【IB放榜】IB狀元榜 聖保羅男女囊括4名IB狀元 男拔誕3狀元

F15X5

如果睇香港成績，好像只有DBS同埋SPCC可以keep到成績，其他IS學校44/45數量都比過往少，唔知係唔係成績好過批收到PG同大學Offer之後就Hea住做IA (因為比重少); 集中等到考試先去盡,所以這班deadline Fighter会比預期低好多....

hellokids

That’s true that some (perhaps not many) students’ results have been upgraded, and some students’ results have been downgraded.  Many students achieved a good grade at their IA but still got their final result downgraded.  It is due to the deficiency of the algorithm system that IB used for this “no exam” exam.  All in all, the grades assigned to the students this time are not truly their grades.  They don’t reflect the individual’s effort and capability.
http://positivelysemidefinite.com/2020/06/160k-students.html?fbclid=IwAR3lXPHP2PgiiKkANWVlUKI0Y4sztgr9qWkim0KGTspUOeym5otLqAADuB8

babieblue

lui 發表於 20-7-12 08:54
其實佢唔係用coursework .佢把IA 同TOK /EE由examiner grade .由放大了IA的比重。以往是20-% of total sco ...

請問你講reddit 個d case係hk 定係外國發生？thanks

lui

babieblue 發表於 20-7-12 19:22
請問你講reddit 個d case係hk 定係外國發生？thanks

不知道，因為大家冇quote country

lui

F15X5 發表於 20-7-12 12:25
如果睇香港成績，好像只有DBS同埋SPCC可以keep到成績，其他IS學校44/45數量都比過往少，唔知係唔係成績好過 ...

IA大部分2019已完成，估計唔會影響學生hea

F15X5

計分方法真係不能反映學生嘅能力，我孩子學校最叻嗰幾個，基本上九成跌一至兩分

Kingcow101

Moonlight819 發表於 20-7-10 09:08
分享CDNIS 今年的IB result, 因不懂在這裡上載相片，只好copy and paste.

-Nine students scored 43 or 44 ...

邊度搵到資料？

muimui2

雖然我無認真研究今年IB 評分因取消考試嘅影響係點，但可以想像到對一啲track record 一般或改善中嘅學校唔公平，因過往成績不及其他一向標青嘅學校好，而影響今屆考生嘅成績。

meimeimandy

lui 發表於 20-7-12 08:54
其實佢唔係用coursework .佢把IA 同TOK /EE由examiner grade .由放大了IA的比重。以往是20-% of total sco ...

呢一代嘅小朋友真係慘要經歷咁多佢哋控制唔到嘅嘢

lui

差一兩分miss 在uk offer 都可以，多d真係冇左。我看小朋友d post 也心流眼淚

hellokids

Yes, those students with their final grades automatically downgraded by the IB special algorithm and missed their uni offers are so poor.  IBO owes them an explanation.  They should at least make it transparent of how their automatic grading process works.
Here are only a few stories:

https://www.wired.com/story/algorithm-set-students-grades-altered-futures/amp

cpmummy

lui 發表於 20-7-12 08:54
其實佢唔係用coursework .佢把IA 同TOK /EE由examiner grade .由放大了IA的比重。以往是20-% of total sco ...

其實真係完全唔知佢哋點計，我見原本好叻，好勤力果一批居然拿不到45，當中已收Oxford 和Cambridge offer的，都跌1-3分，反而平時只中上升了grade

Reddit的case真係慘

poonseelai

cpmummy 發表於 20-7-13 19:19
其實真係完全唔知佢哋點計，我見原本好叻，好勤力果一批居然拿不到45，當中已收Oxford 和Cambridge offer ...

oxford typical offer 係38/45, 如果PG 係45, 最後跌 1 - 3 分都入到嘅，但唔開心總會有

SISian

好奇一問，學校平均IB成績計算會否包括不合格同學呢？
原因我朋友讀果間今年IB話有突破考到好成績，我入佢學校網站睇，拎走晒所有唔合格學生才計算，其他學校係咪都係咁計？

poonseelai

SISian 發表於 20-7-21 10:54
好奇一問，學校平均IB成績計算會否包括不合格同學呢？
原因我朋友讀果間今年IB話有突破考到好成績，我入佢 ...

Managed to check IBO data:
IBO average diploma point: 29.92 includes results of students not awarded the diploma.  Page 5 shows the number of students of each grade

https://www.ibo.org/contentassets/bc850970f4e54b87828f83c7976a4db6/dp-statistical-bulletin-may-2020-en.pdf

F15X5

今年44/45全球只有559（0.83%）人，比較2019 的803（1.19%）人少好多；如果只是看45分，今年45分只有141， 係自然只2014年新低，2017/18/19分別278/259/275）； 看來今天評核的方式可能對成績好那一批不利。

SISian

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

唔該晒，照咁睇就應該計埋唔合格先公平比較，學校冇理由唔知掛

poonseelai

SISian 發表於 20-7-21 13:52
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

唔該晒，照咁睇就應該計埋唔合格先公平比較，學校冇理由唔知掛 ...

唔會唔知嘅，如果quote ibo overall average point 作比較，應該用番相同 basis, 香港ib schools 差不多 100%取得 diploma。事實上，未能取得 diploma 未必低分，你睇番ibo report page 5, 全球19個取32分都取不到diploma, 除了要總分24分，仲有其他分數要求，例如3科HL不能少過12分

jamhappybobo

chickchick 發表於 20-7-9 11:08
又可能轉去其他IS呢, 未必係差先走/因出國而走

CKY呢幾年害慘好多學生，有興趣自己search吓資料就知點解最後咁少人考IB

poonseelai

jamhappybobo 發表於 20-7-29 17:32
CKY呢幾年害慘好多學生，有興趣自己search吓資料就知點解最後咁少人考IB

any link?