不知所為的聖馬加利

jeremyphlam

香港是一個很奇怪的地方，只要吹好自己英文有幾勁幾勁，自自然然就有人覺得係好學校。

都係個句，請半日假去學校附近睇下學生食晏，放學時的表現，再搵接放學的家長傾下，有幾難？

Lynn

我的女也正就讀SMC,也是我們比較過後的決定,我覺得還不錯! 可能也可以說自己讚自己花香!

當初的決定也包括了對其他家長的反應,在BK 或是我曾去校外看過,和我家校車等車的媽媽和工人姐姐談過,當然有些抱怨一些學校行政例如去年校車半途壞掉等等問題,但是大家對我都很friendly,我的女兒會在這兒讀書12年,學習不同的知識和同伴的互動,我的女兒是獨女,可想而知,這些同學會是她一生重要的友伴,一起成長,我很高興有一群和我會一樣用心的SMC家長一起勉勵自己, 小孩和學校都做得更好!   又再讚自己了!

AAmother

其實我地 SMC 的家長好少會回復這類帖的，少事放大的那樣樣都係大問題，豉汁和叉就能代表一所學校的
"好與壞" ???
我地的小朋友係學校是好開心愉快學習的，就我囝他病了都希望能返一日學，那就係我地家長想見到的健康、活潑、學習能力高的兒女！
學術程度有幾高，我地冇話自己高過謀謀學校，我地只係默默看守自己的兒女，盡能力比他們我地應為係最好的事物！

你也是最好父母，希望能找最合適的小學！

原帖由 bobo_ling 於 10-10-21 20:02 發表


我都唔知佢乜都無比我, 一坐低打開包燒賣,粒粒既皮都係爛, 覺得好差, 仲要遇上一個叫我上幾層樓才飲到啖水既清潔ar 姐, 比我感覺想係e間學校生存, 要有好高既容忍度, 同好大既能耐law.... ...

小品

To the parents who don't like the school but having the offers, please please release your offer to the waiting list.

kiu-mummy

作為SMC的家長，我認為總有其他人會覺得我地賣花讚花香的了，但我地有小朋友喺入面讀緊的，當然會最清楚裡面的情況，好與差梗會有，但我會衡量究竟差的事情喺咪真的去到接受不了的情況呢，例如小食部的服務態度，會否影響咗我的決定而唔入讀呢；又或者，面試時的安排稍為混亂，是否會蓋過我對這所學校優點的印象呢。凡事都有兩面，那就要衡量吓自己韵接受程度了。

sampapa

HKCEE result is no good.
May be middle of band 2.
Only the language subject is better.
Due to short history and first primay kid to secondary in 2008/2009.
Therefore, all result of CE come from new comer not own kid.
The primary parent is concerned the quality of secondary section.

sampapa

Some parent will select other band 1 or top DSS for secondary place not SMC.
I know some p6 kid promted to other top band 1 or top DSS by self.

I hope secondary is improved as primary secondary in coming years.

So far,
I will give mark to different area, 100 is full.
90~95% to education quality for primary section.
60~70% to education quality for secondary section.
40~50% to non-education area, eg general admin or clerical work.

sampapa

I think you are disappointed.
Some parent hold the seat to Aug/Sep, even SMC is not cup of tea.
They says "the school is bad or anything", but they hold the offer on the same time.
For me, when better offer received, other seat is released ASAP.
In 2009, some student is reported school after 1 week.
They are transfered from other school.
It means some kid not reported.

kc_01k

睇倒隔離個POST D SMC 家長, 圍剿人, 好恐怖吓.........

雖然唔關我事, 不過有點兒那個吧.  

CHIULHJ

可能你會感到很失望，事情發展不如你所說般，他們彼此尊重不好嗎?

原帖由 kc_01k 於 10-10-22 16:20 發表
睇倒隔離個POST D SMC 家長, 圍剿人, 好恐怖吓......... mouth:" />

雖然唔關我事, 不過有點兒那個吧.  

CHIULHJ

你所發表的嚴重指控跟事實不符，我想你欠了SMC家長們一個公道。

原帖由 kc_01k 於 10-10-22 16:20 發表
睇倒隔離個POST D SMC 家長, 圍剿人, 好恐怖吓......... mouth:" />

雖然唔關我事, 不過有點兒那個吧.  

Naurto

You gave an objective marking, and I apprecipate your honesty..... I have the same feeling that their lanuguage is good, and they put much effort ( I guess) on enlgish drama, and eng. poem activities..etc... My feeling is they are changing their strategies to be more and more traditional / tough in the future..... Hope your student enjoy the its english environment....

G-Ma

沒錯, 我們的小朋友要在這裡念12年的書, 當初我也是很小心選擇.  入了smc後我好開心係囡囡既同學品性都好好, 佢識到一班好朋友, 我相信佢地會係佢一生既好朋友啦!  而我地家長亦相處得好融洽.  仲有係很好感激學校既安排, 令到小女有好多不同發揮的機會, 特別是上一學期那個45周年的英文話劇表演(亞拉丁), 有幸囡囡可以參與, 中小學的同學一起排練了好多個月, 當晚的表演真係令我好感動, 我從來無諗過普通學校既話劇係會咁認真, 無論劇本, 配樂, 燈光, 服裝, 音響, 招呼賓客, 場刊......等等都睇得出佢地真係落左好多好多心機, 而中學既學生亦好照顧小學既學生, 係facebook見到佢地既照片真係好開心打成一遍好似大家庭咁.  我囡囡都係獨女, smc可以比到佢同大哥哥大姐姐一齊成長既經歷.

原帖由 Lynn 於 10-10-22 10:58 發表
我的女也正就讀SMC,也是我們比較過後的決定,我覺得還不錯! 可能也可以說自己讚自己花香!

當初的決定也包括了對其他家長的反應,在BK 或是我曾去校外看過,和我家校車等車的媽媽和工人姐姐談過,當然有些抱怨一些學校行 ...

cpcog

For me, I don't need my girl to go to a top school with excellent academic result. I prefer the school offering a happy learning attitude and strong language environment. That's why I only choose the schools with similar faith.
I truely believe that some parents would expect other things from the primary schools. Everyone has different choice and preference. We should respect that.

大頭mama

[Iam a SMC S1secondary school parent,
my daughter is a new comer , I can tell you that this year have 65 students came from their own primary school, if secondary school is not good, how can so many students choose their own secondary school?

I agree that the primary school student 's English standard are very high, but I also believe that the Secondary School is improving, that why I choose this school for my children

My daughter is very happy studying in this school, she like this school very much and I also very satisfy with this school, I think I choose the right school for my daughter.


Some parent will select other band 1 or top DSS for secondary place not SMC.
I know some p6 kid promted to other top band 1 or top DSS by self.

I hope secondary is improved as primary secondary in co ... [/quote]

[ 本帖最後由 大頭mama 於 10-10-23 01:29 編輯 ]

sampapa

Due to this 2 years, new comer of SMCE secondary is selected by interview, not lucky draw kid.
I think that school will select suitable student as primary section.
I hope quality of secondary improved as primary.
Good English is not labelled as GOOD school, just equipped basic skill for future learning & good communication with different country people.
I select SMC due to good manner of  student, who I saw on the street.
Provide full english enviroment for student daily.
小學部P1的英文默書是每兩周讀默20個生寫，而且比一般中文小學還淺。
現在P2都是20個生寫。
最近一次默下列生寫 party, people,house,candy,night,ghost,children,moon,front...,夠簡單容易嗎？
他們的英文程度是每曰八小時從環境浸出來，不是只有每周8堂英語學。
老師雖然新或小經驗，但用心及有愛心，他們都注重學生品行，如有問題壹定跟進。
我有次在學校跟校長談話，每年都有許多人申請，你們是如何選擇？
她說是品徳，誠懇，家長支援，反而超高學術或無自信心或基本禮貌很定不要。
他們是讀小學,不是中學或大學,知識學校會教，但品德要家長支援.
但中文默書跟其他中小一樣多，但是不用背默。
我希望不是SMC的家長，不要只說smc英文有幾好，學校都有在其它科努力。

sampapa

SMC 只是一所普通學校，絕不可跟其他百年名校相比。我選SMC因孩子愉快學習及父母可以小跟進壓力。
SMC要求學生多看課外書，不論是中文，英文，或其他語文。
到現在SMC都能做到，只是文職支援令人怒氣.
我兒也恨喜歡上課，到現在都沒有上任何補習班。

sampapa

I hope non SMC parent understanding, We never say that "SMC is top DSS or  famous school or 學術程度有幾高，我地冇話自己高過謀謀學校".
we say SMC is 健康、活潑、開心愉快學習的返學, less pressure, less copy-write job.
我地的小朋友係學校是好開心愉快學習的，就我囝他病了都希望能返學，那就係我地家長想見到的學校！
I give up other top & famous DSS offer, I hope my kid is 開心愉快學習 and not much pressure.
On the same time, any parent can say anything here, but 彼此尊重不好嗎?
I hope all is real and solid, do not use your ear as your eye.
Please believe your eye, if any understanding or question, you can ask school by email. They will reply by senior staff not clerk.
Finally, Do not say SMC is selling of "English" only, SMC sells all round education.

不平明

幸好好多人都話唔讀. 尤其果d唔like呢間學校既nice 家長.