女拔是否平民免問有冇成功家庭分享面試經驗

FatWater

How come?  DGJS cannot be someone's backup for lucky draw as you are not allowed to join the lucky draw after accepting the offer of DGJS.

Mrssslui 寫道:
DGS for her only as a backup.
She may afraid of her girl's ability.
She's still waiting a subsiz school in Central district, of course, this school cannot compare with DGS.
It's true.

          

hellohoo

duplicate entry: see below.

hellohoo

i'm sorry if this has caused fury in other parents esp the 2 新加入國民 ClaraFong and BoBoCute.
I'm just sharing my experience with what i encounter in medical school and children's choir. This is what happened (re "not very welcomed in groups and they always like to stick together with other DGS girls or DBS boys'")
Maybe because my DGS friends from these samples are either smart or rich. But this is the truth.
I am not against DGS at all. I think it's a very good school indeed. I was being admitted to DGJS, so no biased at all. It's just that in general, they are indeed more snobbish than those other smart students i encounter from other elite schools. That's it! No offence!

ClaraFong 寫道:
I also agree with BoBoCute.
hellohoo's comment about DGS girls being 'usually not very welcomed in groups and they always like to stick together with other DGS girls or DBS boys' is very biased.  這些批評並沒有客觀理據支持,單靠主觀感覺,對DGS學生不公平.

Gorowitz

Dear hellohoo,

How about St. Paul's Co-ed., arguably in the same league as DGS? Do you find their students arrogant and snobbish? Your comment is much appreciated.

Gorowitz

Mrssslui

Why not?? DGS is a private school not DSS, so they have chance in lucky draw.

FatWater 寫道:
How come?  DGJS cannot be someone's backup for lucky draw as you are not allowed to join the lucky draw after accepting the offer of DGJS.



[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
DGS for her only as a backup.
She may afraid of her girl's ability.
She's still waiting a subsiz school in Central district, of course, this school cannot compare with DGS.
It's true.

          [/quote]

Mrssslui

This is an ever ending question.
I think it depends on personal character and family background more than which school they studied.
The comments are given by different person, can't compare.

Gorowitz 寫道:
Dear hellohoo,

How about St. Paul's Co-ed., arguably in the same league as DGS? Do you find their students arrogant and snobbish? Your comment is much appreciated.

Gorowitz

FatWater

Ask some one who has really been accepted by DGJS.  Once you accept the offer of DGJS, your name will be given to EMB of the government.  If you join the lucky draw, EMB will inform DGJS your lucky draw result before 4 June.  DGJS can cancel her offer to you immediately.  This is a well known procedure that many famous private schools will cancel the offer to you once you join the lucky draw.  Otherwise, there will be not a topic in BK asking 請各家長提供資料>邊間私小收生後唔容許大抽獎 at http://www.babykingdom.com/modules/newbb/viewtopic.php?topic_id=333490&forum=7&24

I am not being offensive.  But, if your friend has really joined the lucky draw after accepting DGJS offer, ask her to be careful that the offer might have already been cancelled.

Mrssslui 寫道:
Why not?? DGS is a private school not DSS, so they have chance in lucky draw.
[quote]
FatWater 寫道:
How come?  DGJS cannot be someone's backup for lucky draw as you are not allowed to join the lucky draw after accepting the offer of DGJS.



[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
DGS for her only as a backup.
She may afraid of her girl's ability.
She's still waiting a subsiz school in Central district, of course, this school cannot compare with DGS.
It's true.

          [/quote][/quote]

Mrssslui

I know she is on the waiting list of the subsid school, then will DGS cancel her seat?

Sindy

Mrssslui 寫道:
I know she is on the waiting list of the subsid school, then will DGS cancel her seat?

以我所知,係唔會架喎,佢都唔驚無人讀啦

WYmom

Don't understand, if the girl has joined lucky draw, she should have been allocated to a school, then DGJS will have cancelled her seat already.

hellohoo

Gorowitz,
To be honest with you (and other parents too), i personally feel that there's not much difference at all ACADEMICALLY between the top well-known elite schools-- eg St Paul's co-ed, DGS, DBS, Maryknoll, La Salle, Wah Yan, etc etc etc (+many others not mentioned). They all have very smart students and average students. The main difference is probably the more active participation in extra-curricular activities, school spirit, the way students carry themselves under the influence of their 師兄師姐. Rich and smart students not necessarily are snobbish. Average students can be arrogant too.

But from what i encounter, among all the above top elite schools, DGS has the highest level of snobbishness. Although i hate snobs, i understand one can be snobbish if she's smart or rich, but in many DGS cases, they are like 餅印 ,they believe they are the best and a lot never listen to others and to 講難聽D, some even look down on other non-elite school students.
But the good points of DGS is well-known -- good academic result, variety of extra-curricular activies and participation, and the strong sense to the school.

For St Paul's co-ed, I cannot make a more detailed account than DGS, because I know less SPCC students than DGS, but from what i encounter, they put more emphasis on academic but not on activities, which i think are as important.

In terms of being snobbish and arrogant, they also think they are the best, but different from DGS, they compete with 自己 to reach own's goal rather than competing with other students or colleagues to reach the goal. The 心態 is totally different.

As influenced by the traditional history of 師兄師姐, SPCC students do tend to run along the civil servant 'road'+ other profession.
what i mean is, different school can nurture different types of students, depite same academic level.    

Stones

dgs is dss now! :tongue:

navigator

當大家把話題轉到女拔的學生似乎經常給人一種自以為高人一等的印象時，我看這又能引伸到『平民』與『達官貴人』做人的一般特性了。『達官貴人』在社會上有地位，有頭有面，經常受到人們的『敬重』，內心當然是覺得高人一等。有修養及謙卑的，他們不會處處在人們面前『擺款』以便顯示自已是高人一等的。打個譬如來講，真正的有錢人是不需要自已經常向人家說自已是怎麽有錢的。我個人認為在現今人情冷暖和勝行虛偽的社會裏，有修養及謙虛的『達官貴人』不會是多數的。正如女拔是一家超級名校，其大部份的學生的學業成績等表現都很卓越，受到萬人的『敬重』般，肯定有些是沒有修養及謙卑的SNOBBISH學生存在。至於是多數抑或只是少數的學生才是這樣就不得而知了。假如教出來的學生多數這樣的，從另一個層面來看，女拔則很是失敗的。

BillyM

hellohoo 寫道:
Gorowitz,
To be honest with you (and other parents too), i personally feel that there's not much difference at all ACADEMICALLY between the top well-known elite schools-- eg St Paul's co-ed, DGS, DBS, Maryknoll, La Salle, Wah Yan, etc etc etc (+many others not mentioned). They all have very smart students and average students. The main difference is probably the more active participation in extra-curricular activities, school spirit, the way students carry themselves under the influence of their 師兄師姐. Rich and smart students not necessarily are snobbish. Average students can be arrogant too.

But from what i encounter, among all the above top elite schools, DGS has the highest level of snobbishness. Although i hate snobs, i understand one can be snobbish if she's smart or rich, but in many DGS cases, they are like 餅印 ,they believe they are the best and a lot never listen to others and to 講難聽D, some even look down on other non-elite school students.
But the good points of DGS is well-known -- good academic result, variety of extra-curricular activies and participation, and the strong sense to the school.

For St Paul's co-ed, I cannot make a more detailed account than DGS, because I know less SPCC students than DGS, but from what i encounter, they put more emphasis on academic but not on activities, which i think are as important.

In terms of being snobbish and arrogant, they also think they are the best, but different from DGS, they compete with 自己 to reach own's goal rather than competing with other students or colleagues to reach the goal. The 心態 is totally different.

As influenced by the traditional history of 師兄師姐, SPCC students do tend to run along the civil servant 'road'+ other profession.
what i mean is, different school can nurture different types of students, depite same academic level.    

I don't agree that there's not much difference in academics between the top schools.  Some schools you mentioned can teach better, and some worse.  

ginny66lee

其實我覺得學校好睇小朋友識唔識講英文同
講得好唔好，而作首要條件，
真係咁多有錢人讀咩，你估全港真係乘得
佢哋一間名校？我唸三份一是
舊生子女，三份一是有家底嫁學生，
最後三份一就是英文講得好和成績好嫁
學生。我個女讀ST，佢班就有兩個取錄咗，
但佢哋d成績不算特別好，只可講是一般，
但佢哋用英文做母語，而講中文就一D都唔惦！
BK網有D媽咪講佢D朋友個仔都係靜識講英文而取錄咗。

andrew

i personally feel that there's not much difference at all ACADEMICALLY between the top well-known elite schools-- eg St Paul's co-ed, DGS, DBS, Maryknoll, La Salle, Wah Yan, etc etc etc

I don't agree! It is difficult in HK to find more than 2 schools have the same standard as DGS.

Stones

Re真係咁多有錢人讀咩，你估全港真係乘得
佢哋一間名校？
        HK真係有好多有錢人(貧富縣殊)，DGS肯比位你去讀，大把人仆去！讀唔倒一件事。
  

123daddy

Perhaps you are right, but interview is conducted in Cantonese unless you have specified in your application form the kids speak english only.

123daddy

請回令千金讀邊間kindergarten?   

123daddy

這說明了爛船都有三斤釘