請分享細仔/細女轉讀更好小學repeat P1經驗

brian61950

我仔女都係12月出世,仔係細仔,各方面都表現差些.女比佢做大女,各方面都舒服好多.
你所想的未必可行,因一年比一年難,學校缩小班及出生率大升(多了外來人),還是勤力d好過啦.

mattmame

不能就你只是細女或細仔來作應留一年或不留的!可以給多一點資料嗎?希望我都可以幫幫手.

1)  你小朋友在那間KINDER?

2)  你要入的小學是那幾間?

3)  你小朋友在那方面較差?

4)  女女有家姐或哥哥嗎?

小曳人

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-12-15 18:31 發表
.
你所想的未必可行,因一年比一年難,學校缩小班及出生率大升(多了外來人),還是勤力d好過啦. ...

我都好應同
最近先有個同學仔媽媽問我, 細女, 唔知去唔去重讀K1好~
我都係話一年比一年難.. 真係要3思呀!

ccmommy

我個女係細女(11月中出世), 今年repeat K3.  我舊年只係同佢報考DGJS & SPCC, 但兩間都唔得(無2nd in).  今年除左呢兩間外, 另外再考了6間, 有2nd in 的就全部有得2nd in, 只有1 round interview的就全部都收 (未知result未計), 但那年的出生率是很低的.

mycy

可唔可以先讀p1, 出年再考名校p1?

有無人試過?

Clarawsf

Dear all,
My boy is Dec 05 baby, He studies in K3 n has finished all the P1 interviews but all failed...( over 10 schools ), I am now planning to let him repeat K3 next year. Dunno if it works but I dun want to let him repeat P1 in the gov't or any subsidized schools that I am not targeted in ( I am in Net 40 )...Any advice?
Btw, do you all know if it is difficult to repeat K3 in some hot kinder like St Cat, Keenmind, Learning Habitat?

Thx

Clarawsf

Any advice, pls??

wong_mf89

my son is a Oct boy.  My strategy is:
I will join government P1 allocation and pick the school which I prefer.  To play safe, will also apply private school and DSS (should apply different tiers of school to enhance acceptance chances since afraid the kid is not competitive enough) .  If all failed, or only accepted by those which I not so prefer,  I will still pick the best one to let the kid study P1 first.  After all, under P1 allocation system, all kids will have a seat.  Then, will apply again private & DSS next year to P1 or even P2, depending on kid's maturity.

pandabonita

小朋友到了k2已知道乜叫升班,所以票要留的話k1會好d,不然你要解釋得好清楚,不過每個人的程況都5同,無一個肻定的答案

ync_224

請教大家, 細B若因家姐已有不錯的小學 offer, 還會給她 repeat 嗎?

我不知道我的細B是否有問題, K1三個月了, 還認不到英文字及數字, 攪到我好勞氣.  同家姐 (大B) 話頭醒尾相比, 真是天同地.

前幾日想同細B做假期作業, 有4隻襪 (其中一隻唔同顏色), 搵不同之處, 比哂 hints, 佢都完全唔知我想問咩, 教多兩教, 我忍唔住收埋唔教, 去教大女 ...

細B古惑野多, 但功課完全唔得.  知道不應兩姐妹比較, 但放工歸家後已經好累, 在教極唔明下, 實在控制不到自已 ...

請問細B通常到幾歲才與大B level 呢?

[ 本帖最後由 ync_224 於 10-12-21 17:19 編輯 ]

Sumyeema1

原帖由 goldenbaby 於 10-12-15 18:21 發表
重讀K1

可以考一條龍女校o即KG, 例如聖心，德望，聖保祿， 大坑真光，
或者男女校o即KG, 例如培正。

Kangaroo

原帖由 Clarawsf 於 10-12-17 09:15 發表
Dear all,
My boy is Dec 05 baby, He studies in K3 n has finished all the P1 interviews but all failed...( over 10 schools ), I am now planning to let him repeat K3 next year. Dunno if it works but I d ...

I do not recommend repeat k3 as next year the population will be even bigger than this year and thus the competition will be more keen. Even if the kid is more mature next year, there is no guarantee to get a seat you prefer.

Furbymao

very true, the birth rate of 2006 is at least 8,000 more than 2005, the competition is really keen, and there's no guarantee for super big kids ....

445566

ync
我大女係1月出世, 我細仔係12月出世, 2者係好大分別, 大1個月都唔同啦, 點可以將大女既k1 表現同細b 比較呢...
我細仔依架係k3, 我仔k1時, 完全咩都唔識, 我仔去到k2下學期才叫有d d 似k2 學生, 而上了k3, 就好好多了, 當然不能同別人既大b 比較, 始終人地係大d, 又加上我地唔可以唔承認, 有2個小孩, 我地做mommy 都分心d 啦.. 有時人地又係12月出世, 我仔又係, 不過人地只有一個小孩, 咩都付出多d 啦...

而考小一, 我仔只考了一間私小, 都成功, 不過唔係d 咩名小..
而上小一擔唔擔心, 我大女既經驗話比我知.. 唔係大女一定叻過細女既... 因為佢班考得叻既都細過我女既... 睇小孩本身架咋...
所以我唔會repeat k3, 反而睇佢上學點, 再作出安排, 如果真係唔得, 先轉校再來過lor...

原帖由 ync_224 於 10-12-21 17:09 發表
請教大家, 細B若因家姐已有不錯的小學 offer, 還會給她 repeat 嗎?

我不知道我的細B是否有問題, K1三個月了, 還認不到英文字及數字, 攪到我好勞氣.  同家姐 (大B) 話頭醒尾相比, 真是天同地.

前幾日想同細B做假期 ...

nicolemummy

你仔仔即我仔仔個間都OK架. 我仔仔(8月仔, 無得REPEAT)兩間收, 一間九龍近課程深, 一間就係我地個間但很遠. 我地仲係1516...
但最近, 我地想, 如果在你仔仔個間, 讀得唔夠好, 都有直屬中學收, 如果讀得好, 超過80分, 副校長在字裡行間都話D仔會考其他學校. 在該區其他學校指KINGS, ST JOE個D...
但在九龍個間, 讀到幾深都好, 如果考唔到DBS個D, 就留在觀磄, 都有好中學但大約KINGS STJOE相差一些吧..
所以, 我地都傾向讀得壓力少一些, 但有BACKUP又係好中學校網的這一間.

原帖由 445566 於 10-12-21 23:57 發表
ync
我大女係1月出世, 我細仔係12月出世, 2者係好大分別, 大1個月都唔同啦, 點可以將大女既k1 表現同細b 比較呢...
我細仔依架係k3, 我仔k1時, 完全咩都唔識, 我仔去到k2下學期才叫有d d 似k2 學生, 而上了k3, 就好 ...

karen55407

唔好畀小朋友做細仔，最好就係一早安排遲一年入學，如果要留班都在K1-2留，以上資料係兒童心理專家講嘅。