浸會大學附屬幼稚園,小學及中學(王錦輝中小學)

LoveAschool

dickwu_1968,

I can only agree that there were some tiny problems when the school started to operate, but I think they were far less serious than what you described.  May be I am not a person in the educational field as you do, I don’t understand why the school deserves such a serious complaint from you.  Could you share your experience with us on how good a new school should behave for the first few weeks and how many new schools you have monitored to arrive at the conclusion that HKBUAS is “未見過一間新校是如斯不濟!”?  Your elaboration can help us to judge whether your complaint is right or wrong.

Back in Jul, the school already stated that the Math would be taught in Chinese for the first one/two terms.  Then, it would be changed to English.  It is a fact that the school later added an Eng Math book (probably under the pressure of parents), but they still keep the original plan to teach the Math in Chinese.  So, why did you describe them as “左搖右擺, 漫無立場”?

I also attended the parent-school meeting, but I did not notice that Ms Din avoided any question from the parents.

I suppose you, just like most of the P1 parents of HKBUAS, did not have many chances to have personal contact with the Principals or teachers.  You mentioned that your kid had told you “some information” such that you could conclude “校方多方混亂, 行政人員失責”, Ms Din “演出她的語文天份, 似乎沒有關心學習差異!”.  I suppose your kid is about 6 yrs old.  He/she might not be able to tell you all the truth or might have missed some important information.  Do you think it is a bit unfair to the school if you complaint based on a kid’s feedback?

I think many parents know the working history of Ms Din.  It is not a secret at all.  Did you just know that after the meeting last week?  I think HKBU must have good reasons to get Ms Din on board.  Personally, I don’t need Ms Din, nor any teacher, to prove his/her ability to me before they can take up a role at the school.

Your comment on Ms Din and 陳博士 looks like a vicious personal attack.  Did you know them for a long time or have any history with them?

Since you complaints are such serious, why don't you call up the school to have a discussion with them?

pangw

Dear parents,

A-school informed me that my kid’s admission application is successful, a confirmation letter have been sent out on 30 September 2006.  Suddenly, I become a 07-08 G1 parent and I feel very happy.  I started to observe, collect much information about primary schools and compare the schools for months and years.  Finally, I only applied for A-school only among many other famous schools as I trust A-school.
          

sunlight

同意LoveAschool見解及歡迎pangw加入我們的大家庭。

BUprimary

Hello_minimini,
Is your child in Red group and blue reading group?  

BUprimary

dickwu_1968 寫道:
我的小朋友所說, 由她所領導的  RED GROUP 根本就好像沒有學過東西, 她只顧自己"演出"她的語文天份, 似乎沒有關心學習差異!
My son is also in RED GROUP. Some parents heard from school that children in RED GROUP have higher standard of english. I believe my son is also good at that. In fact, I met Ms. Din once and she can spot my son's english ability and said she will look at his process and apply a more advance level of program for him. THE SCHOOL HAS ALREADY GROUP STUDENTS IN VARIOUS ENGLISH STANDARD, YOUR CHILD'S RED GROUP IS ALREADY IN HIGHER LEVEL. THEY 'VE GOT PROGRAM TO IDENIFRY YOUR CHILD'S ENGLISH ABLITITY.

[quote]
dickwu_1968 寫道:
本人是教育界一員, 深知校內高層機關算盡, 富教育熱誠者 ...... 我只希望我們投下這學校暫時信任的一票不至落空, 我們的小朋友可以在好的老師下教導成長, 而不想被一群瞎心眼的領導害了大家的寶貝 !

Just for my opinion, if you are a professional in education aspect, can observe the poor managment of the school SO FAST and don't feel comfortable with any of the teachers, if i were you, I will look for another YOUR GOOD SCHOOL for my child.

keithfolks

Hi dickwu_1968

I respect freedom of speech and thought.  However, I TOTALLY disagree with your comments.

My daughter is in Red Group too.  Nothing much in the learning?  Perhaps, your kid is an outstanding student or the teaching method in A-School is nothing to us.  Does your kid make a letter-book of her own?  Do you read the story book “…Hungry Caterpillar…” to your kid?  Does your kid read that to you too?  What is your favorite part (inclusive of your kid and you) on the letter-book and the story book?  The favorite parts are which your kid and you should share.  Oops, possibly we did a lot but my daughter told us to do so…

Anyway, I believe you have full of striking thoughts.  Your resistance is not fair or not healthy to your kid growing up in the A-School.  Because we will model ourselves on our way of thinking and behaving to our kids.  Your children will replicate anything from you too.

Please excuse my ruggedness.

dickwu_1968 寫道:
各位關心自己子女, 你們好!
本人亦是教育界一員, 自己的小朋友現正讀小一. 只是開學至今, 加上上星期的家長夜之後, 委實不吐不快!
開學至今, 就我觀察及小朋友告知, 校方多方混亂, 行政人員失責, 實是有目共睹, 亦是我從事教育界以來, 最令人痛心, 可以說, 未見過一間新校是如斯不濟!
就以數學科的教學語言為例, 左搖右擺, 漫無立場, 亦不見有明顯的理念及目標, 實在令人咋舌!
更甚,未見有明顯的理念及目標者, 在英文科尤為嚴重, 上星期的家長夜是令我絕望的, 當天我想是英文科的主任, 亦是本人頗有微言的副校長 -- Miss Din, 她對小一英文科的"理念", 本人實在不感苟同, 應該說, 以她為首的英文科是沒有理念及教學方法的, 因為她根本沒有正面回應過, 在我看來, 學校的英文科可能沒有定下明確的目標, 或許開校倉卒, 沒有準備好吧!  不過, 她作為學校及英文科的代表, 總沒可能如此混過家長們的提問. 據我的小朋友所說, 由她所領導的  RED GROUP 根本就好像沒有學過東西, 她只顧自己"演出"她的語文天份, 似乎沒有關心學習差異!
作為同行, 有必要一考察她的背景, 以作一公正的評價, 一看之下, 昔日她是加拿大國際學校及弘立書院的校長, 不過, 她是否有過人之政績及教學論著? 至少本人未見! 更令人懷疑的是, 她在弘立不是很長時間, 而弘立又因高昂的學費, 未見卓績, 則學校為何特邀她過來呢? 實成疑問.  更令我擔心的是, 本人只見其扶搖直上, 教學成就未見, 教學理念更是 ... 那我們小朋友的英文水平 ........
評論要公允及宏觀一點, 據同行所稱, 另一位副校長陳博士是惠僑的校長, 但今年惠僑好像收生也成問題, 那麼他是落難校長? 特邀他過來, 還是又有玄機?
學校宣稱重視 IT 教學, 那為何課室連電腦也沒有 ? 這又正是學校急就章而開學, 準備不足的寫照!
本人是教育界一員, 深知校內高層機關算盡, 富教育熱誠者 ...... 我只希望我們投下這學校暫時信任的一票不至落空, 我們的小朋友可以在好的老師下教導成長, 而不想被一群瞎心眼的領導害了大家的寶貝 !

sunlight

轉個話題，講啲開心嘢。

今日第一日穿新校服，小朋友真係好開心呀！
昨晚熨衫前，我女急着試穿，並對着鏡子跳起舞來。今早我拖着女兒上校車時，已坐在校車內的幾位小朋友連忙企起身，拉住隻蝴蝶仔show俾我睇佢地件靚靚裙，好可愛啊！
我女是1号車，第4~5站上車。前幾站的家長，你們的小朋友好可愛，每天早上都好生猛，跟我女好好傾tim！

kris313

dear pangw,

when did you receive the call, today or before?

pangw

kris313,

I received call on 30 September 2006.

kris313 寫道:
dear pangw,

when did you receive the call, today or before?

BUprimary

Hi keithfolks,
Which reading group is your daughter in? My son is in blue reading group.   

leonchan

我本人就覺得學校教英文很好很有系統，以下幾點和大家分享吓：

1.本應每班有30人，但上英文堂就分group上，減至每group只有20人，而且上堂時仲會由兩位老師分兩組教；一組是5-6人reading group，會上15mins左右，另一組就上phonics、spelling skill、等等其他內容。明顯學校是不怕麻煩，希望減低師生比例，務求照顧每一位學生。

2.閱讀計劃有專人評估過小朋友是否有能力看完才派第二本，不像一般學校只派書回家叫父母和小朋友一起看就算，跟本唔知你識唔識，而且學校還派了一封信給我們，教我們有步驟地和子女一起閱讀。

3.english team時常有派通告，告知家長他們的進度及在做什麼。

4.Phonics及spelling教得很有系統，比其他學校好好多！

    

Allie

dickwu,

我都好想知多d 你的見解!  你可以再詳細一點或舉例嗎?  作為一個教育行內人, 你對初選浸小一定經過深思熟累, 亦對佢期望殷切!  所為何事你會咁快失望及憤怒呢?  

既然我們選了浸小, 就當然希望她會愈來愈好, 所以若你有建設性的提議, 何不直接向學校反映呢?  又或你覺得一人之力不可行, 你可以講出來, 我們一起探究, 再一起向學校提出來.  我相信正面的回應總比負面的批評好!  何須這麼快定了學校死罪呢?!

keithfolks

Hi BUprimary

My daughter is in Red Group.

keithfolks

Just want to clarify my reply to dickwu_1968.

"full of striking thoughts" means "充滿卓越見解; 為信念原則而奮鬥"

Sorry for the confusion.

AAK

Dear BUprimary,

我囡囡也是藍組.我從來未見過那本Spelling Skills書本.我還以為書店尚未派發.不知您們可有收到.還是真的比老師收了?

AAK

KristieMom

My daughter' Kristie Ho' is also in Blue group. She comes from G1E. I found that her English skills is improving. I agreed with the school's teaching method. Let's time to prove the truth      

KristieMom

The book of spelling Skills was sent to students few days ago. My daughter told me that she need to bring to school today, maybe, the teacher has collected it already.

car-long

各BU 家長早晨      今日又係一個好既新開始啦 !

dickwu  ,

你/妳 好 ,  好好奇你 / 妳為什麼要用新 login 係呢個 topic 留言 ?

新學校亂就預左 ,  只會唔傷害同影響小朋友既可以接受既 ,  你 / 妳既然亦都係 "同行" 你應該清楚明白 " 上有上政策 下有下對策 " 既道理架 .

老師過去係點係好重要 , 今日人地改善左 , 可以比過機會人地嗎 ?   我大仔以前既老師轉左校而家在另一間學校教緊我細仔 ,  好明顯我細仔極喜歡呢位老師 , 我以前係投訴過佢對我個仔 .....  殺校老師轉投另一間學校 , 係好多學校都會發生 ,  校長可能有原因 ( maybe 合作開 ok ) 先至找某老師回校做自已班底 ,   早幾年前我亦面對過咁上下既問題 , 好懷疑那位用廣東話來自殺校的老師點教我個仔 !?  結果係 - - 都幾好啦 !

其實而家係 d 咩事令你咁嬲 ?

carlong