那間 直資 / 私立 是真正活動教學？

flostangraphy

mind to pm me which english bang 1 school you were?

原帖由 daisy17772 於 14/9/2009 17:23 發表


Well how much a student's academic level is ahead of others I would think it depends on which school she's from in HK and which school that she studies in overseas.  To me, I studied band 1 eng scho ...

G-Ma

一條龍會更有利推行活動教學.

原帖由 ziyi 於 09-9-14 10:57 發表
如果不是一條龍的學校,我都非常同意Avbee的見解,因中學只care about公開考試成績去吸引人申請,亦很難去了解由幾十間不同小學來的學生程度

所以如果選擇活動教學的學校,必須選擇一條龍那些,因中小學會有溝通了解. 這 ...

myrchan

傳統學生靠老師筆記過日，硬記知識，無消化，到大學做論文時要自己諗題目，就知驚。填鴨期太長，花太多時間做得益不大的學習，連事倍功半都未必有。

學術成績可令青年人工作生涯頭一步順利一點，但往後日子中，分析及表達能力才是最佳武器。我還是傾向為孩子長遠着想，即使這樣可能會令孩子頭一步較艱難。

原帖由 daisy17772 於 09-9-14 17:23 發表

the academic level for math was more ahead in lower grade, then the gap gradually diminished at higher grade. ... there were a lot more subjects, like international studies, which required students to have global perspectives, come up with analysis and opinions, and to be able to make presentation in English.  From this aspect, I really don't see HK students have major advantages.

daisy17772

原帖由 Reximom 於 09-9-15 11:58 發表


No, 真道個邊d家長實牙實齒話, 每個真道學生都會考哂兩個公開試, IBD與及新高中會考, 請問各位, is it possible?

Anyone knows which year that Logos will have their first batch of students attempting IB?

fongyuen

原帖由 Reximom 於 09-9-15 11:58 發表


No, 真道個邊d家長實牙實齒話, 每個真道學生都會考哂兩個公開試, IBD與及新高中會考, 請問各位, is it possible?

請問阿Reximom女士你期望咩答案？

G-Ma

好同意, 係大學及工作環境下, 懂得"了解, 消化, 融匯, 再表達自己意見" 一定係會著數d, 絕對係一生受用.

原帖由 myrchan 於 09-9-15 04:19 發表
傳統學生靠老師筆記過日，硬記知識，無消化，到大學做論文時要自己諗題目，就知驚。填鴨期太長，花太多時間做得益不大的學習，連事倍功半都未必有。

學術成績可令青年人工作生涯頭一步順利一點，但往後日子中，分析及表達能力才是最 ...

GenevieveTNL

I totally agree your point.  

As my company had some junior staff with good acadamic marks, they always required "step-by-step & detailed" instructions.  Otherwise, the task couldn't be completed.

However, it's difficult to find a school which really can provide such environment.

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-9-15 13:46 發表
好同意, 係大學及工作環境下, 懂得"了解, 消化, 融匯, 再表達自己意見" 一定係會著數d, 絕對係一生受用.

ziyi

算啦,每一個人都有他的考慮,覺得現行ok,覺得政府相唔過

but I still believe 活動教學 is best for my girl and also is continue basis study instead of 6 years primary school only.

littlefaith

原帖由 ziyi 於 09-9-15 14:48 發表
算啦,每一個人都有他的考慮,覺得現行ok,覺得政府相唔過

but I still believe 活動教學 is best for my girl and also is continue basis study instead of 6 years primary school only. ...

ziyi,

好有同感﹗

世界在變，「成績代表一切」已不合時宜。

其實，身為家長，最緊要係揀一間適合自己仔女嘅學校。學校業績 (通常指會考成績、入U率) 好又如何？如果仔女根本讀得唔開心，學校根本唔啱仔女個type，你夾硬要佢讀盞你又慘、佢又慘。

自問大女唔係嗰種適合「填鴨式」教育嘅小朋友，咁我冇理由特登揀「填鴨」學校嚟令大女受苦。

flostangraphy

hi,
我大仔都唔係D坐定定聽書既細路仔...
有冇好學校介紹?
thanks in advance!

原帖由 littlefaith 於 15/9/2009 15:40 發表


ziyi,

好有同感﹗

世界在變，「成績代表一切」已不合時宜。

其實，身為家長，最緊要係揀一間適合自己仔女嘅學校。學校業績 (通常指會考成績、入U率) 好又如何？如果仔女根本讀得唔開心，學校根本唔啱仔女個type，你夾硬要佢讀 ...

ziyi

港同 - 唯一擔心是校長會不會長做,因這個是開校以來第3個,所謂蛇無頭不行,主科雙老師制,照顧學生較好
真道 - 聽聞課堂上學生過份自由,但行IB,對資優生支援好
EC - 很難說,沒有上述問題,也沒有太特出的,而且學費較平
St. Margaret - 我不清楚,要問G-Ma

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-15 16:03 發表
hi,
我大仔都唔係D坐定定聽書既細路仔...
有冇好學校介紹?
thanks in advance!

cherubic

I agree with you and ziyi.  

As I said before, these schools are quite new and many people will not consider it due to a lack of track record.  In fact, more parents prefer traditional schools because they only trust the exam results.  It seems that you are not walking on the typical path.  Therefore, you should have a high EQ and should trust the school you have chosen.

One day, my neightbour said, "It seems that your son is quite good, why not let him study in those 'normal' schools"  The 'normal' schools they refer to are those band 1 or 2 traditional schools.

What a joke!

Charlotte_mom

我都聽過有人話, 小朋友正正常常, 點解唔揀間好既學校
come on! 辦學既, 教學既, 在學既, 交學費既, 都擺左好多心機時間落去, 俾d credit好唔好
況且邊個話活動教學=學唔到野先

原帖由 cherubic 於 09-9-15 04:59 PM 發表
I agree with you and ziyi.  

As I said before, these schools are quite new and many people will not consider it due to a lack of track record.  In fact, more parents prefer traditional schools becaus ...

Charlotte_mom

係, 呢個係港同第3個校長, 我都希望黎梗會穩定d, 令人放心既係辦學7年, 好多制度, 教材等都setup左, 暫時睇交接順利
而且港同有樣野我自己好鐘意, 就係除左拔尖, 仲對跟唔上既學生, 情緒行為有問題學生, 一樣支援, 真係有補底, 唔係照肺唔係放棄, 而且社工係合約制, 每日都o係學校, 呢d唔係間間學校都做到

原帖由 ziyi 於 09-9-15 04:57 PM 發表
港同 - 唯一擔心是校長會不會長做,因這個是開校以來第3個,所謂蛇無頭不行,主科雙老師制,照顧學生較好
真道 - 聽聞課堂上學生過份自由,但行IB,對資優生支援好
EC - 很難說,沒有上述問題,也沒有太特出的,而且學費較平
...

ziyi

除了換了幾任校長外,真的找不出唔好的地方

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-15 20:19 發表
係, 呢個係港同第3個校長, 我都希望黎梗會穩定d, 令人放心既係辦學7年, 好多制度, 教材等都setup左, 暫時睇交接順利
而且港同有樣野我自己好鐘意, 就係除左拔尖, 仲對跟唔上既學生, 情緒行為有問題學生, 一樣支援,  ...

G-Ma

smc算係半活動半傳統, 因為完全活動有時課堂好易太失控, 所以鬆緊要得宜, 小朋友可以讀得愉快之餘亦可以守紀律.

原帖由 ziyi 於 09-9-15 16:57 發表
港同 - 唯一擔心是校長會不會長做,因這個是開校以來第3個,所謂蛇無頭不行,主科雙老師制,照顧學生較好
真道 - 聽聞課堂上學生過份自由,但行IB,對資優生支援好
EC - 很難說,沒有上述問題,也沒有太特出的,而且學費較平
...

G-Ma

其實我覺得直資就好似一門生意咁, 有供有求, 如果你出品既產品有問題亦唔會有人來買, 所以有得幾年運作, 家長們仍然肯比錢入去讀, 無轉校, 咁間學校都唔會係太差.

讀咩學校都唔可以淨係靠哂學校, 家長輔導都好重要, 宜家d家長個個都咁醒目, 間學校有咩唔對路仲唔轉校咩.

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-15 20:12 發表
我都聽過有人話, 小朋友正正常常, 點解唔揀間好既學校
come on! 辦學既, 教學既, 在學既, 交學費既, 都擺左好多心機時間落去, 俾d credit好唔好
況且邊個話活動教學=學唔到野先
...

flostangraphy

有...離我地屋企有d遠....

原帖由 ziyi 於 15/9/2009 20:57 發表
除了換了幾任校長外,真的找不出唔好的地方