張堅庭 教育大逃難 2014年03月21日

ChiChiPaPa

ANChan59 發表於 14-3-25 22:59
你都看到以上都是以尖子比尖子，有何代表性？都不是整體比較，不會有結果，只是各取所需。

我怕甚麼比較， ...

第二理由不合理，因為應是IB對IB，否則不會出現第三個理由。第一理由，也只是目前是這樣，神校對IB的升學輔導在改進中。第三個理由才是真正理由，難根本改變。
反而我想知轉IS的適應情況，例如英文是否跟得上，有否覺得某些能力不及同學，是否不能融入外籍同學的圈子？這些才是真正的比較。

ANChan59

ChiChiPaPa 發表於 14-3-26 05:48
第二理由不合理，因為應是IB對IB，否則不會出現第三個理由。第一理由，也只是目前是這樣，神校對IB的升學輔 ...

第二個理由是合理，兩間神校有NSS及lB老師，後者人工比 NSS老師人工高，但又不能太高，不然有內部矛盾。我指的lS向神校挖角是高30－50％的差異。
第一個理由是學校處理分別，該lS有較多Seminar 俾家長，神校較少，神校集中教學生如何選及申請大學，而非家長。但着名大學都到神校作簡介會，但多數不開放給家長，我只聽過劍橋。神校升大學簡介會是一視同仁，lB及NSS學生都可以參加。

適應如何，沒有細問，下次問吓！

nadal

在高水評學生身上，IS在培養學習能力、主動性、積極性等等的效果是十分明顯的。但在一般水評學生身上，LS和IS的差異就可能分別不大。

有冇人可以分享一下從本地小學升中轉至國際學校的經驗？

friendlyguy

//因為DSE有80%quota入本地U保障嘛！

講笑，講笑！sorry, sorry！


點評      Bluegene  沒有這樣的保證，你攪錯了。//

80% JUPAS (DSE+?)
20% nonJUPAS

HKTHK

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

This is an interesting topic but a pointless discussion.  People all trying to validate their chosen path.  Just another case of confirmation bias by "you-know-who" who can never see the benefit of other possibilities.  His kid might have an open mind from an IS education but the father certainly need to learn a thing or two.  Let's not forget, LS and IS are not the only choices.  Some of the best HK kids are in boarding schools as well.  

HKTHK

回覆 dobbybabie 的帖子

點解無錢唔可以讀IB呀？唔好話外國嗰啲,香港都有UWC啦

hkparent

原帖由 skkeung 於 14-03-25 發表
超神化國際學校學生！閣下子女肯定是國際學校學生！咁社會上，國際學校學生應在社會上層！醫生，律師，建築 ...

Good IS students fly high and won't aim at government jobs. I know many foreigners, overseas graduates and IS graduates who are lawyers, bankers and other professionals who are either in senior management or owners of firms. Recently many IS graduates are accepted into medic programs too.

HKTHK

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

I also wonder if the second point might be broader than just salary.  If one is an IB teacher, what are the considerations in evaluating a job?  Some of the factors that come to mind are salary, the schools educational philosophy, quality of administrators, teacher community, student quality, ...  For all of these factors, I think a good IS will be equal if not better than a NSS.  Given the large number of increases in IB DP programs, it will be interesting to see whether NSS can hold on to good IB teachers.  

ANChan59

原帖由 HKTHK 於 14-03-26 發表
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

This is an interesting topic but a pointless discussion.  People all trying to ...

所以我話無謂比較！邊會一面倒好哂，或者差晒。

這題目唔再討論啦！

shadeslayer

原帖由 ANChan59 於 14-03-26 發表
所以我話無謂比較！邊會一面倒好哂，或者差晒。

這題目唔再討論啦！

I think the point is whether the topic "大逃難", is there any truth in it? Or is it just outright exaggeration.

If there is some truth in it, what are the reasons?  What is wrong with the local education system.

ANChan59

原帖由 shadeslayer 於 14-03-26 發表
I think the point is whether the topic "大逃難", is there any truth in it? Or is it just outright ex ...

I think it's exaggerated, but partially correct.

Parents hunger for better education, need to set the priorities right.

nadal

"大逃難" is an exaggeration but no one can deny that  there certainly is a big demand for alternatives to LS, especially among the middle class who can afford it.

I would say one of the reason is obviously to avoid the stressful work load and exam pressure in local primary school.

shadeslayer

nadal 發表於 14-3-26 11:16
在高水評學生身上，IS在培養學習能力、主動性、積極性等等的效果是十分明顯的。但在一般水評學生身上，LS和 ...

Check this out.
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2759282&page=3&authorid=1049305