對york感覺由天跌左落地 !!

kalau

My son is studying their N1 preparation class for a few months and I'm very happy with his progress and he is also very happy at school.

At first, I also have doubts as to whether this is a good school too because there's a lot of negative comments in BK. And I agree their admin was unclear & uncertain. I read in BK there's a N1 preparation class for big kids before x'mas so I call them up to see if my son can study there. They replied 'yes' and require me to pay within a few days but they didn't give me details on what I was paying!! And they couldn't even tell me which campus he will be studying but school will start in about 2 wks?! When I visited the school, the local teacher said 'One Two Free' to the kids in the playground. I didn't like the English accents and I was worried!! And my husband thinks the principal is the worst speaker of all the kinders. She was only saying all the good things like memorizing a script but couldn't answer any questions directly. Anyways, we still went ahead because one of the 幼稚園面試培訓班 teacher said York is good in English and they teach a lot of things and it's best kids can learn the extra-curriculum in school (in the same environment).


It's been a few months and I can see my son has learnt a lot of things and everyday he'll imitate what the native English teacher has taught him. Frankly, I think my English may be better than some of the local teachers there, but their English is still sufficient to teach these kids. As for misc fees, I only paid once at the beginning of the semester and no other fees. I personally think York is a good school and I heard other parents saying the same thing when we pick up our child.

kalau

All teachers are very loving and caring and every teacher knows each students name!! Everyday when we pick up the child, the teacher will tell you his performance briefly. The teachers are free to talk to you if want to talk in more details. I personally don't see it is as 'negative' as people say. And most important thing, my son is happy and he is learning from school!

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-5-13 18:33 發表
How about the local and NET teacher ? Are they caring for kids ? Will the school always talk to the parent about the progress of the kid ? I can see Mrs Fung has a great expectation on York Kids accor ...

PEGGYP

希望呢度有多d真正讀緊york既家長發表一下意見....唔好成日比d無係york讀過(可能只係收左, 而最后無讀)既家長去批評間學校, 我覺得咁樣對學校好唔公平.

其實, 我覺得york雖然收費多, 因為佢地搞既活動相對比較多元化同"有聲有色", 實在令我地家長覺得滿意...
其實我都係一個全職媽媽，我用咁多時間去發表我既意見，係想比多ｄ人知道我地ｄ真正用家對ｙｏｒｋ既意見，可以去真正了解呢間學校，　有時，見到ｄ留言話ｙｏｒｋ好多收費　（試問邊一間私校開學前可以唔使比雜費，書簿費，　茶點費同校服費，而可能享受以上ｏｆｆｅｒｓ），話我知，等我今年同細佬報讀）．．．．

再講，　一間學校肯搞咁多活動比小朋友參與，小朋友可以學習到好多書本以外既知識，我覺得唔錯呀，　我個仔舊年ｘ’ｍａｓ上台表現，雖然短短幾分鐘，已經見到學校用左唔少心機同佢地彩排同服飾打扮．．．當時我同我老公都”板爛手板”

來緊，　我個小朋友會升ｋ２喇，希望多ｄ家長可以享一下

原帖由 kalau 於 10-5-13 20:47 發表
All teachers are very loving and caring and every teacher knows each students name!! Everyday when we pick up the child, the teacher will tell you his performance briefly. The teachers are free to tal ...

ck07hk

多謝咁多位家長比左咁多正面既意見我地呀, 其實我有朋友既小朋友讀緊九龍塘其他出名既幼稚園.. 好似 KM 咁, 又係咩都係要比錢.. 不過無咩家長投訴... 唔知點解.. York就係咁惹火... 我諗真係除左行政上出左亂子外, 其實問題都唔大啦, 大家開開心心咁讀啦, 唔好再諗負面野, 佢地無收我個女讀國際班, 我都無嬲, 一切都係上天安排, 我地又何需執著?? 而且說到低, York 都係好學校, 大家比心機呀!

fion_yinyin

多謝你地york真正用家的意見。
但真係唔知點解york好商業化同行政混亂已深入民心，希望york既管理層檢討一下

Carman1112

其實有邊間私校唔商業化？私校無政府津貼、無贊助，如果佢地唔搵錢, 點樣生存呢？

我唔介意佢地收錢, 不過最緊要係俾我知道, 我 d 錢要黎做 d 什麼？會有什麼回報？正如我俾千幾蚊雜費, 你都要俾返張 list 我睇, 等我知道我 d 錢要黎買左什麼, 清清楚楚, 咁我就覺得 ok。

我個囡黎緊會讀am主流班, 希望佢同其他小朋友都可以讀得開開心心, 期待8月11日既開學。

vivicicimimi

講得啱！有邊間私人幼稚園唔商業化呀！間間都係咩都收$$$嫁啦！你話York行政亂，HKPS d行政咪一鬼樣亂，但係你又鍾意佢地D教學呀！不過係無人講啫！:;pppp:

poon小朋友

雖然我個小朋友會係今年先入讀york(國際班)但我已在bb一歲時就想他入讀...開心見到有york mami出嚟講吓...

kalau

There are 2 local teachers for his N1 preparation class with 23 kids. I'm not sure it'll be the same for K1 because my son only in prep class.

The school said the main difference between main stream and int'l is:

Main stream have 2 local teachers +  25min native english lesson daily + mandarine (I don't know how many times and how many min/wk)

Int'l have 1 native teacher + 1 local teacher + 25mins of mandarine daily.

I was told the Cambridge course is around $190/hr and needs ~20 hrs/semester x 3 semester for the K2 exam. Maybe they do charge cheaper outside (I really don't know) but I know for sure the school will support this and they do teach similar things in class which reinforce their learning and memories.  

I personally think if you want your kids to have good english, then York is not a bad choice. Of course, if you have offers from St.Cat, then maybe St.Cat is a cheaper choice.

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-5-16 15:06 發表
Thanks for your help.

How many class teacher in one class ?
What is the main differerence between the main stream and international stream ?

ppsfung

我個女係york讀k.3,快畢業了.
我係K2才比個女插班入讀,因為以前的幼稚園程度較淺,我主要想個女學好英文,所以轉校.
佢讀york明顯英文好咗,而且發音準咗(以前的學校都有外藉教師,也有學phonics,但我覺得york係呢方面做得好d).另外,york的老師也很有經驗和耐性.這2方面確是值得一讚的.

但我不打算給我的下一個仔女讀york,主要是這幾年學費加得太多,我認為現在校長想把學校轉營成高檔國際學校,而把經費加在父母身上.我覺得這幾年費用越來越貴,也出了很多新花款來說服父母比錢.
我覺得學校只是嘗試性質,不能擔保我付出的是否得到回報.
如要我再比更費學費去做白老鼠,我寧可讀那些歷史悠久的國際學校.

fion_yinyin

咁其實有邊d收費我地可以唔洗俾？or考慮清楚至俾？
好等我地準家長可以"聰明地"交錢

PEGGYP

hi,

我就冇係學校買學服, 去左九龍城買, 因為起碼平一半, 而質地同學校一樣....
不過唔係件件都有.....
男仔: 運動套 (夏季)- 有, (冬季)- 無
夏季水手裝- 有, 冬季黃恤衫+灰褲 (有)...
但係所有冷外套(白和灰), 同校褸都無係學校買, 我自己就買左d樓下平平地個d(專賣d返學白底衫, 白襪個d鋪頭).
好涷個時就同佢著件深藍羽x(唔識打)
另外, 我無報到學校既課外活動, 因為學費+校車, 加埋都唔算好抵, 所以無報...
暑假班, 我都無報york, 因為係"祟x"報, 每日3小時, 有校車接送(校外生可以參加), 價錢合理, 課程ok啦, 當去玩下, 學下野(唔好係屋企咁hea)
總括, 其實讀york都可以豐儉由人既, 不過家長就要用多d時間去search資料...

rabbitann

diva0813
你覺得york係一間拜金幼稚園, 你有無實例呀?  如果無的話, 你又憑什麼覺得佢拜金呢??  我真係覺得d家長幾好笑, 甘得閒特意去中傷一間學校, 真係好無聊...

原帖由 diva0813 於 10-5-13 11:43 發表
York是一間拜金的幼稚園,TOO BAD. TOO BAD PRINCIPAL.

mokstick

原帖由 rabbitann 於 10-5-18 13:16 發表
diva0813
你覺得york係一間拜金幼稚園, 你有無實例呀?  如果無的話, 你又憑什麼覺得佢拜金呢??  我真係覺得d家長幾好笑, 甘得閒特意去中傷一間學校, 真係好無聊...

...

算la,把口生係人地到,人地鍾意講咩我地都控制5到,我地自己用家like就得!

brrbaby2007

原帖由 rabbitann 於 10-5-18 13:16 發表
diva0813
你覺得york係一間拜金幼稚園, 你有無實例呀?  如果無的話, 你又憑什麼覺得佢拜金呢??  我真係覺得d家長幾好笑, 甘得閒特意去中傷一間學校, 真係好無聊...

...

其實學校拜金又如何，最緊要用家花左錢覺得值，出來的產好就得啦

rabbitann

mokstick & brrbaby2007

非常同意你們的講法. 原本都不想發表意見, 但係真係忍唔住, 點解d家長可以無聊成甘..

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-5-18 16:49 發表


其實學校拜金又如何，最緊要用家花左錢覺得值，出來的產好就得啦

媽珠

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-5-18 16:49 發表


其實學校拜金又如何，最緊要用家花左錢覺得值，出來的產好就得啦