幼稚園爆退學潮

BabyAlexander

Will you still paying the school fee and school bus for July if it still suspended?

http://hk.apple.nextmedia.com/te ... amp;art_id=12890135

本報訊】幼稚園及小學因豬流感停課，暫時未知會否復課，部份 K3學生家長索性安排子女提早退學，幼稚園業界表示已出現退學潮，情況與沙士疫潮時相似。立法會教育界議員張文光指不少家長停交學費，尤以已獲小一派位的畢業班學生家長為甚。
香港幼稚園協會永遠會長胡肖霞表示，不少幼稚園面對家長因停課而不肯交學費的問題，更由於 K3班的學生將升讀小一，部份家長已安排子女退學。她慨嘆「就算停課老師都要照出糧，學校都要交電費，我哋亦都會照畀校車錢，但家長就唔交學費。」
張文光也指出，不少幼稚園向他反映，家長因全港幼稚園停課而停交學費，其中以已獲小一派位的畢業班學生家長為主，「停交兩個月，啲老師要減薪甚至冇得出糧，政府會唔會幫忙？」教育局副秘書長葉曾翠卿認為，雖然學券可幫助幼稚園度過難關，但呼籲家長「唔好唔交學費」。

bakusensei

actually, EDB has forewarned kindergartens, primary schools, etc well on 12 May that there may be a possibility to suspend the school if there is any local case (http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Common/letter_to_sch_20090512_chi.pdf).

if the kindergarten has any well planning, they should be able to arrange a much better continguency during the school suspension.

If a kindergarten thinks that it has already done its best by simply opening the kindergarten during school suspension, I personally don't think this is a responsible kindergarten and I don't think kindergartens doing the "minimum" work is still justified to get the "full" pay.

Kendis1

阿校長呀!麥妳咁得閒嘅, 妳唔係應該諗僅"對策"架咩?

原帖由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 21:22 發表
唉....真係俾你激死, 講極都唔明....

阿校長呀, 若然因為今次停課而導致你收少咗學費而你真係成功告到一個的話, 請公告天下, 以達致你殺一儆百嘅宏願



...

熱血媽媽

算把啦, 打手...

By the way, parents are getting more aggressive to get refund from school and respective activities.

補習班拒退款家長投訴
2009年06月26日
(未有評分)瀏覽人次：1,367 回應：0 轉寄朋友 文章回應
【本報訊】多間學校、補習社及興趣班因豬流感疫潮而停課，令家長措手不及。消費者委員會至今接獲七宗豬流感相關的家長投訴，全部因家長與主辦單位就課程取消退款或延期與否引起爭拗。該會發言人表示，會了解事件及協助投訴人調停，若未能退款，會盡量爭取把課程延期。

批評教局指引不清晰
本報接獲多名家長投訴稱，其所屬補習社等停課，家長要求終止或順延課程，但不獲受理。蔡太向本報表示，擔心升中二的女兒感染豬流感，因此希望終止補習，但有關補習班不肯退款或順延課程，只提議一對一補習，減低感染風險，「一對一我又唔想，放暑假唔想個女太大壓力。希望補習社彈性處理，但係佢話如果六月唔交學費，就發律師信告我。」
蔡太引述消委會稱，成功爭取退款的機會渺茫。她批評教育局對坊間補習社應否停課或順延的指引不清晰，引起不必要混亂。
消委會發言人表示，七宗豬流感相關投訴中，包括 playgroup、補習班、鋼琴班、校巴及遊學團等，涉及費用 1,000元至 6,000元。

boilermaker

Should be like this:

各位唔好再比佢借題發"din"啦 !

原帖由 Namnam05 於 09-6-24 21:19 發表
各位唔好再比佢借題發揮啦 !

Namnam05

無錯所以再講落去無意思兼嘥氣~

原帖由 avbee 於 09-6-24 21:22 發表
surely all the new registers are either teachers or principles

avbee

surely all the new registers are either teachers or principles

winsonma

唉....真係俾你激死, 講極都唔明....

阿校長呀, 若然因為今次停課而導致你收少咗學費而你真係成功告到一個的話, 請公告天下, 以達致你殺一儆百嘅宏願

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 20:42 發表



殺一儆百, 有何不可? 至少要讓家長明白, 幼稚園有權根據教育條例收取符合規定的收費, 那些欠費家長, 又有沒有辦法證明幼稚園濫收費, 又或者沒根據教育局指示辦學? ...

Namnam05

各位唔好再比佢借題發揮啦 !

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 20:46 發表


問題係, 做多d野, 維持良好校譽, 當然對人對己有好處, 但不等於其他幼稚園不能按規定收費!

請問有那一條例規定幼稚園停課便要減收某月份學費?

dolala

原帖由 熱血媽媽 於 09-6-24 15:03 發表
Yes agreed, you can see LH charge 12 months but done a very good contingency plan on this.  a lot better than those kinders just sending a few worksheets, then declaring they have done a lot of work a ...

問題係, 做多d野, 維持良好校譽, 當然對人對己有好處, 但不等於其他幼稚園不能按規定收費!

請問有那一條例規定幼稚園停課便要減收某月份學費?

[ 本帖最後由 dolala 於 09-6-24 20:48 編輯 ]

dolala

原帖由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 15:55 發表
Oh, my god! 我真係無諗過你會提議行呢步, 你知道嗎? 我以前公司從來都不會做這個行動, 因為cost大, 但係return 可能係零, 不過還好, 你不是話揾收數公司, 唉...真係得啖笑~

...

殺一儆百, 有何不可? 至少要讓家長明白, 幼稚園有權根據教育條例收取符合規定的收費, 那些欠費家長, 又有沒有辦法證明幼稚園濫收費, 又或者沒根據教育局指示辦學?

dolala

原帖由 kaifu 於 09-6-24 16:47 發表
Any school principals who are "smart" enough to do that will definitely get a lot of free publicity in the press.  How would that sound to parents of potential kindergarten applicants?  Lighten up, do ...

如果告低收入人士, 可能不近人情。但如果係有一定收入的呢? 無能力付和撒賴不付, 可是兩回事啊!

kaifu

Any school principals who are "smart" enough to do that will definitely get a lot of free publicity in the press.  How would that sound to parents of potential kindergarten applicants?  Lighten up, dolala prinicipal!

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

winsonma

Oh, my god! 我真係無諗過你會提議行呢步, 你知道嗎? 我以前公司從來都不會做這個行動, 因為cost大, 但係return 可能係零, 不過還好, 你不是話揾收數公司, 唉...真係得啖笑~

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

[ 本帖最後由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 16:09 編輯 ]

熱血媽媽

Yes agreed, you can see LH charge 12 months but done a very good contingency plan on this.  a lot better than those kinders just sending a few worksheets, then declaring they have done a lot of work and charging full fees. :;pppp: :;pppp:

for 打官司,  even勝了, but losing  goodwill.  I think not many kinders will risk themselve for this......

bakusensei

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:58 發表
學校假若已經按照教育局指示提供服務, 就算唔係家長心目中既全面上課, 都已經仁至義盡啦!.

i m not sure what's the meaning of "按照教育局指示提供服務". Do you mean simply keep the kindergarten open or just give the kids a little assignments for that two wks or the whole 1.5 months?

some kindergartens, like Learning Habitat, continue to send students video recording the lessons (yes, teachers continue to teach) and homework everyday by school bus and continue to collect and "mark" the homework everyday.

a lot of parents there r v. appreciated about the work the kindergartens done. n didn't ve complaints.

kinders simply keep themselves open really can't say sth like 仁至義盡.

heiheiada

yes! yes! 一定係開左好多個分身去鬧通街!  

原帖由 boilermaker 於 09-6-24 12:33 發表
sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

dolala

原帖由 boilermaker 於 09-6-24 12:33 發表
sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

我作為旁觀者, 都係希望你地注意下法律風險, 學校假如已依足政府指示開放, 佢打官司勝算係有架

boilermaker

sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12