St Clare's versus St Paul's Catholic

candeelian

Thanks God. We got offers from both school. Both schools are similar, traditional girl's school which suits my daughter. The only thing is that I prefer an English primary school, but St Paul's Catholic ranks higher.

Which one will you choose?

1998Ruby1998

Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance can be as competitive as St Clare's.

Comparing the two secondary school, SPSS is more academic. However, a lot of St Clare girls would opt for secondary school such as St Steven Girl's, DGS, St Paul Co-ed....if you are aiming for schools like these, it would better to study in St Clare's then.

gurgur

Have you ask your girl? What is her choose?

happysin

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 12:08
Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance  ...

st paul's catholic not direct to spcs (st paul's convent school) but to st paul's secondary. pls correct if i am wrong.

cmchang0927

happysin 發表於 17-11-27 12:39
st paul's catholic not direct to spcs (st paul's convent school) but to st paul's secondary. pls co ...

st paul cat係去st paul’s secondary.

1998Ruby1998

回覆 happysin 的帖子

Sorry, that was a typo.

cmchang0927

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 11:47
Thanks God. We got offers from both school. Both schools are similar, traditional girl's school whic ...

我女now s2， 8 yrs ago i had the same choices. I chose st paul cat finally.

cmchang0927

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 12:08
Congrats! St Paul Catholic for sure! The school focuses a lot on English, their English performance  ...

2年前st paul cat. p6 ， 3 st paul coedu, 1 dgs, 3 bps, 1 hys, 1 spcs, 1 mss, 1 ssgc, 1 st mary....

yubaba

spcps la. 諗埋個外孫女嘛!

BBQporkpork

如果只有一個小朋友, 我會揀St Clare's

因為返柴灣其實真係好遠 😅

1998Ruby1998

回覆 cmchang0927 的帖子

按學生人數同「挑戰學校」人數，St Clare‘s 多 d 。

cmchang0927

1998Ruby1998 發表於 17-11-27 13:02
回覆 cmchang0927 的帖子

按學生人數同「挑戰學校」人數，St Clare‘s 多 d 。

sppcs only had 11x kids 2 yrs ago
中途又有2個已插了dgjs

BBHHO

BBQporkpork 發表於 17-11-27 12:54
We had same choices last year

we chose SPPCS finally, as we have 2 girls

St Paul 唔系跑馬地咩？

cmchang0927

BBHHO 發表於 17-11-27 14:02
St Paul 唔系跑馬地咩？

因重建，現暫借柴灣校舍

NatalieBaby

首先恭喜樓主, 二選其一都還得神落.

兩間都識人讀, 少少個人意見：

1) sc 学生向外闖的心比sp強烈, 這是以我認識的人計, 可能 sc 中学隔涉, 所以 sc 外闖%多d不為奇

2) 感覺sc 嚴d, 當年參觀高小課室是單行坐不是孖同學坐, 執字体較要求高, 好處是較淑女

3) sc功課少但有不少 continuous assessment.

3) sp 少d  continuous assessment, 而 每日午飯後不上主科, 連va, music 都是早上上堂. 而逢一至四下午有一節功課堂, 不少女女放学前已完成大部份功課. 所以個人觉得頗平衡

4) sp 雖暫借柴灣校舍但仍比Sc 寬敞


5) 如家庭對英文支援少, 可選英小平衡下

candeelian

Thanks all for your view. Giving up either one is a heart-pain.

Studying in Chai Wan for a year is not a problem. This borrowed campus is also very spacious and comfortable.

I like a balanced development and prefer an English primary school. Having said so, giving up on St Paul's Catholic seems like an unwise decision.

cmchang0927

candeelian 發表於 17-11-27 16:12
Thanks all for your view. Giving up either one is a heart-pain.

Studying in Chai Wan for a year is  ...

Also i know a few girls of spss were from st clare ’s primary, but havent heard of vice versa situation....

mcl203

cmchang0927 發表於 17-11-27 16:24
Also i know a few girls of spss were from st clare ’s primary, but havent heard of vice versa situ ...

可能，摩星嶺係一主因～～～

^GGmami^

NatalieBaby 發表於 17-11-27 14:24
首先恭喜樓主, 二選其一都算還得神落.

兩間都識人讀, 少少個人意見：

非常同意，sp應該係少數唔谷嘅津校，小一上學期無測考(係有評估)，默書由開學到而家都只係默過3中3英，功課基本上喺學校已做晒，我個女依然係每日放學返屋企就玩玩玩，佢每日返學都好開心!

Bunnygirl

其實SC kindergarten 都有好多人大抽獎後扣灣仔三大女津, 如果有三大其中一間中咗多數會走. 可能都係同中學位置有關. 尤其st Francis 同st Paul cath都係全新校捨. 太吸引!