SFA vs Good Hope

youma

原帖由 wh0709 於 11-11-15 15:50 發表
Seems both homework is a great burden, is single gender affects your choice? I like moral edu and nice campus, esp swimming pool of GH!

No free swimming lesson is offered to GH primary girls. A girl can never swim at GH swimming pool unless she attends the paid swimming class organised by outside swim org (e.g. Stanford). It is no difference to outsiders!

youma

原帖由 jonahlee 於 11-11-15 15:57 發表
Good Hope.  All round development

GH is not offering all round development!

• Every girl is allowed to join one or none after-school ECA activity.
• Most of GH girls have never joined any sport teams or music orchestras in GH.
• Participation to speech competitions and music competitions are not encouraged. Most of the applications to speech fest are rejected and school refuses to sign on the app. form.
• Education tour? Sorry, none.
• Math competition? sorry, not encouraged. You have to apply to the organizers by yourself.
• Drama? Ballet? IT? Swimming? forget them.
• Anyway, English is excellent. General academic is good.

youma

原帖由 RLML 於 11-11-16 15:56 發表
其實只要登入GH website, 就看到音樂節的下載表格, 而且還有其他聯校活動, 真的如此封閉嗎? 還是吃不到的葡萄是酸的, 或惡意中傷? 家長要小心判斷. 只是路過, 不喜勿插! ...

你叫人[不喜勿插], 但你卻先插人! 不過我唔會介意.

一間學校是否鼓勵學生參加音樂節, 不單看有冇下載表格吧? 是否著緊, 鼓勵和各樣配套更重要.
至於speech fest, 每年很多GH girls 都被rejected參加, 你可以自己去查證.

youma

原帖由 manyui 於 11-11-16 01:57 發表

Thank you for your good sharing. How about SFA?

SFA 的 ECA 應有盡有, 大多沒有限制限量, 只要唔撞時間便可以. 資優生更有gifted classes.
當然, 家長唔敢玩太多.

youma

原帖由 cutebear123 於 11-11-16 22:12 發表
My daughter is now studying in GHS(KG) and selected to attend the 63rd Speech Festival.  Even the training is organized in Sat and needed to pay for engaging external teacher, I think the school is en ...

You are correct.

The key word is "selected". Most of the girls are not selected.  
But in many schools, e.g. SFA, all students no matter good or not, are allowed to participate in speech fest competitions without limit.

youma

原帖由 williskg 於 11-11-16 22:20 發表
but there is no secondary support for the sfa. some of the student go to ghs.

It is true. 但sfa 升中學位都唔差, 有家長甚至認為更好.

事實上, 兩間都是熱門好學校.

youma

原帖由 小天使kiki 於 11-11-16 22:26 發表
我呀女同好多同學都有參加朗誦節喎，同埋點解可以rejected?

You are right, 不過, 冇被selected的人數, 比有參加人數更多, 你問下你個女便知.
測試水準較差便被rejected, 好似話係怕影響個人信心, 你問下老師便知.

youma

原帖由 cutebear123 於 11-11-16 22:44 發表
Is it normal practice for most of schools, right?  My friend's son is studying in Pui Ching Primary School and the teachers only select a small portion of students to attend this kind of competitions.

Yes, some schools allow all students to attend speech fest if they wish while some do not. I don't have the statistics.

But as this is almost no cost to a school to put its chop on the form, it is puzzled why schools reject applications. Maybe the main reason that the school rejects applications is for the fame of school.


[ 本帖最後由 youma 於 11-11-16 23:21 編輯 ]

youma

Anyway, don't take my words too serious.

Although GH is not minded to offer all round development (maybe the school want the girls concentrating on the academic), it's no harm. Almost all parents arrange various ECAs for the girls outside.

It doesn't dampen the popularity and academic performance of GH Primary.

Relax.

youma

原帖由 WCYH 於 11-11-16 23:30 發表
In DGJS, only selected stds can attend the speech festival. Certainly, you can join through some centres outside by yourself. In SPCC, even you are selected, you need to have training outside by yourself. For SFA, my friend's son have no duty in the class even requested due to chance for  gifted std mainly , so now change to YWS, very happy and bright, more chances for him to learn.

Change to YWS just because no duty in class? 唔係馬?
Studying at SFA and GHS can be happy and bright too.
By the way, the academic levels of SFA and GHS are certainly much higher than YWS.

youma

原帖由 eirisc 於 11-11-20 00:04 發表
一句都尾. 冇中學嘅小學都係冇保障.㸃都係有中學好d嫁啦.邊個想六年後又玩一次呢個遊戲.入中學比入小學更難因大部份好中學都有小學.要做到全香港最top個幾位先可以入到去.談何容易. ...

都要看間直資中學得唔得.

youma

原帖由 menmen 於 11-11-18 15:32 發表
Youma,
It's not the problem of cost to stamp a chop to the application form to let GHS girls to join the speech festival but the limitation of time for those Chinese subject class teachers to give practise and advice to their students.  
If the school let all the girls to join so it will put great burden to the subject teachers. The teachers are impossible to give practise to all students within school time.
If you're not very familiar with the policy of GHS pls don't give too much comments to the school unless you've a girl study in GHS.

• It is not necessary to train all enrolled girls. But it is necessary to give them a chance to participate.
• What is the real reason of not allowing all girls to participate? You can ask the Principle Sister to understand the rationale.
• BK is a platform to let parents freely comment and discuss, no matter what role we are. (By the way, I am of course not a simple guy.)

[ 本帖最後由 youma 於 11-11-22 00:15 編輯 ]