校際音樂節鋼琴示範光碟

RMA

ChiWaWa,

何司能教授有出鋼琴 graded class o既 dvd, 你可以去各大琴行問問。

舊年 chamber music 的確係出左一套 piano solo for graded competitions o既。不過我聽過，彈得唔係好，而且最後要搞到 2 月尾 3 月先出，仲唔係咁 approachable，起碼大琴行都唔見蹤影，見到o既時候已經係 3 月尾，出黎做乜?

見舊年虧咁多，今年死都唔出啦，而且唔叫好亦唔叫座...
(雖然已經係搵 apa / hk concert pianists 演繹)

RMA

kcarol,

o, sorry, 一定係我自己記錯左。原來係 vcd 至真...

音樂變化無限，如果要抄襲不如唔好彈，因為人地已經彈左...

不過對於小朋友，如果有臨帖，總好過冇。但何教授呢隻呢，可能都係同舊年班 apa 先生一樣...

RMA

Sindy,

呢 d 野係比學生做參考o既，我自己就唔要啦。

既然係比學生o既，應該早 d 出，唔係去到要比賽果個月先出。就算係我錯，話佢地係 2 月尾 / 3 月先有貨。at least 大琴行都冇，連我去問 sales 佢地話未聽過有。

royal o既 cd 早半年已經出左。我唸最少都應該有兩個月時間比學生參考。而唔係 2 / 3 個星期。

如果係咁叫好叫座，佢地今年唔會唔出啦。right?

RMA

Zoey,

今年出，不過係阿何教授出，你仍然可以同朋友合資。最少而家已經有貨。唔係 2 / 3 / 4 個星期 / 1 個月前先有。咁'蚊'，難怪要搵速遞促銷。(如果係二月頭先有，其實冇一個月，因為 festival 廿幾號已經開始)

唔知有冇人送貨呢何教授。

RMA

kcarol,

究竟係 vcd 定 dvd?
我話 dvd 你又話 vcd... hahahahahaha

haha, 冇首歌係完整，真係 rubbish。
不過何教授o既野你都唔應該有好大期望o既。

以前佢出果 d aural training textbook / reference / tool books  都真係...差勁，雖然已經放左水...

舊年我冇買因為覺得呢班野唔會彈得好，而且去過個 website 睇過 d sample video，見呀李老師睇譜彈，1d 都唔 convincing 咁 read 哂隻 Mozart Sonata K.280 (1st mvt)，再睇埋劉老師隻 Chopin，肯定自己唔會買... 要聽，Daniel Barenboim, Yundi Li, Murray Perahia, Andra Schiff, Tamas Vasary, 全部都彈得好過佢地。

o, 原來仲要分咁多隻 cd 咁麻煩，擺明屈水... 唔緊要，香港o既家長都願意花呢 d 錢o既。但鋼琴老師，自己 reference 就貴左 d haha...

RMA

kcarol,

佢地又真係好離譜...

RMA

kcarol,

haha, 好多人都知架, 西崎...

唔知呢, 咁 technical o既錄音問題我唔識，但我覺得佢地整體 quality 真係幾差呢。

不過如果大家 defend 佢話佢o既理想係大眾化呢，我冇乜野講，因為要做理想，同現實係會有距離o既。

但唸深一層 quality 係咁樣，學生聽左的確係有反效果。

RMA

JP,

而家我學生通常都會用 digital recorder, 手提電話等 equipment 錄我彈琴... 冇錢收最驚佢賣比人添 (hehe 講笑啫， 邊有資格 publish / 出 cd 呀...)

但我唔否認 '身 demo'，係好過聽 cd.

RMA

kcarol,

你話佢地有時會搵到勁人，但 piano o既 cd，我就真係唔覺得有。其他o既 genre 我都唔會買 naxos. 雖然佢地係平，但唔係叫超值...

warrrren,

In terms of the interpretation and style of many performer Naxos invited, I am sorry but have to conclude that their impact in solo piano works are rather unsatisfactory.

When you listen to some of their publications (popular repertoire such as Mozart Sonatas and Bach's WTC),  you'll find the artists are not really up to standard to provide an exemplary performance to kids/youngsters for studies.

When students are not experienced to judge the musicality, listening to these Naxos CDs and merely copying would be a serious  '反效果'.