梁錦松二仔獲男拔小取錄

Zhaiba

You guys so sad.

He alone cannot build the current education system so please don't criticise anymore, he is also just a parent like us.

He is so successful in his career isnt it "normal" that these elite school will definitely accept his son? Where is back door?

hogwarts

HoHoMon,

Yes, he is the "ONE".  Also, He is also member of a number of advisory bodies of our Central Government.  You see, the elites know what is the best for themselves and the commoners la.

Ah, the family might think SPCC still having a Chinese section and sent the girl by good faith.

HoHoMom

Not sure what's so sad about pointing out the fact that he is the one who strongly advocated teachign in mother tongue, yet sending his son to an English school. Those are just objective facts.

Successful in his career ? .......well, depends on who you speak to.  He and his fans would probably agree with that.

原帖由 Zhaiba 於 11-1-10 20:53 發表
You guys so sad.

He alone cannot build the current education system so please don't criticise anymore, he is also just a parent like us.

He is so successful in his career isnt it "normal" that these ...

HoHoMom

原帖由 hogwarts 於 11-1-10 20:55 發表
HoHoMon,

Yes, he is the "ONE".  Also, He is also member of a number of advisory bodies of our Central Government.  You see, the elites know what is the best for themselves and the commoners la.

Ah,  ...

kenmay

(己多不欲，勿施於人), 套用在他身上最適當.
GoodGrief, 請不要誤會, 我不是反對你的論點, 只是借用你的佳句.

原帖由 GoodGrief 於 11-1-10 19:05 發表
我想提出另一觀點。


梁錦松先生和伏明霞女士是“公眾人物”，這是事實，他們不能改變這點。若學校因他們的名人身份而收了他們的子女，這是他們的問題還是學校的問題？

若梁先生真的“走後門”，但是收定唔收梁先生的子女的 ...

hogwarts

Other interesting fact about Mr. Leung.  He is also founder of UGA, the NGO which runs the DSS UGA.   

Yes, Mr. Leung is only one of the ruling elite, and should not be responsible to all the good or wrong doings of the system.  It is their deeds making you feel being betrayed and treated like fools.

Yes, as a parent, I can understand their choice as parents but I cannot forget and forgive their high sounding policy and salesmanship in the past.  

As quoted by Billy Joel in his song "Honesty":

"If you search for tenderness
it isn't hard to find.
You can have the love you need to live.

But if you look for truthfulness
You might just as well be blind.
It always seems to be so hard to give.

Honesty is such a lonely word.
Everyone is so untrue.
Honesty is hardly ever heard....."

Yes, we can give tenderness to our children but do not look for honesty from our leaders.

We should just enjoy Billy Joel's "Honesty"

http://www.metacafe.com/watch/sy-13406455/billy_joel_honesty_official_music_video/

[ 本帖最後由 hogwarts 於 11-1-10 22:00 編輯 ]

ANChan59

A kind reminder, my initial post just persume Mr. leung's attitude and direction of his third kid's education path only.

No intention against his family......

I am so glad most parents are very considerate and limited the discussion just on policy level and based on objective facts.

Zhaiba

If Asia chief of Blackstone is not successful then I donno what is.  

He made a mistake in buying a car, he was wrong and he resigned, paid his price.  But of course you can keep critising this foreever.

hogwarts

Asian chief of BlackStone, without doubt, is a benchmark of great success.

Well, the good performance of the fund and the investments of our Central Government ................

Yes, one has paid the price, while some of us are still paying the price, but of course, we will share the leaders' vision and live with their strategies for the benefit of our future generations and not the least - our city.

Yes, we should be patient and be grateful.

[ 本帖最後由 hogwarts 於 11-1-10 23:19 編輯 ]

Zhaiba

原帖由 HoHoMom 於 11-1-10 21:11 發表
Not sure what's so sad about pointing out the fact that he is the one who strongly advocated teachign in mother tongue, yet sending his son to an English school. Those are just objective facts.

Succ ...

What a funny logic.  If he choose DBS does that means he needs to convert every school to DBS for the general public?

sadsam

同意。不要人身攻擊。

好似葉劉咁咪係一樣，佢宜家都唔support政府啦！打工既，冇計 >_<

原帖由 Student123 於 11-1-10 19:19 發表
Please stop the atmopshere of attacking.

If he didn't show up during the briefing & interview process & get admitted to DBSPD, BK Parents will attack in another version, right?

If he send his son t ...

caa

How sad we are being HK people! If those government officers at the very top don't buy some policies, why didn't they fight for the good but instead pushed forward those arguable policies to our general public? All of them are considered successful and it should be easy for them to find another job and quit if they were really "forced" to put forward something they couldn't agree.

The general public's children are put in the test lab first. If it turns out right, maybe the gov officers' children will then go for it.

原帖由 sadsam 於 11-1-11 09:54 發表
同意。不要人身攻擊。

好似葉劉咁咪係一樣，佢宜家都唔support政府啦！打工既，冇計 >_<

sadsam

真係好sad架。

sadsam

係囉，應該仲要試下唔同既banding，由第一身家長既親身感受最好不過。名校要試，就殺既校都要試，殺唔死既也要試。

原帖由 hui916 於 11-1-10 18:25 發表
不過我認為梁生應安排其二仔去入讀一間有殺校危機的Band 3小學, 才能感受一下民眾的疾苦.

judy

I don't think so, because when he promoted the educational reform(s), he didn't have kids yet. He promoted any non-sense and he wouldn't the receiving end in the past.

Now, he is the player, a father and fully understand the importance of education and the quality of traditional famous elite school. I can guarantee he won't send his kids to Pui Kiu, International schools, and some new approaches DSS....

我想問吓，拔褲，唔係教改之產物麽？教改的其中一項，就係鼓勵拆墙鬆。提供更多選擇。有人喜歡培僑那類學校，有人喜歡拔褲較傳统喲，各花入各眼。所有進步社會無不如此。何 non-sense之有呢？

HoHoMom

But your logic is far funnier. And the question isthe what's so sad about stating objective facts ?

HoHoMom

If to act against what one preaches is not hypocracy and irresponsibility, I dunno what is.

Anyone here cares about that car incident anymore ? You are the one bringing it up.

原帖由 Zhaiba 於 11-1-10 22:33 發表
If Asia chief of Blackstone is not successful then I donno what is.  

He made a mistake in buying a car, he was wrong and he resigned, paid his price.  But of course you can keep critising this foree ...

Zhaiba

Is it so difficult to understand?  The government set policy which it thinks is best for the general public but there is no policy which can possibly satisfy everyone.  The official definitely have their rights to choose what they think are best for them which may not be suitable for the general public, or what the government cannot provide.

e.g. most of the parents want to send their kids to DXS (or whatever elite school they want), can the government change all the government school to the elite school?  No! no government can possibly do that so why keep critising this man who is just a parent like us who want to give a better education to his kid......that is the sad thing.