係屋企通常用咩語言? <-- 有感而發

CacaBebe_C6

其實, 我想問呢d 咁既問題, 對於學校揀學生真係有影響? d 老師係咪真係鍾意聽到 "我地係屋企係用全英語對話架" 咁先開心? 係咪講廣東話就要睇低個小朋友?
其實要睇既係小朋友既能力, 如認知, 辨識等.... 跟本同係屋企用咩語言是無關的.... 難道一個天才/資優兒童, 係屋企如果係講廣東話, 果間學校都要放棄佢??

點解要問d 咁無謂既問題??

[ 本帖最後由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 19:32 編輯 ]

marcuscyrus

原帖由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 19:29 發表
其實, 我想問呢d 咁既問題, 對於學校揀學生真係有影響? d 老師係咪真係鍾意聽到 "我地係屋企係用全英語對話架" 咁先開心? 係咪講廣東話就要睇低個小朋友?
其實要睇既係小朋友既能力, 如認知, 辨識等.... 跟本同係屋 ...

呢條問題，我答廣東話
而我兒們報的是英普班
大兒waiting list 入
細兒直接入

cow1303

原帖由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 19:29 發表
其實, 我想問呢d 咁既問題, 對於學校揀學生真係有影響? d 老師係咪真係鍾意聽到 "我地係屋企係用全英語對話架" 咁先開心? 係咪講廣東話就要睇低個小朋友?
其實要睇既係小朋友既能力, 如認知, 辨識等.... 跟本同係屋 ...

絕對有影響. 學校係想清楚知道家長同學校理念是否相同, 因有些學校偏向母語教學(如果在家只說英文, 學校可能唔會收的), 有些偏向國際化(學校要小朋友有一定的英文水平).

chingching0513

咁如果我答工人用英文父母用廣東話,咁又算係咩?

CacaBebe_C6

原帖由 cow1303 於 11-11-5 19:56 發表


絕對有影響. 學校係想清楚知道家長同學校理念是否相同, 因有些學校偏向母語教學(如果在家只說英文, 學校可能唔會收的), 有些偏向國際化(學校要小朋友有一定的英文水平). ...

都岩既...
但咁其實係小朋友既能力先決丫... 定係呢d 家庭因素先決?? 唔通真係唔岩 channel 就幾叻都唔收??

j-mum

原帖由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 21:02 發表


都岩既...
但咁其實係小朋友既能力先決丫... 定係呢d 家庭因素先決?? 唔通真係唔岩 channel 就幾叻都唔收??

CacaBebe,

May I know which particular KG are you talking about? And are you applying Eng/PTH K1?  I do know some of the KGs have preference when they select students into their Eng/PTH stream because the purpose of having Eng/PTH class is to cater the need of foreigners' family (expatriates).  That's why want to know the lauguage environments the family is providing to the kids.  Haven't said that I believe this question is not offensive and is NOT critical for SOME KGs.  

Don't upset!

CacaBebe_C6

原帖由 j-mum 於 11-11-5 21:43 發表


CacaBebe,

May I know which particular KG are you talking about? And are you applying Eng/PTH K1?  I do know some of the KGs have preference when they select students into their Eng/PTH stream becau ...

um... most of the famous KG may ask this question in their questionaire or individual interview, this usually embarrass me as my answer is Cantonese, just thinking if I use Cantonese at home, then we cannot easily get the offer for ENG/PTH admission (personally feeling), in fact, most of the parents want their children study in 英普班... so that they can have the excellent environment for their language learning.

please don't mind it is just my personal feeling...

ho_yan2406

我仔有in一間有英普同英粵班的kg,但我報英粵班,有問用咩語言多,有冇講下其他語言,我照答:我同婆婆用廣東話多,但都有教下英文,麻麻有教佢普通話~
老師又問:有冇上playgroup?我話有,係全英playgroup,外國人教~
老師再問:咁你都好注重佢d英文?我答係~!

MC-煎

唔好太多心！
我都係照實答廣東話！ 唔好覺得英文有乜咁了不起！而對粵語產生抗拒！

我真係為中文而驕傲！ （我為左小朋友有中文既學習環境， 而起美國搬返來。我同太太既英文都好好， 但從未主動教授英文）

siden

Agree, don't be too sensitive. Don't think too much is happier in this difficult education atmosphere.

If during KV interview you answer your language mostly used at home is english, your chance being accepted is less.

Different schools prefer different medium language. They are not discriminating cantonese. (Most schools I guess)

[ 本帖最後由 siden 於 11-11-6 12:40 編輯 ]

may123

我都係照答廣東話

麥兜MaMa

原帖由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 19:29 發表
其實, 我想問呢d 咁既問題, 對於學校揀學生真係有影響? d 老師係咪真係鍾意聽到 "我地係屋企係用全英語對話架" 咁先開心? 係咪講廣東話就要睇低個小朋友?
其實要睇既係小朋友既能力, 如認知, 辨識等.... 跟本同係屋 ...

做咩甘唔開心呀?? 有人歧視你地呀? 個老師串你們?

麥兜MaMa

其實我地姐姐用英文多, 我們用中文.
為左令阿仔明D老師講什麼, 呢大半年專門同佢傾多D中文, 上多D PG(沒番Ｎ）

麥兜MaMa

原帖由 CacaBebe_C6 於 11-11-5 22:04 發表



um... most of the famous KG may ask this question in their questionaire or individual interview, this usually embarrass me as my answer is Cantonese, just thinking if I use Cantonese at home, then  ...

算啦，　果間甘多人in，　都唔中定英既問題，合眼緣多Ｄ。聖誕樹都有反應家，平常心啦。

CacaBebe_C6

原帖由 麥兜MaMa 於 11-11-7 00:40 發表


做咩甘唔開心呀?? 有人歧視你地呀? 個老師串你們?

唔係呀, 麥兜媽媽, 無人歧視過我地... 亦唔係投訴d 乜野... 只不過係唔明點解要問呢條問題... 如果我報英粵班, 在家用廣東話當然無問題, 但如果我揀英普班呢? 莫非我用廣東話就不能在學校學普通話嗎? 我地都想可以全天候用普通話/英文來學習語言.... 我係唔想因為我地係屋企用廣東話而抺煞左亞囝可以全天候學習其他語言既機會.....

um.... 或者只係我個人諗多左... 不過我都係照實答我地係屋企是用廣東話的....

CacaBebe_C6

原帖由 MC-煎 於 11-11-6 12:21 發表
唔好太多心！
我都係照實答廣東話！ 唔好覺得英文有乜咁了不起！而對粵語產生抗拒！

我真係為中文而驕傲！ （我為左小朋友有中文既學習環境， 而起美國搬返來。我同太太既英文都好好， 但從未主動教授英文） ...

我真係為中文而驕傲！ <--- 超 LIKE

CacaBebe_C6

原帖由 麥兜MaMa 於 11-11-7 00:51 發表


算啦，　果間甘多人in，　都唔中定英既問題，合眼緣多Ｄ。聖誕樹都有反應家，平常心啦。

你仲記得聖誕樹.... 哈哈....

ronniedad

可唔可以咁睇, 可能學校的英普班原意係希望俾D屋企真係以普通話溝通的家庭報讀. 等佢地係課堂上能夠理解. 只是而家大趨勢要三文兩語至多左家長想報讀. 咁佢要問多些理由都不為過啩.