了，取了較極端的例子。我相信不是所有主流本地小學也是這樣，也不是所有國際學校都這麼好。在主流小學轉往國際學校，有成功也有失敗的個案，當中其實有不少變數和環境因素，結果並不是「一面倒」的。

MarcusD 寫道:
Dear mattsmum

Thanks for your sharing.

Do you know, who is the author?

MarcusD

[quote]
mattsmum 寫道:
when I read this article I had to say that it is like describing the last few years. that is why i post thin link for anybody not fully aware of what our scholars did say about education reform.

[quote]
WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Happy小米 寫道:
mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

As far as I have experienced with local schools, the cases described are true and common.


[/quote][/quote][/quote]

inho

MarcusD 寫道:
Dear mattsmum

Thanks for your sharing.

Do you know, who is the author?

MarcusD

Dear MarcusD,

Try this: http://www.fed.cuhk.edu.hk/~hkier/content/eng/publications/publications.htm

教育改革的核心問題：學習的性質──從主流小學到國際小學 （pdf 全文） （回頁頂）
連文嘗、黃顯華

inho

[quote]
mattsmum 寫道:
when I read this article I had to say that it is like describing the last few years. that is why i post thin link for anybody not fully aware of what our scholars did say about education reform.

[quote]
WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Happy小米 寫道:
mattsmum,

謝謝分享!
不過, 对于傳統學校的批評, 是否普遍性的?
看上來, 好似番去自己讀書年代咁封建. 或更差...
是否大部分傳統學校都是這樣的?

As far as I have experienced with local schools, the cases described are true and common.


[/quote][/quote][/quote]

mattsmum

連文嘗- pui kie school ?
黃顯華 -professor in CU education.

agree that this article 把問題(兩極化), life is never that simple. still good to konw that there are people looking  into these issue, telling the truth and proposing an answer.

the key point is " motivation", what affects motivation, etc.this article explained quite a lot.

any scholar here in BK telling us how this article is rated in academic circle?



[quote]
agneslth 寫道:
我也看過這論文。

文章的大部份觀點我也認同。

但個人認為這文章有點把問題「兩極化」了，取了較極端的例子。我相信不是所有主流本地小學也是這樣，也不是所有國際學校都這麼好。在主流小學轉往國際學校，有成功也有失敗的個案，當中其實有不少變數和環境因素，結果並不是「一面倒」的。


[quote]