ESF TY今年考小一如何

VVhuilee

Moonlight819 發表於 17-2-20 15:50
Yes

did u find out how many kids in ur class got offer?  thanks for sharing.  seems it is quite ok for hong0706's class

Saboc

Yes, good strategy.  

Moonlight819

VVhuilee 發表於 17-2-20 15:57
did u find out how many kids in ur class got offer?  thanks for sharing.  seems it is quite ok for  ...

It's quite hard to find out as some of them don't disclose and so I can only know part of the picture.

Moonlight819

Does anybody know where did the waiting or rejected students go at the end in the past?

964000

Moonlight819 發表於 17-2-20 18:21
Does anybody know where did the waiting or rejected students go at the end in the past?

Most waiting did get a spot at the end.
I only knew one got reject, who kept total silence during all interviews, he finally got into local kinder k3 and surprisingly he fares well in local system, seems he likes to follow instructions and rules rather the feee style way

ciaochibi

hong0706 發表於 17-2-20 13:13
大概K1近完結前，PYP coordinator 會個別測試每個小孩英語能力，睇下能否達到考小學要求，如： 放水杯係枱 ...

As far as I know, the teacher would discuss with u the way forward if they realize that your kid is marginal near the end of k1 term.

AJW2010

lckfwylyk 發表於 17-2-20 10:20
our class with 18 students, only 6 got offer in the first round, for the rest, half are rejected and ...

Sound so scary.  May I know which class are you in?  Did the teacher talk about the issues during the parent consultation?

Moonlight819

ciaochibi 發表於 17-2-20 19:23
As far as I know, the teacher would discuss with u the way forward if they realize that your kid is ...

I know some cases that there wasn't any discussion with the teachers before and the teachers said their children have no problem, but at last get rejected!

ciaochibi

Moonlight819 發表於 17-2-21 18:31
I know some cases that there wasn't any discussion with the teachers before and the teachers said t ...

The discussion was not with class teacher but with the vice principal.

Moonlight819

ciaochibi 發表於 17-2-21 18:38
The discussion was not with class teacher but with the vice principal.

No also!

ciaochibi

Moonlight819 發表於 17-2-21 18:42
No also!

If u did not receive this call, I guess that your case is  not imminent from their point of view.  

VVhuilee

Want to follow up on the final admission % into ESF Primary for ESF TY.  Any K2 parents can share?  thanks!

edmondlukluk

我個仔宜家讀Bradbury year 2, 記得兩年前佢interview, 我都好驚佢入唔到。好彩佢肯講野。英文雖然有口音（我太太平日係屋企同佢講日文），不過都收左佢。我估計，佢地主要睇小朋友夠唔夠主動。

另外，我請左一個係esf做嘅補習老師，佢近排先同我太太講開，話esf收生標準同以前係有d唔同，門檻高左....畢竟政府冇資助之後，佢地宜家可以用佢地自己訂下嘅準則收生....（雖然冇人知道係咩標準...）

我朋友今年都俾esf reject左....

964000

edmondlukluk 發表於 17-6-6 12:17
我個仔宜家讀Bradbury year 2, 記得兩年前佢interview, 我都好驚佢入唔到。好彩佢肯講野。英文雖然有口音（ ...

I think they don't just test English level, they also look for outgoing and inquisitive character which is more suitable for IB.

edmondlukluk

964000 發表於 17-6-6 12:20
I think they don't just test English level, they also look for outgoing and inquisitive character w ...

係。我覺得主動學習最緊要。就算唔太識講，你肯主動答問題，都pass.

964000

edmondlukluk 發表於 17-6-6 12:22
係。我覺得主動學習最緊要。就算唔太識講，你肯主動答問題，都pass.

我見過有個男孩子，讀local kinder, 平日主要跟工人説英語，英文其實不是特別好，但佢勝在吾怕醜，平時在會所見到説英文的小孩也會主動搭咀，結果在设有priority之下，kjs也收了他入y1（幾年前）。

抺茶雪糕

i wonder if it's less competitive applying for KJS, BHS than SJS? thanks

Moonlight819

964000 發表於 17-6-6 12:40
我見過有個男孩子，讀local kinder, 平日主要跟工人説英語，英文其實不是特別好，但佢勝在吾怕醜，平時在 ...

I think there would not be happened in recent years. I heard that the KJS is the most competitive this year and quite a few of kindy priority children even got rejected!

VVhuilee

抺茶雪糕 發表於 17-6-6 12:45
i wonder if it's less competitive applying for KJS, BHS than SJS? thanks

SJS 2018/19 會係大競爭，因為wks有8班。

964000

Moonlight819 發表於 17-6-6 13:40
I think there would not be happened in recent years. I heard that the KJS is the most competitive t ...

係啦，佢真係超好采，之後仲帶埋細佬妹入ESF