ESF foundation schools

babyonboard

回覆 little-pig-pig 的帖子

想請教下parent interview會以甚麼形式進行，大概會問甚麼問題?

Cara2006

little-pig-pig 發表於 17-2-21 16:52
因為唔止 English proficiency, 其實social skill 都睇，仲有唔好忘記仲有個parent interview

True. I think it is valid to say social or communication skills is the most important. I read in another topic someone had a very good analyse of the situation. IB is a very different teaching approach. Social or communication skills is extremely important.

Moonlight819

Sweetiesdragonb 發表於 17-2-21 15:25
Totally agree! My son speaks fluent English and mainly English. I never received any advice from es ...

As the above parent said, it's so ridiculous that even the native speakers have the reject cases and I think their social skills normally is ok too. Your case is just like my friend and she's quite angry about the situation as she has not been informed by the school before that her child has any problem in English proficiency and her child is good in English and outgoing (of course no discipline problem), but received also the rejected letter.

858

little-pig-pig 發表於 17-2-21 16:52
因為唔止 English proficiency, 其實social skill 都睇，仲有唔好忘記仲有個parent interview
...

RC又用什麼準則揀選學生？RC無in家長。

hong0706

Cara2006 發表於 17-2-21 16:56
"Native speakers" means? Genuinely native? Or "trained native" from local families?
As far as I se ...

Native means native. Mixed, or one or both parents ABC or BBC.
And that's the issue, ESF emphasis again again again you should not train your kids, not attend interview classes, and just play as they do in classes. And had given offers on this base in the past. Now, they are rewarding those who train their kids like in local schools, and penalises those who listen to them.

難怪今年有D怨聲載道

little-pig-pig

babyonboard 發表於 17-2-21 17:02
回覆 little-pig-pig 的帖子

想請教下parent interview會以甚麼形式進行，大概會問甚麼問題?

問什麼問題唔重要，你要細心去諗點解學校要搞個parent interview? 目的何在？佢地想見你地係為咗想知道你地的什麼東西？當你明白我講乜就知要點樣準備個parent interview

hong0706

Cara2006 發表於 17-2-21 17:03
True. I think it is valid to say social or communication skills is the most important. I read in a ...

The problem is in the all admission briefing, they said over and over again they are non- selective and they "ONLY" assess the English proficiency.!
所以話, 唔好信哂學校, 來年考生： 就好似LS 咁train , 着數D

Moonlight819

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:08
Native means native. Mixed, or one or both parents ABC or BBC.
And that's the issue, ESF emphasis a ...

Yes, that's why we feel to be cheated by school as we don't let our child to have any academic tuition after school..

hong0706

babyonboard 發表於 17-2-21 17:02
回覆 little-pig-pig 的帖子

想請教下parent interview會以甚麼形式進行，大概會問甚麼問題?

完全唔重要，除非你一句英文都聽唔明，咁就難講D！
一入去學校已講明唔係assess 家長， 只係想了解小孩多D（如：在家用什麼語文，喜歡玩乜，性格係點），同問你小孩有什麼地方你想學校知。如果你自己唔係口水佬口水婆，唔洗10分鐘

hong0706

858 發表於 17-2-21 17:00
我諗我解釋到siblings失敗率高的原因，siblings制度方便家長照顧學生。但由於有太多家長濫用呢種priority ...

我講嘅係在TY讀的siblings.

nintendo

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:14
The problem is in the all admission briefing, they said over and over again they are non- selective  ...

你咁講亦唔公度。
如果兩個小朋友 A 和 B 去 interview ，A 係唔出聲唔釆人，但 B 有問必答，咁如果學校收 A ，對 B 又公平嗎？
如果唔出聲，可能老師當你聽唔明，英文水平唔夠。

858

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:14
The problem is in the all admission briefing, they said over and over again they are non- selective  ...

我地有兩個補習老師又有join langauage camp, 後補係咩意思？

hong0706

nintendo 發表於 17-2-21 17:31
你咁講亦唔公度。
如果兩個小朋友 A 和 B 去 interview ，A 係唔出聲唔釆人，但 B 有問必答，咁如果學校收 ...

問題係大部分呢D冇上enhancement course (kinder老師上課觀察 覺得冇問題），小學老師亦去過kinder 觀察！同埋，ESF講過N次佢地老師經驗豐富，有能力令「任何」學生講嘢。
我不想爭論對錯，觀點角度不同，我只希望佢地有second interview 的能順利通過。同埋提醒來年考生的家長。

nintendo

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:08
Native means native. Mixed, or one or both parents ABC or BBC.
And that's the issue, ESF emphasis a ...

Well, how can you presume native speakers would always nail the interview?

We did not witness the interview, we cannot be sure how that kid perform.

hong0706

858 發表於 17-2-21 17:41
我地有兩個補習老師又有join langauage camp, 後補係咩意思？

唔明，乜「後補」？

hong0706

nintendo 發表於 17-2-21 17:44
Well, how can you presume native speakers would always nail the interview?

We did not witness the  ...

唔洗問，佢地一定表現唔好啦，唔係點會肥
只係太多native 家庭太天真！

nintendo

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:43
問題係大部分呢D冇上enhancement course (kinder老師上課觀察 覺得冇問題），小學老師亦去過kinder 觀察！ ...

No one is here to argue.
I am here to reason with you.
Even for adult, there can be a bad day for everyone.
How can you be so sure the children that failed did not have a bad day.

I do not agree that it is particularly strange this year.
Every year around this time, there are lots of topics discussing about whether the admission results are fair.
I can understand the disappointment.
But I guess parents need to be fair as well.

nintendo

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:49
唔洗問，佢地一定表現唔好啦，唔係點會肥
只係太多native 家庭太天真！

你發我脾氣都唔會有位，
不過我由你。
Go ahead.

hong0706

同die hard fans 傾真係唔易，仲係一D完全唔知今年情況的人，我決定放棄。

Sweetiesdragonb

hong0706 發表於 17-2-21 17:08
Native means native. Mixed, or one or both parents ABC or BBC.
And that's the issue, ESF emphasis a ...

Yes. Extremely disappointed with esf now and think they are real bull shit